Table 1.
Differences between the Original THPP and the adapted version of THPP and comments from study findings
| Domain | Original THPP | Adapted version of THPP | Comments |
| Language (appropriateness, cultural applicability of terms and comprehension) |
Language - English | Translated into Local language (Chichewa) – Simplified further using daily spoken words and common idioms |
Participants recommended simplified Chichewa as they had challenges to comprehend some literal translated words - explored idioms used for key words and daily spoken words/language |
| Provider of the intervention |
Female peer volunteer | Female peer volunteer | A female volunteer was viewed culturally acceptable by majority of participants. Few indicated that they would consider male volunteers with consent from family |
| Illustrations and pictures | Illustrations and stories consistent with Asian culture |
Redesigned all Illustrations and stories to a local Malawian context |
Illustrations were not consistent with local Malawian culture, they conveyed different messages to different participants. Just like one participant said; “There are things that are not adding up in these pictures.... looks like she [the woman in the picture] is smoking, or touching her mouth... the facial expressions need to be improved”. |
| Content (Cultural appropriateness and context) |
Content - Focus on the mother and baby. Utilizing core elements of CBT – building empathetic relationship, family involvement, focusing on the here and now, behavior activation and problem solving |
Content - Focus on the mother and baby. Utilizing core elements of CBT – building empathetic relationship, family involvement, focusing on the here and now, behavior activation and problem solving -These were maintained using simplified Chichewa |
Participants recommended the focus of the intervention and strategies used |
| Implementation (frequency of sessions and place) |
Place – home Frequency – 10 individual sessions, 4 group sessions |
Place – home Frequency – 7 individual sessions and 4 group sessions |
Participants did not recommend specific number of sessions, rather flexibility on number of sessions depending on the need. From available evidence, a minimum of 8 sessions are considered effective (Vanobberghen et al, 2020), hence the adapted version has a minimum of 7 sessions and maximum 10 sessions; 4 sessions during pregnancy (Session 1: Introductory Session, Session 2: Mother's Personal Health Session 3: Mother's Relationship with people around her and Session 4: Mother Child Relationship) then 3 sessions following child birth (Session 5: Mother's Personal Health, Session 6: Mother's Relationship with people around her, Session 7: Mother's Child Relationship) The remaining 3 sessions, sessions 8–10 can be delivered if the mother still screens positive for depression after session 8, (Session 8: Mothers Personal Health Session 9: Mother's Relationship with people around her and Session 10: Mother Child Relationship). |