Skip to main content
. 2022 Mar 9;127(3):394–407. doi: 10.1038/s41416-022-01769-8

Table 2.

Main ongoing clinical trials (N = 21) investigating the role of interventional circulating tumour DNA (ctDNA) to drive treatment decision-making in colorectal cancer (CRC) patients according to different clinical settings, suggesting potential future applications and developments.

Study
(Code Identifiers)
Location
Trial design
Status
Estimated enrolment (N pts)
ctDNA analysis
Main characteristics and inclusion criteria
Post-surgical resection with curative intent

PEGASUS

(NCT04259944)

Italy–Spain

Phase IIa

Recruiting

140

LUNAR1 panel

• Resected stage III or T4N0 stage II colon cancer

• ctDNA-guided adjuvant treatment: initially those ctDNA-positive will receive CAPOX while those negative capecitabine monotherapy; following treatment will be tailored on following ctDNA reassessment

OPTIMIZE

(NCT04680260)

Denmark

Randomised Phase II

Not yet recruiting

350

NA

• Radical intended treatment for metastatic CRC with no evidence of further disease

• Clinically eligible for adjuvant chemotherapy

• ctDNA-guided post-surgical treatment

DYNAMIC-II

(ACTRN12615000381 583)

Australia

Phase III

Recruiting

450

NA

• Resected stage II CRC

• Pts will be randomly assigned to ctDNA treatment-guided group or not, and to those ctDNA-positive 5-FU will be given while to ctDNA-negative will be followed up

DYNAMIC-III trial

(ACTRN12617001566325)

Australia

Randomised Phase II/III

1000

NA

• Resected stage III colon cancer

• ctDNA-negative pts in experimental arm will be de-escalated adjuvant treatment strategy and those ctDNA-positive will be escalated adjuvant treatment strategy; control will be treated as per SoC

MEDOCC-CrEATE

(NL6281/NTR6455)

Netherlands

Randomised TwiCs design

Recruiting

1320

NGS PGDx elio panel

• Stage II colon cancer pts without indication for adjuvant treatment according to current guidelines

• ctDNA-positive pts will be offered 8 cycles of adjuvant capecitabine plus oxaliplatin while ctDNA-negative pts and control group will be followed up

COBRA

(NCT04068103 and NRG-GI005)

USA

Phase II/III

Recruiting

1408

LUNAR panel

• Stage IIA resected CRC

• Pts in experimental arm II will receive adjuvant treatment (at investigator choice) if ctDNA-positive and surveillance if ctDNA-negative

IMPROVE-IT

(NCT03748680)

Denmark

Phase II randomised

Recruiting

64

NA

• Stage I or II disease radically resected

• Detectable ctDNA in post-operative plasma sample

• No indication for adjuvant chemotherapy according to DCCG guidelines but standard adjuvant chemotherapy administered if ctDNA-positive

(NCT03436563)

USA

Phase Ib/II

Recruiting

74

NA

• Pts with detectable ctDNA following resection of all known liver metastases will receive treatment with an anti-PD-L1/TGFbetaRII Fusion Protein M7824

• Resected MSS metastatic CRC

ALTAIR

(NCT04457297)

Japan

Phase III

Recruiting

240

Signatera panel

• Pts who undergone radical curative resection of the primary and metastatic tumours

• Pts tested positive for ctDNA but with no evidence of disease at imaging will receive TAS-102 or placebo

VEGA

(jRCT1031200006)

Japan

Phase III

Recruiting

1240

NA

• High‐risk stage II or low‐risk stage III (T1‐3 and N1) CRC, and ctDNA‐negative status at week 4 after surgery

• Randomisation between surgery alone versus adjuvant CAPOX

BESPOKE

(NCT04264702)

USA

NA

Recruiting

2000

Signatera panel

• Resected stage II or III colorectal cancer (CRC)

• Pts may be recommended for adjuvant treatment or observation by their treating clinician

Neoadjuvant setting

SYNCOPE

(NCT04842006)

Finland

Randomised

Not yet recruiting

93

NA

• LARC randomised to receive TNT using capecitabine/oxaliplatin and SCRT vs long course CRT using capecitabine

• ctDNA and organoid-guided adjuvant therapy as experimental arm compared to SoC

• Assessment of MRD after surgery and correlation with prognosis

Metastatic unresectable disease

(NCT03844620)

USA

Phase II

Recruiting

100

NA

• Pts clinically eligible for either regorafenib or trifluridin-tipiracil

• Pts will continue treatment beyond 1st cycle depending on ctDNA results

(NCT04831528)

China

Phase II

Not yet recruiting

100

NA

• Pts must have failed after first-line treatment containing cetuximab

• Individualised second-line targeted therapy based on ctDNA analysis

FOLICOLOR

(NCT04735900)

International

NA

Recruiting

60

NPY Methylation

• Unresectable metastatic disease

• Identification of PD by NPY Methylation in liquid biopsies

• To assess response and progression to first-line FOLFOX/FOLFIRI treatment on liquid biopsy

NCT04509635

China

Phase III

Not yet recruiting

50

NA

RAS wt on ctDNA

• Non-resectable liver metastases candidate to anti-EGFR rechallenge based on ctDNA results

LIBImAb

(NCT04776655)

Italy

Phase III

Not yet recruiting

280

KRAS, NRAS and in BRAFV600 status assessment using the Idylla system (Biocartis)

RAS/BRAF wt on solid tumour biopsy but with RAS mutant at liquid biopsy

• To compare di efficacy of FOLFIRI + Cetuximab or Bevacizumab in tissue wt but liquid mutant RAS mCRC

NCT04224415

China

Phase II

Not yet recruiting

35

RAS/BRAF status assessment

• First-line therapy of FOLFOX/FOLFIRI/FOLFOXIRI + Cetuximab effectively and the PFS is not less than 6 months

• ≥4 months after the last time treated with Cetuximab

RAS/BRAF wt on ctDNA

PARERE

(NCT04787341)

Italy

Phase II

Recruiting

214

IdyllaTM ctKRAS-NRAS-BRAF Mutation Test

RAS and BRAF wt status of primary CRC or related metastasis

RAS and BRAF wt ctDNA at the time of screening

• Previous first-line anti-EGFR-containing therapy with at least a PR or SD ≥ 6 months; ≥4 months elapsed between the end of first-line anti-EGFR administration and screening; ≥1 line of therapy between the end of first-line anti-EGFR administration and screening

NCT04775862

Saudi Arabia

Phase II

Recruiting

60

RAS status assessment

• Baseline must be RAS/BRAF wt on solid tumour tissue

RAS wt on ctDNA

• Tumour burden with <4 organ involvement

NCT03992456

USA

Phase II

Recruiting

120

Guardant360 assay

RAS and BRAF wt on tumour tissue taken from primary or metastatic site

• PD after treatment with an anti-EGFR monoclonal antibody for at least 4 months

• ≥ 90 days from the last anti-EGFR treatment

BRAF, EGFR, ERBB2, RAS, MET wt highest allele frequency reported for any gene mutation <2%

These studies were retrieved through an extensive search performed on ClinicalTrial.gov in October 2021. The Medical Subject Headings terms used were (“Colo-rectal Cancer” as condition/disease) and (“circulating tumor dna” as other terms).

ctDNA circulating tumour DNA, N number, pts patients, NA not available, CRC colorectal cancer, CAPOX capecitabine plus oxaliplatin, NGS next-generation sequencing, 5-FU 5-fluorouracil, SoC standard of care, DCCG Dutch Colorectal Cancer Group, LARC locally advanced rectal cancer, SCRT short course radiotherapy, CRT chemoradiotherapy, MRD minimal residual disease, FOLFOX 5-fluorouracil plus oxaliplatin, TNT total neoadjuvant treatment, cCR clinical complete response, PD progressive disease, MSS microsatellite stable, NPY Neuropeptide Y, wt wild-type.

aMatched historical control 1:3 with TOSCA trial patients.