Skip to main content
. 2022 Aug 5;12:13478. doi: 10.1038/s41598-022-16971-0

Table 2.

Significance of the effects of irrigation methods, nitrogen fertilization levels, bio-char levels and their interactions on maize growth and yield using ANOVA.

Year Source SOD activity (U mg-1) POD activity (μ g−1 min−1) MDA content (μmol g−1) Dry matter in R1 (g plant−1) Dry matter in R6 (g plant−1) Yield (kg h−1 m−2)
2019 I 290,164.16** 70,886.58** 9.60** 70,699.28** 208,532.59** 10,097,100.5**
N 6107.70** 5892.70** 0.73** 20,169.25** 36,629.26** 10,393,276.3**
B 4855.22** 1208.81** 0.44** 7946.72** 9950.65** 7,380,317.5**
I*N 948.53** 320.23** 0.64** 1895.76** 3.07 ns 45,308.0 ns
I*B 1486.48** 133.95* 0.04** 467.99** 190.79 ns 348,143.1*
N*B 323.26 ns 46.77 ns 0.02** 297.16* 192.56 ns 154,434.3 ns
I*N*B 256.61 ns 62.31 ns 0.03** 32.77 ns 272.11 ns 53,392.3 ns
2020 I 397,884.12** 69,708.33** 7.03** 87,983.62** 228,038.68** 131,641,538.0**
N 14,928.20** 5084.57** 0.90** 29,624.76** 41,972.59** 11,665,380.5**
B 6027.17** 1090.46** 0.34** 7807.38** 9053.22** 7,129,577.7**
I*N 785.32 ns 47.20 ns 0.30** 901.68** 351.13 ns 1,137,105.8**
I*B 737.31* 181.47** 0.16** 731.83** 178.31 ns 221,938.0 ns
N*B 81.50 ns 47.19 ns 0.01 ns 70.41 ns 198.04 ns 29,515.3 ns
I*N*B 89.10 ns 25.03 ns 0.01 ns 26.93 ns 180.49 ns 26,164.0 ns

Numbers were F values. Stars indicated the level of significance (*p < 0.05, **p < 0.01), ns represented insignificant. I represented irrigation methods, including RI and DS; N represented nitrogen fertilization levels, including N0, N150,N300; B represented bio-char levels, including C0,C8,C16,C24.