Skip to main content
. 2022 Jul 20;10(7):e34504. doi: 10.2196/34504

Table 3.

Prediction performance of weekly emergency department patient arrivals.

Models Training Testing
MAPEa (%) RMSEb MAPE (%) RMSE
Patient arrivals

ARIMAc 3.6 17.02 5.2 24.28

ANNd 3.5 19.19 3.6 19.20

SVMe 2.2 18.52 4.1 18.59

RFf 2.5 19.36 3.0 19.67

LSTMg 2.9 16.93 4.2 20.79

ELMh 2.8 16.52 3.2 16.99
Patient arrivals + traditional variables

GLMi 3.2 16.79 5.3 24.44

ARIMAXj 3.5 17.85 5.1 23.16

ANN 3.4 16.10 4.0 18.48

SVM 2.8 16.24 3.9 17.45

RF 2.9 17.05 3.7 18.36

LSTM 3.2 16.43 4.4 19.94

ELM 2.7 13.17 3.5 16.72
Patient arrivals + traditional variables + internet search index

GLM 3.2 16.24 5.0 23.18

ARIMAX 3.4 17.84 5.1 22.00

ANN 3.0 14.51 3.3 15.45

SVM 2.6 14.84 3.1 15.09

RF 2.9 15.92 3.3 16.32

LSTM 3.0 15.15 3.4 16.69

ELM 2.6 13.10 3.0 14.55

aMAPE: average mean absolute percentage error.

bRMSE: root mean square error.

cARIMA: autoregressive integrated moving average model.

dANN: artificial neural network.

eSVM: support vector machine.

fRF: random forest.

gLSTM: long short-term memory.

hELM: extreme learning machine.

iGLM: generalized linear model.

jARIMAX: ARIMA with explanatory variables.