Skip to main content
. 2022 Jul 18;10:938113. doi: 10.3389/fpubh.2022.938113

Table 4.

Quality assessment.

Source Risk of bias Applicability concerns
Patient selection Index test Reference standard Flow and timing Patient selection Index test Reference standard
Was the statistical management adequate? Were the inclusion/exclusion criteria specified? Was the type of study (retrospective or prospective) specified? Were the imaging acquisition protocol and the segmentation method(s) detailed? Was the image processing approach detailed? Was the validation independent (i.e., no internal)? Was the reference standard adequate? Was there an appropriate interval between index test and reference standard?
Chetan et al. (1) Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes No Yes Unclear Yes Yes Unclear
Parmar et al. (2) Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes No Yes Unclear Yes Yes Yes
Sun et al. (3) Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes No Unclear Unclear Yes Yes Yes
Ling et al. (4) Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes No Yes Unclear Yes Yes Yes
Coudray et al. (5) Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Unclear Yes Yes Unclear
Xu et al. (6) Yes No Yes Yes Yes No Unclear Unclear Yes Yes Yes
Baldwin et al. (7) Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes No Yes Unclear Yes Yes Yes
Schroers et al. (8) Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes No Yes Unclear Yes Yes Yes
Wang et al. (9) Yes No Yes Yes No No Unclear Unclear Yes Yes Unclear
Leleu et al. (10) Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Unclear Yes Yes Yes
Ann et al. (11) Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Unclear Unclear Yes Yes Unclear
Cong et al. (12) Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes No Unclear Yes Yes Yes
Botta et al. (13) Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Unclear Yes Yes Unclear
Botta et al. (13) Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Unclear Yes Yes Unclear
Wei et al. (14) Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes No Yes Unclear Yes Yes Yes
Khorrami et al. (15) Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes No Unclear Unclear Yes Yes Yes
Kirienko et al. (16) Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes No Unclear Unclear Yes Yes Unclear
Rossi et al. (17) Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes No Yes Unclear Yes Yes Unclear
Chai et al. (18) Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Unclear Yes Yes Yes
Wang et al. (19) Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes No Unclear Unclear Yes Yes Unclear