Skip to main content
. 2022 Aug 1;17(8):e0272375. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0272375

Table 1. Summary of study and patients’ characteristics.

Author, Year Country Study Design Multicentre? (Y/N) Study Setting Peer-reviewed? (Y/N) Quality Rating COVID-19 Patients, n Male, n (%) Age (SD/IQR) Bacterial Coinfection, n (%) Most common Bacteria, N (%) Antibiotic Use, N (%) Antibiotic Class (most common)
1. Puzniak L, 2021[34] USA Retrospective Cohort Y Hospital Y Good 17003 9026 (53) 61.7 (18) 2889 (16.99) Enterobacterales, 1594 (55.17) 11562 (68) Cephalosporins
2. Wang L, 2020 [35] UK Retrospective Cohort Y Hospital Y Good 1396 903 (65) 67.4 (16.2) 37(2.65) E. Coli, 6 (16.22) 36 (2.58)
3. Michael S, 2020 [36] USA Retrospective Cohort Y Hospital Y Good 73 35 (48) 27 (36.99) NR
4. S. Hughes, 2020 [37] UK Retrospective Cohort Y Hospital Y Good 836 519 (62) 69 (55–81) 27 (3.23) S. aureus, 4 (14.81
5. Contou D, 2020 [38] France Retrospective Cohort N Hospital Y Good 92 73 (79) 61 (55–70) 26 (28.26) S. aureus, 10 (38.46) 39 (42.39) Cephalosporins
6. Cheng, L, 2020 [39] China Retrospective Cohort Y Hospital Y Good 147 85 (58) 36 (24–54) 4 (2.72) 52 (35.37) Cephalosporins
7. Neto A G M,2020 [40] USA Retrospective Cohort N Hospital Y Good 242 123 (51) 66 (14.75) 46 (19.01) E. Coli, 12 (26.09) 162 (66.94) Cephalosporins
8. Lardaro T, 2020 [41] USA Retrospective Cohort Y Hospital Y Good 542 269 (50) 62.8 (16.5) 20 (3.69) S. aureus, 7 (35)
9. Chen S, 2020 [42] China Retrospective Cohort N Hospital Y Good 408 196 (48) 48 (34–60) 25 (6.13) mycoplasma pneumonia, 13 (52) 60 (14.71) NR
10. Baskar V, 2021 [43] UK Retrospective Cohort Y Hospital Y Good 254 164 (65) 59 (49–69) 14 (5.51) S. aureus, 4 (28.57)
11. Russell C D, 2021 [44] UK Prospective Cohort Y Hospital Y Good 48902 28116 (58) 74 (59–84) 318 (0.65) E. Coli, 64 (20.13) 39528 (80.83) Penicillin/B-lactams
12. Lehmann C J,2021 [45] USA Retrospective Cohort N Hospital Y Poor 321 155 (48) 60 (17) 7 (2.18) S. aureus, 2 (28.57) 222 (69.16) NR
13. Vaughn V,2021 [46] USA Retrospective Cohort Y Hospital Y Good 1705 885 (52) 64.7 (53–77) 59 (3.46) 965 (56.6) Cephalosporins
14. Miao Q, 2021 [47] China Retrospective Cohort N Hospital Y Good 323 17 (5.26) Klebsiella pneumonia, 11 (64.71)
15. Karami Z, 2020 [48] Netherlands Retrospective Cohort Y Hospital Y Good 925 591 (64) 70 (59–77) 7 (0.76) S. aureus, 4 (57.14) 556 (60.11) Cephalosporins
16. Garcia-Vidal C, 2021 [49] Spain Retrospective Cohort N Hospital Y Good 989 552 (56) 62 (48–74) 31 (3.13) Streptococcus pneumonia, 12 (38.71) 917 (92.72) Macrolide
17. Crotty M P, 2020 [50] USA Prospective Cohort Y Hospital N Good 289 58.6 (14.4) 25 (8.65) S. aureus, 5 (20) 271 (93.77) NR
18. Wei W, 2020 [51] USA Prospective Cohort N Hospital N Good 147 87 (59) 52 87 (59.18) Cephalosporins
19. Karaba S, 2020 [52] USA Prospective Cohort Y Hospital Y Good 1016 543 (53) 62 (48–74) 53 (5.22) 717 (70.57) NR
20. Martin A, 2020 [53] USA Retrospective Cohort Y Hospital N Good 208 105 (51) 69 (60–80) 24 (11.54) S. aureus, 5 (20.83) 172 (82.69) Cephalosporins
21. Rothe K, 2021 [54] Germany Retrospective Cohort N Hospital Y Good 140 90 (64) 63.5 (17–99) 3 (2.14) 116 (82.86) Penicillin/B-lactams
22. Asmarawati T P, 2020 [55] Indonesia Retrospective Cohort N Hospital Y Good 218 120 (55) 52.45 (14.44) 13 (5.96) NR 164 (75.23) Quinolones