Skip to main content
. 2022 Jun;34(2):87–94. doi: 10.4314/mmj.v34i2.3

Table 1.

Differences between the Original THPP and the adapted version of THPP and comments from study findings

Domain Original THPP Adapted version of THPP Comments
Language
(appropriateness,
cultural applicability
of terms and
comprehension)
Language - English Translated into Local language
(Chichewa) – Simplified further
using daily spoken words and
common idioms
Participants recommended simplified
Chichewa as they had challenges to
comprehend some literal translated words -
explored idioms used for key words and daily
spoken words/language
Provider of the
intervention
Female peer volunteer Female peer volunteer A female volunteer was viewed culturally
acceptable by majority of participants. Few
indicated that they would consider male
volunteers with consent from family
Illustrations and pictures Illustrations and stories
consistent with Asian culture
Redesigned all Illustrations
and stories to a local Malawian
context
Illustrations were not consistent with local
Malawian culture, they conveyed different
messages to different participants. Just like
one participant said; “There are things that are
not adding up in these pictures.... looks like
she [the woman in the picture] is smoking, or
touching her mouth... the facial expressions
need to be improved”.
Content (Cultural
appropriateness and
context)
Content - Focus on the
mother and baby.

Utilizing core elements of
CBT – building empathetic
relationship, family
involvement, focusing on
the here and now, behavior
activation and problem
solving
Content - Focus on the mother
and baby.

Utilizing core elements of CBT –
building empathetic relationship,
family involvement, focusing
on the here and now, behavior
activation and problem solving

-These were maintained using
simplified Chichewa
Participants recommended the focus of the
intervention and strategies used
Implementation
(frequency of sessions
and place)
Place – home

Frequency – 10 individual
sessions, 4 group sessions
Place – home

Frequency – 7 individual sessions
and 4 group sessions
Participants did not recommend specific
number of sessions, rather flexibility on
number of sessions depending on the
need. From available evidence, a minimum
of 8 sessions are considered effective
(Vanobberghen et al, 2020), hence the
adapted version has a minimum of 7 sessions
and maximum 10 sessions; 4 sessions during
pregnancy (Session 1: Introductory Session,
Session 2: Mother's Personal Health

Session 3: Mother's Relationship with people
around her and Session 4: Mother Child
Relationship) then 3 sessions following
child birth (Session 5: Mother's Personal
Health, Session 6: Mother's Relationship with
people around her, Session 7: Mother's Child
Relationship)

The remaining 3 sessions, sessions 8–10 can
be delivered if the mother still screens positive
for depression after session 8, (Session 8:
Mothers Personal Health Session 9: Mother's
Relationship with people around her and
Session 10: Mother Child Relationship).