Skip to main content
. 2022 Aug 10;22:341. doi: 10.1186/s12903-022-02366-0

Table 2.

Characteristics of selected studies (N = 18)

References Study design Country Setting Participants ASD diagnosis Malocclusion measures Eligibility criteria* Group of comparison
Vittek et al. [35] Cross-sectional United States Healthcare services

N total = 458; N ASD = 26

boys (63.8%), girls (36.2%)

Age group: 6–87 years-old

Medical records

Angle's classification, crowding, crossbite, open bite, overbite and overjet

Examiner: N.I

Clinical calibration: N.I

Examination conditions: dental chair using mouth mirroe and probe

Exclusion criteria

Edentulous patients and those without molar relationship

Yes

Children without intellectual and mental disabilities (N = 8841), organic brain (N = 238), seizure disorder (N = 90), cerebral palsy (N = 47), down (N = 57)

Manzano et al. [36] Cross-sectional Venezuela Special education institutes

N total = 133; N ASD = 23

boys (55.6%), girls (44.4%)

Age group: 3–4 years-old

Medical diagnosis

Angle's classification (só relata no resultado)

Examiner: N.I

Clinical calibration: N.I

Local of examination: N.I

Inclusion criteria

Age between 3 and 4 years

Yes

Down syndrome (N = 65), deaf and speech impaired (N = 26), sight impaired (N = 7), cerebral palsy (N = 12)

DeMattei et al. [37] Cross-sectional United States Three schools for disabled children

N total = 55; N ASD = 39

boys (72.7%) girls (27.3%)

Age group: 2.6–21.0 years-old

Medical records and school files

Angle´s classification, crowding, crossbite

Examiner: dental hygienists

Clinical calibration: N.I

Examination conditions: portable dental chairs

None

Yes

Children with other developmental disorders (N = 16)

Luppanapornlarp et al. [38] Cross-sectional Thailand Division of Dentistry of University

N total = 80; N ASD = 32

boys (78.1%), girls (21.8%)

Age group: 8–12 years-old

Mean age = 9.8 ± 1.1

Not reported

Dental Aesthetic Index

Examiner: N.I

Clinical calibration: Intrarater Correlation Coefficient = 0.98

Examination conditions: N.I

Inclusion criteria

Age between 8 and 12 years, history of orthodontic treatment

Exclusion criteria

Inability to cooperate in the oral examination

Yes

Children without ASD (N = 48)

Soni et al. [39] Cross-sectional India Special schools

N total = 78, N ASD = 10

boys (66.7%) and girls (33.3)

Age group:12–15 years

Not reported

IOTN

Examiner: N.I

Clinical calibration: Kappa > 0.82

Examination conditions: use of natural daylight

Exclusion criteria

Age between 12 and 15 years, Inability to cooperate in the oral examination

Yes

Down syndrome (N = 4), hearing impaired (N = 11), learning disability (N = 2), mental retardation (N = 43), orthopedic disability (N = 2), spastic paraplegia (N = 1) and visually impaired (N = 5)

Orellana et al. [40] Cross-sectional Spain Two day-centres for people with autism

N total = 60; N ASD = 30

boys (90.0%), girls (10.0%)

Age group: 20–41 years-old

Mean age = 27.8 ± 5.8

Not reported

Dental crowding, open bite

Examiner: dentists

Clinical calibration: Kappa > 0.81

Examination conditions: portable dental chair and lamp

None

Yes

Individuals without ASD (N = 30)

Rekha et al. [41] Cross-sectional India Twelve special education schools, three autistic child centres and three therapy centres

N ASD = 483

boys (75.1%), girls (24.9%)

Age group: 4–16 years-old

School files

Proclination, crowding, anterior open bite, rotation

Examiner: pediatric dentistry

Clinical calibration: N.I

Local of examination: mouth mirror in broad daylight

None No
Muppa et al. [42] Cross-sectional India Eleven special schools

N total = 844; N ASD = 40

boys (80.0%), girls (20.0%)

Age group: 6–30 years-old

Not reported

Class I, Class II, Class III, anterior crowding, anterior spacing, deep bite, open bite, and anterior cross bite

Examiner: N.I

Clinical calibration: N.I

Examination conditions: under natural light, with the child in the knee to knee position

None

Yes

Mild Intellectual Disability (MID) (N = 308), moderate ID (N = 201), severe ID (N = 83, Hearing and speech (N = 172), cerebral palsy (N = 40)

Vellappally et al. [43] Cross-sectional India Fourteen special schools for disabled

N total = 243; N ASD = 14

boys (60.1%), girls (39.9%)

Age group: 12–18 years-old

Mean age 14.1 ± 2.0

Not reported

Dental Aesthetic Index

Examiner: N.I

Clinical calibration: reproducibility = 90%

Examination conditions: N.I

Inclusion criteria

Ages ≥ 12 and < 19 years, intelligence Quotient (IQ) ≤ 85

Exclusion criteria

Inability to cooperate in the oral examination, history of orthodontic treatment

Yes

Intellectual disability (ID) alone (N = 108), ID and cerebral palsy (N = 55), Down’s syndrome (N = 36), ID and a learning disability (N = 18) and ID and a speech-hearing impairment (N = 12)

Du et al. [44] Cross-sectional China Nineteen special child care centres

N total = 514; N ASD = 257

boys (84.4%), girls (15.6%)

Age group: 2.7–6.4 years-old Mean age = 4.9 ± 0.8

Not reported

Deep overbite, anterior open bite, increased overjet, anterior crossbite and posterior crossbite

Examiner: N.I

Clinical calibration: Kappa > 0.70

Examination conditions: chair using an intra-oral mirror with a LED light source

None

Yes

Children without ASD (N = 257)

Alkhadra [45] Cross-sectional Kingdom of Saudi Arabia Five rehabilitation centres for disabled children

N total = 72; N ASD = 55

boys (72.7%) girls (27.3%)

Age group: 6–14 years-old

Medical records

Angle’s classification, overjet, overbite, incisor open bite, cross bite in the right and left side on both anterior and posterior

Examiner: N.I

Clinical calibration: N.I

Examination conditions: portable chair under natural light using a disposable mouth mirror and tongue blade

Exclusion criteria

History of ongoing medical treatment, extraction, and orthodontic treatment

Yes

Children with Down syndrome (N = 100)

Fontaine-Sylvestre et al. [46] Cross-sectional Canada Division of dentistry, children's hospital

N total = 200; N ASD = 99

boys (78.8%), girls (21.2%)

Age group: 5–18 years-old Mean age = 11.0 ± 3.7

Medical diagnosis

Angle's classification, midline deviation, crossbite, open bite, overbite, crowding,

Examiner: N.I

Clinical calibration: N.I

Examination conditions: dental chair

Inclusion criteria

Age between 5 to 18 years

Mixed or permanent dentition

Exclusion criteria

Another disorder or syndrome than ASD, history of orthodontic treatment, Incomplete files with respect to the child's diagnosis of ASD

Yes

Children without ASD (N = 101)

Alkhabuli et al.[47] Cross-sectional United Arab Emirates Rehabilitation centres for disabled children

N total = 54; N ASD = 9

boys (70.4%) girls (29.6%)

Age group: 3–17 years-old

Medical records

Angle’s classification, crowding; spacing, anterior open bite, IOTN

Examiner: N.I

Clinical calibration: Kappa = 0.83

Examination conditions: adjustable chair using torchlight, dental explorer, and mouth mirror

Inclusion criteria

Age ≤ 17 years

No
Kuter and Guler [48] Cross-sectional Turkey Regular schools

N total = 407; N ASD = 285

boys (80%), girls (20%)

Age group: 5–16 years-old

Not reported

crowding, open bite, deep-palate

Examiner: N.I

Clinical calibration: N.I

Examination conditions: chair using dental mirror and explorer

None

Yes

Children without ASD (N = 122)

Leiva-Garcia et al. [49] Cross-sectional Spain Rehabilitation centre for disabled children

N total = 146; N ASD = 55

boys (74%), girls (26%)

Age group: 6–18 years-old

Mean age = 10.7 ± 3.0

Medical diagnosis

Angle's classification, open bite, crossbite

Examiner: one pediatric dentist

Clinical calibration: Kappa = 0.80

Examination conditions: chair under natural light and using a sterile exploration kit comprising an oral probe and mirror, and cotton tips

Exclusion criteria

Special diets, food allergies or medications capable of modifying dietary intake and oral health

Yes

Children with typical development (N = 91)

Orellana et al. [50] Cross-sectional Chile Institutions for people with ASD

N ASD = 123

boys (82.9%), girls (17.1%)

Age group: 4–23 years-old

Mean age = 9.4 ± 4.3

Not reported

Deep/ogival palate, anterior

open bite, anterior and posterior crossbite

Examiner: dentists

Clinical calibration: Kappa > 0.81

Examination conditions: portable dental chair and lamp

Inclusion criteria

Understanding very simple instructions

No
Mangione et al. [51] Cross-sectional France special dental care department Division of Dentistry of University

N ASD = 118

boys (75.4%), girls (24.6%)

Age group: 4–53 years-old

Mean age = 23.3

Medical records

mild to severe dental and/or alveolar malocclusions

Examiner: N.I

Clinical calibration: N.I

Examination conditions: dental chairs

None No
Bagattoni et al. [52] Cross-sectional Italy Special Needs Dentistry Unit of University

N total = 128, N ASD = 64

boys (66%), girls (34%)

Age group: 9.0 ± 2.9 years

Medical diagnosis

Angle’s classification, posterior crossbite, anterior open bite and deep bite

Examiner: dentists

Clinical calibration: N.I

Examination conditions: dental chair using a dental mirror and a WHO periodontal probe

Exclusion criteria:

Medical condition associated with oral diseases, inability to cooperate in the oral examination, dental prophylaxis in the previous 6 months, history of orthodontic treatment

Children without ASD (N = 64)

*Diagnostic methods of ASD and non-ASDs were not considered as eligibility criteria

N.I.: not informed