Table 5.

Results of the analysis of energy efficiency by province in the third phase 2011–2019

Region	Province	2011	2012	2013	2014	2015	2016	2017	2018	2019	Average value
East	Beijing	1.156975	1.218058	1.16232	1.067273	1.048862	1.081241	1.010164	1.059567	1	1.089385
	Tianjin	0.932598	0.867342	1.004331	1.034379	0.927898	1.078027	1.039647	1.026726	0.865812	0.975195
	Hebei	0.82915	0.761711	0.813714	0.800227	0.801476	0.850938	0.864531	0.860925	0.816717	0.822154
	Liaoning	0.733815	0.70624	0.754706	0.746755	0.771081	0.843884	0.800049	0.838684	0.891098	0.787368
	Shanghai	0.825793	0.804027	0.843816	0.918964	0.921365	1.026139	0.991747	0.976326	1.043603	0.927976
	Jiangsu	0.791658	0.757149	0.823393	0.864104	0.83725	0.838584	0.856114	0.844699	0.798031	0.823442
	Zhejiang	0.777163	0.730351	0.853544	0.813785	0.809865	0.880239	0.877817	0.84998	0.778605	0.819039
	Fujian	0.925735	0.819859	0.817797	0.880359	0.875468	0.80568	0.87162	0.928617	0.854189	0.864369
	Shandong	0.73901	0.736841	0.75789	0.768607	0.773197	0.779703	0.709333	0.75202	0.777807	0.754934
	Guangdong	0.8022	0.751489	0.787896	0.838592	0.798622	0.76266	0.803769	0.839137	0.826528	0.80121
	Hainan	1.074147	1.139734	1.075506	1.040253	1.091931	1.006031	1.055286	1.012022	1.00915	1.056007
Middle	Shanxi	0.852684	0.792525	0.775426	0.785088	0.817261	0.837283	0.896118	0.90007	0.909513	0.840663
	Jilin	0.811473	0.776705	0.893731	0.841676	0.873823	1.031719	0.940151	0.989758	1.001821	0.906762
	Heilongjiang	0.75731	0.726405	0.843125	0.820261	0.832634	0.903126	0.801429	0.870682	0.860019	0.823888
	Anhui	0.846919	0.771867	0.771613	0.816166	0.862687	0.844639	0.822138	0.872958	0.827111	0.826233
	Jiangxi	0.861216	0.808003	0.885559	0.881353	0.845059	0.799245	0.833266	0.936192	0.86323	0.857014
	Henan	0.814921	0.778122	0.779383	0.777184	0.790592	0.851955	0.840447	0.846181	0.861165	0.81555
	Hubei	0.877477	0.787803	0.745363	0.804797	0.845564	0.882929	0.883718	0.889034	0.846228	0.840324
	Hunan	0.816538	0.756707	0.723447	0.836944	0.857242	0.858504	0.826032	0.867928	0.894385	0.826414
West	Inner Mongolia	0.859298	0.806287	0.795244	0.722187	0.73951	0.809853	0.850487	0.841519	0.911364	0.815083
	Guangxi	0.83222	0.788097	0.832601	0.847284	0.821733	0.793648	0.892339	0.949009	0.893689	0.850069
	Chongqing	0.849722	0.832728	0.816189	0.909567	0.924165	0.943447	0.893906	0.941753	1.022047	0.903725
	Sichuan	0.778843	0.746546	0.753075	0.749807	0.755595	0.803428	0.809466	0.821906	0.901633	0.791144
	Guizhou	0.840097	0.796256	0.791717	0.781037	0.817737	0.850478	0.897089	1.001317	1.005966	0.864633
	Yunnan	0.91869	0.838573	0.798945	0.806219	0.88007	0.864763	0.924128	1.000535	0.857349	0.876586
	Shaanxi	0.794008	0.733343	0.742392	0.7916	0.834033	0.8757	0.855014	0.889837	0.887615	0.822616
	Gansu	0.855393	0.860528	0.843688	0.849262	0.873561	0.945701	0.847914	0.908577	1.000371	0.887222
	Qinghai	1.034355	1.01224	1.117752	1.090269	1.075491	1.100122	1.089547	1.065676	0.940147	1.0584
	Ningxia	0.978544	0.903956	1.003374	0.867935	0.852432	0.939147	1.004927	0.920878	1.04745	0.946516
	Xinjiang	0.844649	0.796439	0.76176	0.734655	0.806826	0.834862	0.792231	0.830126	0.848719	0.805585