Skip to main content
. 2022 Jul 20;14(7):1577. doi: 10.3390/v14071577

Table 2.

Precision and risk of bias assessment for mosquito-borne virus prevalence measures in Egypt.

Virus Author, Year Region/City/Governorate Species Sampling Approach Risk of Bias Assessment Precision Ref.
Sampling Assay
DENV Hussen, 2020 Upper Egypt (Sohag and Assiut) Human
Camel
MSCS
MSCS
Low High Low [34]
DENV, SINV, WNV Mohammed, 1970 Alexandria Human Conv. High High High [26]
DENV, SINV,
WNV
Darwish, 1975 Throughout Egypt Human CS Low Low High [33]
RVFV Mroz, 2017 Nile Delta Cattle MSCS Low Low High [11]
Mroz, 2017 Throughout Egypt Different livestock MSCS Low Low High [10]
El-Bahgy, 2018 From different herds in Egypt and originated from Sudan Camel MSCS Low High High [53]
Meegan, 1979 Qalyoubiya, Sharqiya, Giza Human Conv. High Low Low [36]
Abdel-Rahim, 1999 Aswan and Assiut Sheep
Cattle
Conv.
Conv.
High
High
Low
Low
Low
Low
[45]
Imam, 1979 Qalyoubiya, Sharqiya, Giza, Menia, Aswan, Sohag, Cairo Different animals Conv. High Low High [35]
Hanafi, 2011 Aswan, Beni Suef, Behera, Cairo, Daqahliya,
Kafr El-Sheikh, Qalyoubiya, Qena, and Sharqiya
Human Conv. High Low High [50]
Kafr El-Sheikh Different livestock Cluster Low High High
Kafr El-Sheikh Mosquito Cluster Low Low High
Youssef, 2001 Behera
Alexandria
Menia
Rat Cluster Low High High [48]
Youssef, 2002 Behera
Alexandria
Menia
Rat Cluster Low Low High [49]
Niklasson, 1979 Swedish soldiers serving in Egypt Human Cluster Low High High [37]
Mahmoud, 2021 Aswan, Qena, and Luxor Different livestock Cluster Low High Low [9]
Horton, 2014 Giza (originated from governorates throughout Egypt) Different livestock Cluster Low High High [52]
Turkistany, 2001 Slaughterhouse personnel in Makkah from Egypt Human Cluster Low High Low [46]
Abu-Elyazeed, 1996 Behera, Beni Suef, Cairo, Damietta, Daqahliya, Gharbiya, Giza, North Sinai, Ismailia, Kafr El-Sheikh, Menoufiya, Port Said, Qalyoubiya, Sharqiya, South Sinai Human Cluster Low High High [42]
Youssef, 2009 Alexandria Pig
Human
Cluster
Cluster
Low
Low
High
High
High
Low
[51]
Allam, 1986 Nile Delta Sheep Cluster Low Low High [38]
Arthur, 1993 Aswan Different livestock Conv. High Low Low [44]
Botros, 1988 Daqahliya Sheep Cluster Low Low High [39]
Centers for Disease Control & Prevention (CDC), 1994 Aswan Human Cluster Low High High [43]
RVFV, SINV El-Esnawy, 2001 NA Human Cluster Low High High [47]
RVFV, WNV, CHIKV Darwish, 1987 Giza Human Conv. High Low Low [24]
RVFV, WNV Corwin, 1992 Sharqiya Human MSCS Low High High [40]
RVFV, WNV Corwin, 1993 Nile River Valley Human Random Low High High [41]
SINV, WNV Turell, 2002 Aswan Mosquitoes Random Low Low High [56]
WNV Selim, 2020 Qalyoubiya, Menoufia, Kafr El-Sheikh, Gharbia Horse Random Low Low High [60]
Selim, 2020 Qalyoubiya, Menoufia, Kafr El-Sheikh, Gharbia Different livestock Random Low High High [59]
Soliman, 2010 Upper Egypt (Qena), Middle Egypt (Fayoum), Lower Egypt (Sharqiya), North Sinai (Al-Areesh), South Sinai (Nuweiba) Human Random Low High High [57]
Youssef, 2017 Blood donors from the blood bank of Ain Shams University Hospitals Human Random Low Low High [58]
Schmidt, 1964 Kafr El-Sheikh Tick MSCS High Low High [55]
Schmidt, 1963 Upper and Lower Egypt Equine Random Low Low High [54]

Risk of bias (ROB) assessment was considered low when (i) sampling was based on random or cluster selection and (ii) measures included viral neutralization testing or biological assays (i.e., virus isolation or RT-PCR). ROB was considered high for (i) acute infection studies or studies on sera or tissues taken from the affected herds, or (ii) measures conducted by immunological assays. Studies were considered to have a high precision if the number of individuals tested was ≥100 for humans and animals and ≥1000 for vectors. Abbreviations: CHIKV: Chikungunya virus; Conv: convenience sampling; CS: cluster sampling; DENV: dengue virus; MSCS: multi-stage cluster sampling; Ref: reference; RVFV: Rift Valley fever virus; SINV: Sindbis virus; WNV: West Nile virus.