Skip to main content
. 2022 Jun 1;68(2):175–183. doi: 10.5606/tftrd.2022.7866

Table 3. Comparison of the kinematics and kinetics at the ankle, knee, and hip and pelvic and thoracic angles measurements between the groups.

  AFO-PS AFO-OD Therapeutic effect①②/③④
Parameters Pre-intervention① Post­-intervention② Pre-intervention③ Post­-intervention④   Main effect
  Mean±SD Mean±SD Mean±SD Mean±SD Interaction Time Group
Ankle joint angle              
Initial contact (°) -10.9±9.0 -8.0±7.6 -6.2±6.5 -7.4±6.3 0.041 - -
Loading response (°) -12.6±9.0 -10.4±7.1 -8.7±6.8 -10.3±6.4 0.054 0.754 0.373
Max dorsiflexion in single stance (°) 1.6±9.3 4.4±6.4 4.9±6.6 4.7±6.4 0.094 0.122 0.400
Max plantarflexion in pre-swing phase (°) -4.0±8.4 -3.1±6.9 -1.4±8.0 -2.1±8.0 0.449 0.925 0.438
Ankle j oint moment              
Max dorsiflexion in loading response (Nm/BW) -0.0±0.0 -0.0±0.1 -0.0±0.0 -0.0±0.1 0.056 0.022 0.209
Max plantarflexion in stance phase (Nm/BW) 0.6±0.3 0.7±0.3 0.7±0.3 0.7±0.3 0.557 0.008 0.655
Ankle joint power              
Max power in pre-swing (W) 0.3±0.3 0.4±0.4 0.2±0.2 0.3±0.2 0.593 0.047 0.235
Knee joint angle and knee angular velocity              
Initial contact (°) 9.4±5.2 9.0±6.3 6.5±7.4 5.2±6.7 0.447 0.183 0.096
Max flexion in loading response (°) 17.2±4.4 15.3±5.9 11.5±9.6 12.0±10.8 0.063 0.276 0.632
Max extension in single stance (°) 6.9±8.7 6.0±10.6 1.0±12.1 1.1±12.2      
Max flexion in swing (0) 41.8±11.9 43.2±11.0 37.3±14.9 38.1±14.3 0.507 0.591 0.126
Max angular velocity in pre-swing (deg s-1) 144.8±76.0 181.6±108.3 146.2±69.8 171.3±78.8 0.697 0.198 0.254
Knee joint moment         0.324 <0.001 0.865
Max extension in loading response (Nm/BW) 0.2±0.2 0.2±0.2 0.2±0.2 0.2±0.2      
Hip joint angle and hip angular velocity         0.831 0.762 0.587
Initial contact (°) 18.1±5.5 21.1±6.4 18.3±7.2 17.6±7.9      
Max extension in single stance (°) 8.3±9.7 7.2±12.4 7.0±11.1 5.1±10.4 0.122 0.308 0.384
Max angular velocity in pre-swing (deg s-1) 64.6±32.9 76.8±40.5 68.0±37.8 64.0±36.5 0.778 0.223 0.615
Hip joint moment         0.048 - -
Max extension in loading response (Nm/BW) 0.3±0.2 0.3±0.2 0.5±0.7 0.5±0.6      
Max flexion in pre-swing (Nm/BW) -0.3±0.2 -0.4±0.3 -0.3±0.2 -0.3±0.2 0.797 0.856 0.242
Pelvic tilt         0.583 0.024 0.265
Initial contact (0) -2.8±5.0 -6.1±6.8 -5.6±6.4 -5.3±6.0      
Nonparetic foot-off (0) -7.1±4.4 -9.9±7.1 -10.1±6.1 -10.0±6.4 0.061 0.126 0.560
Nonparetic initial contact (0) -8.7±4.7 -11.2±5.0 -11.7±6.4 -12.4±6.0 0.140 0.158 0.364
Foot-off (0) -7.0±5.4 -10.2±7.5 -11.0±6.3 -11.7±6.0 0.112 0.356 0.233
Pelvic obliquity         0.193 0.048 0.130
Initial contact (0) 2.3±3.0 1.6±2.1 2.6±3.2 2.7±2.8      
Nonparetic foot-off (0) 0.6±2.6 0.2±2.8 0.6±2.6 0.6±3.1 0.404 0.559 0.380
Nonparetic initial contact (0) 0.3±2.4 -0.6±2.7 1.4±2.7 0.6±3.2 0.598 0.668 0.771
Foot-off (0) 1.7±3.0 0.6±2.8 2.7±2.8 1.9±3.2 0.825 0.042 0.173
Thoracic tilt         0.722 0.041 0.188
Initial contact (0) -2.7±5.5 -3.0±6.4 -3.9±5.8 -1.8±6.1      
Nonparetic foot off (0) -5.2±6.2 -5.1±7.0 -6.8±6.5 -5.1±8.5 0.088 0.197 0.980
Nonparetic initial contact (0) -7.7±6.7 -7.0±7.1 -9.2±7.4 -8.3±8.9 0.208 0.169 0.723
Foot-off (0) -5.8±6.3 -6.3±7.6 -8.3±7.4 -7.7±9.6 0.871 0.310 0.537
AFO-PS: Ankle-foot orthoses plantarflexion stop; AFO-OD: Ankle-foot orthoses oil damper; Pre-intervention: Without AFO before two weeks’ use; Post-intervention: Without the AFO after two weeks’ use; SD: Standard deviation; IQR: Interquartile range; BW: Body weight (kg); BH: Body height (m); COG: Center of gravity; COP: Center of pressure; SVA: Shank-vertical-angle; Joint angle: positive numbers: Flexion/dorsiflexion; Negative numbers: Extension/plantarflexion; Internal joint moment: Positive numbers; Extension/plantarflexion; negative numbers: Flexion/ dorsiflexion; Ankle power: Positive numbers: Generation; negative numbers: Absorption: Tilt angle: negative values indicate forward tilt; Obliquity angle: A positive value indicates that the pelvis is higher on the paretic side than on the nonparetic side; Pre-intervention: Without AFO use before two weeks’ use; Post-intervention: Without the AFO after two weeks’ use; AFO-PS: AFO with plantarflexion stop; AFO-OD: AFO with oil damper;