Table 2.
I4.0 Key Performance Indicators chosen for the study through literature
| Code | KPIs for I4.0 implementation Risks prioritization | Description | Literature support |
|---|---|---|---|
| P1 | Decentralization | The distributed delegation of authorities, facilities, and cyber-physical systems to execute decisions independently with minimal human intervention | Mittal et al. (2019), Morgan et al. (2021) |
| P2 | Integrity | The trustworthiness of the data sources and active resources, compliant with I4.0 standards and procedures is defined as the ability to confirm the accuracy and reliability of the sourced information | Vaidya et al. (2018), Corallo et al. (2020) |
| P3 | Availability | It describes the access to the information by the right person at the right time without compromising safety and security | Birkel et al. (2019), Corallo et al. (2020) |
| P4 | Cost | Cost constitutes the monetary investment in infrastructure development, training, software hardware, technical support, maintenance, service, sensors, networking, and upskilling of the workforce | Mittal et al. (2018), Deloitte (2019), Morgan et al. (2021) |
| P5 | Interoperability | The ability of a system to interconnect, integrate, coordinate, and collaborate in a self-organized mode without any turbulence | Qin et al. (2016), Ibarra et al. (2018), Mittal et al. (2019), Sun et al. (2020) |
| P6 | Virtualization | A simulated platform of a physical system developed using the internet cloud to help a user access a physical system’s characteristics in a virtual environment | Hermann et al. (2016), Siltori et al. (2021) |
| P7 | Adaptability | It is the ability of the system to accommodate, upgrade, and respond to changes in the business environment through a data-driven decision-making process | Bartodziej (2017), Sriram and Vinodh (2020), Sony and Aithal (2020) |
| P8 | Modularity | It is the approach of creating reusable building blocks/coupling or decoupling modules to facilitate production processes, which helps realign and reorganize the production lines as per requirements | Safar et al. (2018), Siltori et al. (2021), Ghobakhloo and Iranmanesh (2021) |
| P9 | Connectivity | It reflects the high-bandwidth internet network, enhancing communication, enabling the effective exchange of data, and facilitating collaboration among all connected devices | Pedone and Mezgár (2018), Castro‐martin et al. (2021) |
| P10 | Service orientation | It is the ability of the company to customize the product based on the customer’s expectations. This requires efficient communication between people and intelligent devices to capture customer inputs | Hermann et al. (2016), Kozak et al. (2018), Pedone and Mezgár (2018) |
| P11 | IT infrastructure | It comprises the devices, networking, machines, hardware, and software that provides seamless and high-speed connectivity needed to support I4.0 requirements, i.e., self-organizing, self-controlling devices IoT, CPS, Software, hardware, etc | Lee et al. (2017), Schuh et al. (2020), Habibi Rad et al. (2021) |
| P12 | Prediction capabilities | It is the ability of the connected devices, hardware, software, and IT infrastructure based on the predefined criteria to interpret, analyze, forecast, and decisions making in real-time | Colli et al. (2019), Habibi Rad et al. (2021) |
| P13 | Flexibility | It can be defined as the degree to handle agility to accommodate last-minute changes. It is the measure of the speed to respond to the changing demand and product adaptation | VanBoskirk (2016), Mittal et al. (2018), Fragapane et al. (2020), Salunkhe and Fast-Berglund (2020) |
| P14 | Quality |
It is the measure of efficiency and effectiveness of resource utilization in manufacturing products and services. Adherence to the set standards is ensured by real-time data acquisition, processing, analytics through intensive network connectivity and infrastructure support of IoT devices BDA, CPS, AI, IoT, Cloud uses, VR, AR, etc. The cost of information is always affected by the quality of the network, integration, and collaboration across the system |
Bibby and Dehe (2018), Schumacher et al. (2019), Salunkhe and Fast-Berglund (2020) |
| P15 | Information security | It is described as maintaining the privacy and safety of the business information and data from any theft or unauthorized sharing. This information access is granted to a few authorized personnel when needed, and the data is stored and edited through standard procedures defined for verification, processing, and validation. The data collected from all the sources in the whole system should be handled securely | Geissbauer et al. (2016), Kagermann, (2015), Culot et al. (2019), Bai et al. (2020) |
| P16 | Capacity to make real-time decisions | The intelligent factory can collect, store, analyze and process information and extract meaningful insights from the collected data to be used for making real-time decisions | Lee et al. (2017), Lu (2017), Cohen et al. (2019), Eslami et al. (2021) |