Table 1.
Summary chart of the theoretical approaches toward Self-Regulation analyzed in this paper.
Theory | Year | Discipline | Object of study | Concepts/Paradigm | Motivation types | Applications | Limitations |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1. Social Cognitive Theory | 1997 | Social psychology | Person, context | Self-efficacy, Self-regulation | Intrinsic, extrinsic | Social, educational, clinical | Micro-level analysis |
2. Self-Determination Theory (SDT) | 1985 | Developmental psych/learning | Person, context | SR (Autonomy) vs. ER (Heteronomy) | Introjected motiv /a-motivation/external motivation | Wellbeing/ psychopathology autonomy-competence | Human development process, external regulation = external dys-motivation |
3. Self-Regulated Learning Theory (SRL) | 2001 | Psychology of learning | Person, context | Self-Regulated Learning (SRL) | SR motivation | Learning process | Molar-level processes |
4. SRL vs. ERL Theory (SRL vs. ERL) | 2017 | Instructional psychology | Person x context | SR vs. ER Learning Processes | SRL vs. ERL motivation, regulatory | Teaching and Learning Process | Molar-level processes |
5. SR vs. ER Theory (SR vs. ER) | 2021 | Multiple spheres of psychology | Person x context | SR vs. ER in different contexts | SR x ER Factors | Different contexts | Micro- and molecular level process analysis |