Skip to main content
. 2022 Jul 25;12(7):e060214. doi: 10.1136/bmjopen-2021-060214

Table 1.

Summary of study characteristics

Author(s) of Corresponding Study(s) Intervention/programme name Research design Population sample sizes
(pre–post assessment data and mean age and sex)
Participant ethnicity* (postassessment data) Employment status (postassessment data) Reason for referral Duration of Follow-up Referral pathway (Husk et al)8
Crone et al26 Art Lift Uncontrolled Before/after study Preassessment n=157
Postassessment n=84
(mean age=57, SD=15), male n=22, female n=62
NR NR Anxiety and depression 2.5 months Direct Referral from Link Worker in Primary Care
Crone et al27 Uncontrolled Before/after study Preassessment n=818
Postassessment n=651
(mean age=51.9, SD=15.9), male n=142†, female n=509
NR NR Anxiety and depression 2.5 months Direct Referral from Link Worker in Primary Care
Sumner et al28 Uncontrolled Before/after study Preassessment n=547
Postassessment n=418
(mean age=49.7, SD=15.5), male n=83†, female n=335
NR In‡ n=76
Out§ n=176
Retired n=103
Anxiety and depression 2.5 months Direct Referral from Link Worker in Primary Care
Sumner et al29 Uncontrolled Before/after study Preassessment n=245
Postassessment n=110
(mean age=51.3, SD=15.9), male n=16†, female n=94
NR In‡ n=22
Out§ n=86
Retired n=NR
Unknown n=2
Anxiety and depression 2 months Direct Referral from Link Worker in Primary Care
van de Venter et al30 Art Shine Uncontrolled Before/after study Preassessment n=NR
Postassessment n=44
(mean age=43, SD=NR), male n=7, female n=36, other n=1
‘White British’ n=29 (66%)
‘Black and minority ethnic’ n=9 (21%)
Unknown n=6
NR Depression and social isolation 5 months Direct Referral from Primary Care
Foster et al31 British Red Cross: Connecting Communities Uncontrolled Before/after study Preassessment n=NR
Postassessment n=2250
(mean age=65.6, SD=18.8), male n=702, female n=1426, other n=122
‘White British’ n=1,313 (58%)
‘Not White British’ n=499 (22%)
Unknown n=438
NR Loneliness 3 months Link Worker Model
Roberts and Windl32 Cadwyn Mon Uncontrolled Before/after study Preassessment n=182
Postassessment n=120
(mean age=76.7, SD=NR), male n=22, female n=98, other n=1
NR NR Loneliness and social isolation 3.75 months Link Worker Model
Afuwape et al33 Cares of Life Project Randomised controlled trial n=16 Intervention group
Preassessment n=20
Postassessment n=16 (mean age=43.6, SD=7.7) male n=NR, female n=NR


n=16 Comparison group
Preassessment n=20
Postassessment n=16
(mean age=32.6, SD=11.0) male n=NR, female n=NR
‘All participants were of Black African Origin or Black Caribbean Origin’ n=32 NR Anxiety and depression 3 months Direct referral from multiple Sectors¶
Morton et al34 Fife Social Prescribing (Mood Café) Uncontrolled Before/after study Preassessment n=174
Postassessment n=136
(mean age=52, SD=11), male n=37, female n=99†
NR NR Anxiety and depression NR Link Worker Model
Thomson et al35 GROW: Art, Park and Well-being Uncontrolled Before/after study Preassessment n=20
Postassessment n=20
(mean age=NR), male n=11, female n=9†
NR NR Mental well-being 2.5 months Direct referral from Community and Local Mental Health Services
Pescheny et al36 Luton Social Prescribing Programme Uncontrolled Before/after study Preassessment n=162
Postassessment n=63
(mean age=NR), male n=23, female n=40
NR In‡ n=22
Out§ n=41
Mild to moderate mental health issues Dependant on Needs Assessment Link Worker Model
Thomson et al37 Museums on Prescription Uncontrolled Before/after study Preassessment n=NR
Postassessment n=115
(mean age=NR), male n=42†, female n=73
‘White-British’ n=94 (82%)
Other=NR
NR Social isolation 2.5 months Direct Referral from Community Care
Kellezi et al38 Social Cure and Social Prescribing Uncontrolled Before/after study Preassessment n=630
Postassessment n=178 (mean age=55.8, SD=13.8), male=86, female=91, other n=1
NR NR Loneliness 4 months Link Worker Model
Wakefield et al39 Uncontrolled Before/after study Preassessment n=630
Postassessment n=63 (mean age=57.1, SD=15.7), male=32, female=31
NR NR Social isolation and loneliness 9 months Link Worker Model
Jones et al40 Southwest Well-being Programme Uncontrolled Before/after study Preassessment n=841
Postassessment n=687 (mean age=NR), male n=179, female n=357, other n=151
‘White’ n=623 (91%)
‘Black or Minority Ethnic Group’ n=38 (6%)
Unknown n=26
In‡ n=259
Out§ n=198
Retired n=209
Other n=21
Anxiety and depression 3 months Direct Referral from Community Care
Carnes et al41 Unnamed Intervention Matched groups design Survey Study
Intervention Group
Preassessment, n=184
Postassessment, n=65
(mean age=NR)
male=NR, female=NR


Comparison group (matched based on age, GP attendance and diagnosis)
Preassessment, n=302
Postassessment, n=127
Mean age=NR
mMale=NR, female=NR


Analysis of healthcare Resource use
Intervention group, n=377
(Mean age=NR)
male=NR, female=NR


Comparison group (matched based on age, sex, ethnicity and comorbidities), n=7540
Mean age=NR
male=NR, female=NR
Survey Study
Intervention Group
Post-assessment=NR
Comparison group
Preassessment:
White n=170
Non-white n=123
Post-assessment=NR
Analysis of Healthcare Resource use=NR
NR Anxiety and depression 8 months Link Worker Model
Maund et al42 Wetlands for Well-being Uncontrolled Before/after Sstudy Preassessment n=16
Postassessment n=16 (mean age=NR), male=8, female=8
‘White-British’ n=13 (82%)
‘White-Other’ n=3 (19%)
In‡ n=1
Out§ n=10
Retired n=5
Anxiety and depression 1.5 months Link worker model from community referral

*Terminology used by authors.

†Not explicitly reported, calculated by authors.

‡In=in work, education or position of responsibility.

§Out=out of work, education or position of responsibility.

¶Multiple sector—referral from a combination of the following: general practitioner, healthcare professional, community, self-referral, secondary care or social care.

NR, not reported.