Skip to main content
. 2022 Jul 27;17(7):e0268480. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0268480

Table 2. The characteristics of included studies (reports) in the systematic review and meta-analysis.

Author Publication year Country Study design Sample type Cervical cancer cases Healthy controls Cancer stage Cut-off value Test method AUROC
Qiu et al [44] 2020 China Case-control Serum 112 90 stage I-IIA >2 qRT-PCR 0.783*
Ma et al [69] 2019 China Case-control Plasma 97 87 stage I-II NR qRT-PCR 0.677 (0.577–0.776)
Zamani et al [70] 2020 Iran Case-control Tissue 50 46 NR 0.0003284 qRT-PCR 0.856 (0.774–0.938)
Jia et al [71] 2015 China Case-control Serum 123 94 Up to stage III NR qRT-PCR 0.819 (0.762‑0.876)
Ruan et al [72] 2020 China Case-control Serum 68 57 NR 3.855 qRT-PCR 0.723 (0.631–0.815)
Du et al [61] 2020 China Case-control Serum 140 140 stage I-II NR qRT-PCR < 0.7*
Park et al [73] 2017 Korea Case-control Tissue 52 50 stage I-IIA >1.975 qRT-PCR 0.833 (0.753–0.912)
Aftab et al [74] 2021 India prospective Urine 50 50 stage I-IV 1.912 qRT-PCR 0.971 (0.957–0.985)
Aftab et al [74] 2021 India prospective Tissue 40 30 stage I-IV 1.182 qRT-PCR 0.993 (0.975–1.000)
Zhu et al [75] 2018 China Case-control Tissue 25 23 NR NR qRT-PCR 0.871 (0.743–0.950)

NR: Not Reported

*This article was not included in the meta-analysis because only point estimate can be extracted from the article; AUROC: Area under receiver operating characteristics curve