Skip to main content
. 2022 Jul 18;18(7):e1010290. doi: 10.1371/journal.pgen.1010290

Table 1. Simulation results under different relationships between the genetic variants and the exposure at each time point.

MR MVMR
Exposures associated with different liability periods
β 1 Liability effect 0.344 0.200
Effect estimate 0.340 0.1958
Est. Std. Error 0.029 0.0107
Simulation Std. Error 0.011 0.0106
Absolute bias 0.010 0.0092
Coverage 100% 93%
F-statistic 96.31
Conditional F-statistic 55.76
No. SNPs 72 114
β 2 Liability effect 0.376 0.300
Effect estimate 0.371 0.297
Est. Std. Error 0.015 0.009
Simulation Std. Error 0.008 0.009
Absolute bias 0.008 0.008
Coverage 99% 94%
F-statistic 129.31
Conditional F-statistic 78.01
No. SNPs 83 114
Exposures associated with the same liability period
β 1 Liability effect 0.530 0.200
Effect estimate 0.519 0.207
Est. Std. Error 0.011 0.080
Simulation Std. Error 0.011 0.080
Absolute bias 0.013 0.063
Coverage 82% 94%
F-statistic 96.31
Conditional F-statistic 1.06
No. SNPs 72 86
β 2 Liability effect 0.480 0.300
Effect estimate 0.474 0.288
Est. Std. Error 0.009 0.073
Simulation Std. Error 0.009 0.072
Absolute bias 0.009 0.058
Coverage 89% 94%
F-statistic 115.76
Conditional F-statistic 1.06
No. SNPs 83 86

N = 150,000, reps = 2000, Direct effect of exposures on the outcome; X1: β1 = 0.2, X2: β2 = 0.3. Effect of X1 on X2 = 0.1. Effect of the liability for each exposure point are given in the table. Absolute bias is the mean value of the absolute bias of the effect estimate across the simulations. For each of Effect estimate, Est. Std Error, F-statistic and Conditional F-statistic mean values across each iteration of the simulation are reported. Simulation Std. Error is the estimated standard error in the effect estimate across the repetitions in the simulation. Coverage gives the proportion of times the true effect estimate falls within the 95%CI, No. SNPs is the mean number of SNPS selected for estimation.