Table 4.
Test model | Reference modelb,c | ||||||||||||
GLMd | ARIMAXe | ANNf | SVMg | RFh | LSTMi | ||||||||
Patient arrivals + traditional variables | |||||||||||||
|
ELM | 2.8297 (<.001) | 3.0624 (<.001) | 2.012 (<.001) | 1.8178 (<.001) | 2.8481 (<.001) | 2.1002 (<.001) | ||||||
|
GLM |
|
0.2935 (.31) | 0.86595 (.11) | 1.0707 (.06) | 0.7643 (.09) | 0.1663 (.54) | ||||||
|
ARIMAX |
|
|
0.64435 (.17) | 1.0691 (.06) | 0.3957 (.23) | 0.4876 (.68) | ||||||
|
ANN |
|
|
|
0.13244 (.38) | 0.2746 (.45) | 1.9512 (.01) | ||||||
|
SVM |
|
|
|
|
0.5823 (.27) | 0.8714 (.12) | ||||||
|
RF |
|
|
|
|
|
1.0045 (.08) | ||||||
Patient arrivals + traditional variables + internet search index | |||||||||||||
|
ELM | 2.5062 (<.001) | 3.79 (<.001) | 2.0047 (<.001) | 2.0325 (<.001) | 2.0476 (<.001) | 1.6659 (.02) | ||||||
|
GLM |
|
0.32675 (.30) | 1.1462 (.12) | 1.6064 (.07) | 1.0467 (.09) | 0.3647 (.64) | ||||||
|
ARIMAX |
|
|
1.7314 (.06) | 2.2885 (.05) | 1.5946 (.11) | 1.2671 (.07) | ||||||
|
ANN |
|
|
|
0.14419 (.40) | 0.2104 (.49) | 1.2304 (.08) | ||||||
|
SVM |
|
|
|
|
0.2593 (.36) | 1.4391 (.04) | ||||||
|
RF |
|
|
|
|
|
1.2992 (.06) |
aDM: Diebold-Mariano.
bThe P value modified by false discovery rate is given in brackets. The significance level is .05.
cValues are presented as the Diebold-Mariano statistic (P value modified by false discovery rate).
dGLM: generalized linear model.
eARIMAX: ARIMA with explanatory variables.
fANN: artificial neural network.
gSVM: support vector machine.
hRF: random forest.
iLSTM: long short-term memory.