Skip to main content
. 2022 Aug 3;2022(8):CD013829. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD013829.pub2

4. Response, adherence and contamination rates.

  Response rates to recruitment  Adherence to screening  Contamination
Aberle 2011 Not available Overall adherence to all 3 screening rounds: 95% of participants completed LDCT scan, 93% in the control group completed CXR Not available
Becker 2020
  • 292,440 people received questionnaires

  • 95,797 people responded

  • 4913 people met eligibility criteria

  • 4052 people were enrolled and randomised to the trial (1% of those who received a questionnaire, and 4% of respondents)


 
 
 
 
 
Baseline: almost 100% completed LDCT scan.
1‐year: 95% completed LDCT scan.
2‐year: 93% completed LDCT scan.
3‐year: 93% completed LDCT scan.
4‐year: 94% completed LDCT scan. 
10 years postrandomisation: 264 participants in the control arm had received a CT.
Blanchon 2007
  • 830 eligible people were approached

  • 765 people consented to be randomised (92% of eligible people) 


 
Baseline: 86% participants completed LDCT scan, 75% in control arm completed CXR. At baseline: 6 participants in the control arm inadvertently received a LDCT. 
De Koning 2020
  • 606,409 people received the first questionnaire

  • 150,920 responded to the questionnaire

  • 30,959 people were eligible and invited to participate

  • 15,822 people completed second questionnaire and were included and randomised (3% of people who received the first questionnaire and 51% of eligible respondents)

Baseline: 95% of participants completed LDCT scan
1 year: 97% of participants completed LDCT scan
3 years: 95% completed LDCT scan
5.5 years: 78% of participants completed LDCT scan
At 2 years: 3.6% of participants in the control arm had received CT for any reason
Field 2021
  • 247,354 people invited to participate in study

  • 75,958 responded positively to invitations

  • 8729 of respondents assessed as high risk

  • 5967 responded to second questionnaire

  • 4868 invited to recruitment centre

  • 4152 attended recruitment centre

  • 4061 consented to participation 

  • 4055 randomised to trial (2% of those invited and 46% of high‐risk respondents)

Baseline: 98% of participants completed LDCT scan Not available
Gohagan 2005
  • 653,417 people mailed information packages

  • 12,270 people contacted screening centre and underwent eligibility assessment

  • 4828 people eligible for trial

  • 3409 people were randomised, however 91 participants subsequently found to be ineligible 

  • 3318 participants randomised and included in analysis (1% of people who received mail packages and 27% who were screened for eligibility)

Baseline: 95% of participants completed LDCT scan, 93% of the control group completed CXR
1‐year: 86% of participants completed LDCT scan, 80% of the control group completed CXR 
Contamination assessed by random sample of participants
At baseline: 5% of respondents in the intervention arm had received a CXR for medical or screening purposes. 0.9% of respondents in the control arm had received a CT for medical or screening purposes.
At 1 year: 10% of participants in the intervention arm had received a CXR for medical or screening purposes and 1.3% of respondents in the control arm had received a CT for medical or screening purposes. 
Infante 2015 Not available Not available 3 years post‐randomisation:
  • intervention arm (74 extra CT scan, 233 extra CXRs)

  • control arm (extra 68 CTs, 209 extra CXRs)


Did not specify if for screening purposes, only outside protocol
LaRocca 2002
  • 3418 people completed screening questionnaires

  • 904 participants completed pre‐screening baseline CXR

  • 871 participants randomised to trial (25% of people who completed screening questionnaire)

Not available Not available
Paci 2017
  • 71232 people sent letters

  • 17,055 people responded to letters

  • 3206 people were eligible and randomised (5% of people who received letters and 19% of respondents)

Baseline: 87% completed LDCT scan
1 year: 85% completed LDCT scan
2 years: 82% completed scan
3 years: 80% completed scan
 
Not available
Pastorino 2012 Not available Baseline: 97% of annual group completed scan, 97% of biennial group completed scan
1 year: 97% of the annual group and 97% of the biennial group completed the scan
2 years: 98% of the annual group and 95% of the biennial group completed the scan
3 years: 97% of the annual group and 97% of the biennial group completed the scan
4 years: 96% of the annual group and 92% of the biennial group completed the scan
5 years: 79% of the annual group and 98% of the biennial group completed the scan
6 years: 54% of the annual group and 77% of the biennial group completed the scan
10 years post‐randomisation: 21 of 1723 participants in the control arm had received a LDCT
Wille 2016
  • 5861 people assessed for eligibility

  • 4104 people randomised to the trial (70% of people assessed)

Not available After 5 years post‐randomisation: 0 cases of contamination in the intervention arm; 3 cases in the control arm

CT: computed tomography; CXR: chest x‐ray; LDCT: low‐dose computed tomography