Table 2.
Number of patients discharged directly in the intervention cohort
| Study | Injury | DD cohort size; n | DD rate; % | Relative to all patients with |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Comparative | ||||
| Abdelmalek [10] | 5MC neck Fx | 6 | 22.2 | 5MC neck fractures |
| Bansal [11] | 5MC neck Fx | 38 | n/a | – |
| Ferguson [12] | 5MT Fx | 280 | 82.6 | 5MT fractures |
| Hamilton [13] | Paediatric forearm Fx | 159 | n/a | – |
| Kelly [14] | Multiple | 45 | 18.2 | Minor trauma injuries |
| Khan [15] | Torus Fx wrist | 69 | n/a | – |
| Mackenzie [9] | 5MC Fx | 88 | n/a | – |
| 5MT Fx | 87 | n/a | – | |
| Radial head/neck Fx | 114 | n/a | – | |
| Matthews [16] | Paediatric clavicle Fx | 18 | 78.3 | Paediatric zone 2 (midshaft) clavicle fractures |
| Seewoonarain [17] | Torus Fx wrist | 33 | 75.0 | Torus fractures of the distal radius |
| Vardy/Jenkins [2, 8] | Multiple | 3802 | 59.5 | Musculoskeletal injuries in the ED not requiring immediate admission |
| Non-comparative | ||||
| Bhattacharyya [18] | Clavicle Fx | 62 | 44.9 | Clavicle fractures |
| Breathnach [19] | Multiple | 42 | 26.8 | Any type of fracture |
| Brogan [20] | 5MT Fx | 499 | 75.3 | 5MT fractures |
| Brooksbank [21] | Mallet finger | 46 | 97.9 | Mallet finger injuries |
| Callender [22] | Torus Fx wrist | 119 | n/a | – |
| Evans [23] | Hand/wrist injuries | 54 | 18.6 | Hand/wrist injuries |
| Gamble [24] | 5MC Fx | 167 | n/a | – |
| Gleeson [25]—I | Torus Fx wrist; paediatric clavicle Fx | 61 | n/a | – |
| Gleeson [26]—II | 5MC neck, 5MT base, Weber A Fx | 33 | n/a | – |
| Ibrahim [27] | Hand/wrist injuries | 38 | 38.0 | Hand/wrist injuries |
| Jayaram [28] | Radial head/neck Fx | 182 | 90.1 | Mason type 1 or 2 radial head/neck fractures |
| Little [29] | Hand/wrist injuries | 968 | 26.1 | Hand injuries |
| O’Reilly [30] | Multiple | 901 | 33.3 | Musculoskeletal injuries in the ED |
| Robinson [31] | Multiple paediatric | 229 | n/a | – |
| White [1] | Multiple | 3222 | 26.7 | Musculoskeletal injuries in the ED |
If studies reported exclusively on outcomes in patients that were discharged directly, a direct discharge rate could not be determined (n/a/)
5MC fifth metacarpal, 5MT fifth metatarsal, DD direct discharge, ED emergency department, FU follow-up, Fx fracture, n/a not applicable, VFC virtual fracture clinic