Table 2.
Author; country | Method | Participants | Indication for PIVC | Intervention | Comparator | PIVC inserter/operator USG and landmark PIVC | Outcomes |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Avelar et al. 17 ; Brazil | Single centre RCT | N = 355; 1 day to 18 years; hospitalised | Admitted to a paediatric surgical unit | Ultrasound | Traditional landmark | Trained nurse | Successful insertion of PIVC on first puncture; catheter dwell time; absence of identification of signs of local intravenous therapy complications |
Benkhadra et al. 18 ; France | Single centre RCT | N = 40; less than 3 years; operating room suite | Induction of anaesthesia | Ultrasound | Traditional landmark | Anaesthetist | First‐time insertion success; overall PIVC insertion success; time to cannulation, total number of punctures and type of catheter used |
Curtis et al. 19 ; Canada | Single centre RCT | N = 418; less than 16 years; emergency department | Required PIVC as part of their treatment | Ultrasound and near infrared light | Traditional landmark | Not stated | First‐attempt PIVC insertion success; number of attempts to successful PIVC placement; time to successful PIVC insertion |
Doniger et al. 20 ; USA | Single centre RCT | N = 50; less than 10 years; emergency department | Required PIVC as part of their treatment | Ultrasound | Traditional landmark | Emergency department nurse or physician | Number of attempts; overall PIVC insertion success; overall procedure time; number of needle redirections and the necessity for alternative methods of vascular access |
Hanada et al. 21 ; USA | Single centre RCT | N = 102; weighing greater than or equal to 3 kg and aged less than 4 years; operating room suite | Maintenance of anaesthesia | Ultrasound | Traditional landmark | Anaesthetist | First‐attempt insertion success; success rate of PIVC insertion within 10 min |
PIVC, paediatric peripheral intravenous catheter; RCT, randomised controlled trial.