Table 1.
Summary of selected high intensity focused ultrasound (HIFU) studies and imaging findings across multiple modalities. We summarize a selection of imaging findings following both thermal and mechanical HIFU ablation. Two radiofrequency ablation (RFA) studies are also included due to novelty of the imaging methods and its applicability to thermal HIFU assessment.
Study | Ablation modality | Imaging modality | Clinical/preclinical | Animal model | Findings | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
MRI | Hoogenboom et al. [5] | HIFU (boiling histotripsy) | Noncontrast T2 MRI | Preclinical | C57B/6 mice EL4 thymoma |
Ablated region is hyperintense with hypointense rim on noncontrast T2w MRI |
Rouviere et al. [7] | HIFU (thermal) | Contrast-enhanced T1 MRI | Clinical | N/A | Ablated region is nonenhancing accompanied (variably) with a hyperintense rim due to hyperemia | |
Pilatou et al. [8] | HIFU (thermal) | Diffusion-weighted and ADC MRI | Clinical | N/A | Ablated lesions have increased intensity on high value DWI images | |
Liao et al. [9] | HIFU (thermal) | Diffusion-weighted MRI | Clinical | N/A | Reduction in ADC following ablation; high-signal ring around ablated region on DWI | |
Vidal-Jove et al. [10] | HIFU (histotripsy) | Contrast-enhanced T1 MRI | Clinical | N/A | Mechanically disrupted region appears as a nonperfused volume | |
Morochnik et al. [11] | HIFU (thermal) | T2 map MRI | Clinical | N/A | T2 increases during HIFU treatment | |
Worlikar et al. [12] | HIFU (histotripsy) | T2w MRI | Preclinical | Sprague-Dawley rats N1-S1 hepatic tumors |
Ablated region hypointense immediately following ablation followed by gradual resorption | |
Lee et al. [13] | HIFU (thermal) | 13C MRI | Preclinical | C57Bl6 X FVB TRAMP prostate cancer model |
Ablated regions exhibited 13C lactate and 13C urea intensity similar to background. Partially ablated regions had decreased intensity which recovered after 5 days | |
CT | Yang et al. [14] | HIFU (thermal) | Contrast-enhanced CT | Preclinical | Rabbit Healthy liver |
Ablated lesion is low-density and nonenhancing |
Orgera et al. [15] | HIFU (thermal) | Contrast-enhanced CT | Clinical | N/A | Nonenhancing ablated lesion appears shortly after ablation | |
US | Luo et al. [16] | HIFU +/- microbubbles | US | Preclinical | Rabbit VX2 liver tumor |
Transient hyperechogenicity after ablation on b-mode |
Sasaki et al. [17] | HIFU (thermal) | US | Preclinical | Ex vivo porcine liver | Decorrelation between RF frames during HIFU | |
Zhou et al. [18] | HIFU (thermal) | Doppler US | Clinical | N/A | No blood flow on Doppler after HIFU ablation | |
Vlaisavljevich et al. [19] | HIFU (histotripsy) | US | Preclinical | Porcine Healthy liver |
Bubble cloud can be used to monitor treatment in real time | |
Wright et al. [20] | HIFU (histotripsy) | US | Preclinical | Rabbit femoral artery | HIFU thrombolysis restored blood flow | |
PET | Chen et al. [21] | RFA | 18FDG PET | Clinical | N/A | PET had increased sensitivity (94.1%) and specificity (81.3%) to recurrent tumor after thermal ablation |
Orgera et al. [15] | HIFU (thermal) | 18FDG PET | Clinical | N/A | Reduction in metabolic activity after HIFU delineates ablation margins | |
Shyn et al. [22] | RFA | 13N ammonia and 18FDG PET | Clinical | N/A | Entire ablation margin can be assessed intraprocedurally |