4. Response, adherence and contamination rates.
Response rates to recruitment | Adherence to screening | Contamination | |
Aberle 2011 | Not available | Overall adherence to all 3 screening rounds: 95% of participants completed LDCT scan, 93% in the control group completed CXR | Not available |
Becker 2020 |
|
Baseline: almost 100% completed LDCT scan. 1‐year: 95% completed LDCT scan. 2‐year: 93% completed LDCT scan. 3‐year: 93% completed LDCT scan. 4‐year: 94% completed LDCT scan. |
10 years postrandomisation: 264 participants in the control arm had received a CT. |
Blanchon 2007 |
|
Baseline: 86% participants completed LDCT scan, 75% in control arm completed CXR. | At baseline: 6 participants in the control arm inadvertently received a LDCT. |
De Koning 2020 |
|
Baseline: 95% of participants completed LDCT scan 1 year: 97% of participants completed LDCT scan 3 years: 95% completed LDCT scan 5.5 years: 78% of participants completed LDCT scan |
At 2 years: 3.6% of participants in the control arm had received CT for any reason |
Field 2021 |
|
Baseline: 98% of participants completed LDCT scan | Not available |
Gohagan 2005 |
|
Baseline: 95% of participants completed LDCT scan, 93% of the control group completed CXR 1‐year: 86% of participants completed LDCT scan, 80% of the control group completed CXR |
Contamination assessed by random sample of participants At baseline: 5% of respondents in the intervention arm had received a CXR for medical or screening purposes. 0.9% of respondents in the control arm had received a CT for medical or screening purposes. At 1 year: 10% of participants in the intervention arm had received a CXR for medical or screening purposes and 1.3% of respondents in the control arm had received a CT for medical or screening purposes. |
Infante 2015 | Not available | Not available | 3 years post‐randomisation:
Did not specify if for screening purposes, only outside protocol |
LaRocca 2002 |
|
Not available | Not available |
Paci 2017 |
|
Baseline: 87% completed LDCT scan 1 year: 85% completed LDCT scan 2 years: 82% completed scan 3 years: 80% completed scan |
Not available |
Pastorino 2012 | Not available | Baseline: 97% of annual group completed scan, 97% of biennial group completed scan 1 year: 97% of the annual group and 97% of the biennial group completed the scan 2 years: 98% of the annual group and 95% of the biennial group completed the scan 3 years: 97% of the annual group and 97% of the biennial group completed the scan 4 years: 96% of the annual group and 92% of the biennial group completed the scan 5 years: 79% of the annual group and 98% of the biennial group completed the scan 6 years: 54% of the annual group and 77% of the biennial group completed the scan |
10 years post‐randomisation: 21 of 1723 participants in the control arm had received a LDCT |
Wille 2016 |
|
Not available | After 5 years post‐randomisation: 0 cases of contamination in the intervention arm; 3 cases in the control arm |
CT: computed tomography; CXR: chest x‐ray; LDCT: low‐dose computed tomography