Table 1. Inclusion and exclusion criteria.
Inclusion criteria | Exclusion criteria | |
---|---|---|
Population | Human beings with or without NCDs. Human beings with or without NCD risk factors. | Subjects are not human beings. |
Intervention | NCD prevention and/or control interventions that are provided within health systems (see Table A in S1 Appendix). | Interventions that are not specified in the inclusion criteria. |
Outcome | Implementation outcomes as defined by Proctor and colleagues and Glasgow and colleagues [20,21] • Acceptability • Adoption • Appropriateness • Feasibility • Fidelity • Penetration • Sustainability • Implementation costs • Reach • Implementation • Maintenance |
Outcomes other than those specified in the inclusion criteria. |
Study design | Quantitative, qualitative, or mixed method. Quantitative study designs included experimental and observational. • Experimental designs: ○ Randomized controlled trial, ○ Cluster randomized trial, ○ Randomized step wedge, • Observational designs: ○ Quasi-experimental designs: ▪ Single interrupted time series, ▪ Controlled interrupted time series, ▪ Pre-post with comparison group, ▪ Regression discontinuity, ▪ Nonrandomized stepped wedge ○ Preexperimental designs (no control group or no repeated measures): ▪ Pre-post ▪ Post-only design ○ Other observational designs include: ▪ Cohort studies ▪ Cross-sectional studies ▪ Case-control studies |
Nonempirical/primary research including: • Review • Meta-analysis • Editorial • Commentary • Letter to editor • Opinion paper • Newspaper • Protocols • Case report • Epidemiological/descriptive studies (e.g., nonintervention association studies including knowledge, attitude, discrete choice experiment, awareness, willingness, and perception (including perceived barriers) studies) and not in the context of implementation of NCD interventions. • Instrument/screening or diagnostic test validation studies • Call to action • Sharing experience/lessons learned on the field if not resulting from research • (Descriptive) cost-effectiveness studies based on modeling (and not in the context of implementation of NCD interventions) |
Geographic Scope | LMICs (see Table C in S1 Appendix) | Areas other than LMICs |
Time frame | 1990–2020 | Studies published before 1990 |
LMIC, low- and middle-income country; NCD, noncommunicable disease.