Table 2.
References | Study design | Country | Setting | Participants | ASD diagnosis | Malocclusion measures | Eligibility criteria* | Group of comparison |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Vittek et al. [35] | Cross-sectional | United States | Healthcare services |
N total = 458; N ASD = 26 boys (63.8%), girls (36.2%) Age group: 6–87 years-old |
Medical records |
Angle's classification, crowding, crossbite, open bite, overbite and overjet Examiner: N.I Clinical calibration: N.I Examination conditions: dental chair using mouth mirroe and probe |
Exclusion criteria Edentulous patients and those without molar relationship |
Yes Children without intellectual and mental disabilities (N = 8841), organic brain (N = 238), seizure disorder (N = 90), cerebral palsy (N = 47), down (N = 57) |
Manzano et al. [36] | Cross-sectional | Venezuela | Special education institutes |
N total = 133; N ASD = 23 boys (55.6%), girls (44.4%) Age group: 3–4 years-old |
Medical diagnosis |
Angle's classification (só relata no resultado) Examiner: N.I Clinical calibration: N.I Local of examination: N.I |
Inclusion criteria Age between 3 and 4 years |
Yes Down syndrome (N = 65), deaf and speech impaired (N = 26), sight impaired (N = 7), cerebral palsy (N = 12) |
DeMattei et al. [37] | Cross-sectional | United States | Three schools for disabled children |
N total = 55; N ASD = 39 boys (72.7%) girls (27.3%) Age group: 2.6–21.0 years-old |
Medical records and school files |
Angle´s classification, crowding, crossbite Examiner: dental hygienists Clinical calibration: N.I Examination conditions: portable dental chairs |
None |
Yes Children with other developmental disorders (N = 16) |
Luppanapornlarp et al. [38] | Cross-sectional | Thailand | Division of Dentistry of University |
N total = 80; N ASD = 32 boys (78.1%), girls (21.8%) Age group: 8–12 years-old Mean age = 9.8 ± 1.1 |
Not reported |
Dental Aesthetic Index Examiner: N.I Clinical calibration: Intrarater Correlation Coefficient = 0.98 Examination conditions: N.I |
Inclusion criteria Age between 8 and 12 years, history of orthodontic treatment Exclusion criteria Inability to cooperate in the oral examination |
Yes Children without ASD (N = 48) |
Soni et al. [39] | Cross-sectional | India | Special schools |
N total = 78, N ASD = 10 boys (66.7%) and girls (33.3) Age group:12–15 years |
Not reported |
IOTN Examiner: N.I Clinical calibration: Kappa > 0.82 Examination conditions: use of natural daylight |
Exclusion criteria Age between 12 and 15 years, Inability to cooperate in the oral examination |
Yes Down syndrome (N = 4), hearing impaired (N = 11), learning disability (N = 2), mental retardation (N = 43), orthopedic disability (N = 2), spastic paraplegia (N = 1) and visually impaired (N = 5) |
Orellana et al. [40] | Cross-sectional | Spain | Two day-centres for people with autism |
N total = 60; N ASD = 30 boys (90.0%), girls (10.0%) Age group: 20–41 years-old Mean age = 27.8 ± 5.8 |
Not reported |
Dental crowding, open bite Examiner: dentists Clinical calibration: Kappa > 0.81 Examination conditions: portable dental chair and lamp |
None |
Yes Individuals without ASD (N = 30) |
Rekha et al. [41] | Cross-sectional | India | Twelve special education schools, three autistic child centres and three therapy centres |
N ASD = 483 boys (75.1%), girls (24.9%) Age group: 4–16 years-old |
School files |
Proclination, crowding, anterior open bite, rotation Examiner: pediatric dentistry Clinical calibration: N.I Local of examination: mouth mirror in broad daylight |
None | No |
Muppa et al. [42] | Cross-sectional | India | Eleven special schools |
N total = 844; N ASD = 40 boys (80.0%), girls (20.0%) Age group: 6–30 years-old |
Not reported |
Class I, Class II, Class III, anterior crowding, anterior spacing, deep bite, open bite, and anterior cross bite Examiner: N.I Clinical calibration: N.I Examination conditions: under natural light, with the child in the knee to knee position |
None |
Yes Mild Intellectual Disability (MID) (N = 308), moderate ID (N = 201), severe ID (N = 83, Hearing and speech (N = 172), cerebral palsy (N = 40) |
Vellappally et al. [43] | Cross-sectional | India | Fourteen special schools for disabled |
N total = 243; N ASD = 14 boys (60.1%), girls (39.9%) Age group: 12–18 years-old Mean age 14.1 ± 2.0 |
Not reported |
Dental Aesthetic Index Examiner: N.I Clinical calibration: reproducibility = 90% Examination conditions: N.I |
Inclusion criteria Ages ≥ 12 and < 19 years, intelligence Quotient (IQ) ≤ 85 Exclusion criteria Inability to cooperate in the oral examination, history of orthodontic treatment |
Yes Intellectual disability (ID) alone (N = 108), ID and cerebral palsy (N = 55), Down’s syndrome (N = 36), ID and a learning disability (N = 18) and ID and a speech-hearing impairment (N = 12) |
Du et al. [44] | Cross-sectional | China | Nineteen special child care centres |
N total = 514; N ASD = 257 boys (84.4%), girls (15.6%) Age group: 2.7–6.4 years-old Mean age = 4.9 ± 0.8 |
Not reported |
Deep overbite, anterior open bite, increased overjet, anterior crossbite and posterior crossbite Examiner: N.I Clinical calibration: Kappa > 0.70 Examination conditions: chair using an intra-oral mirror with a LED light source |
None |
Yes Children without ASD (N = 257) |
Alkhadra [45] | Cross-sectional | Kingdom of Saudi Arabia | Five rehabilitation centres for disabled children |
N total = 72; N ASD = 55 boys (72.7%) girls (27.3%) Age group: 6–14 years-old |
Medical records |
Angle’s classification, overjet, overbite, incisor open bite, cross bite in the right and left side on both anterior and posterior Examiner: N.I Clinical calibration: N.I Examination conditions: portable chair under natural light using a disposable mouth mirror and tongue blade |
Exclusion criteria History of ongoing medical treatment, extraction, and orthodontic treatment |
Yes Children with Down syndrome (N = 100) |
Fontaine-Sylvestre et al. [46] | Cross-sectional | Canada | Division of dentistry, children's hospital |
N total = 200; N ASD = 99 boys (78.8%), girls (21.2%) Age group: 5–18 years-old Mean age = 11.0 ± 3.7 |
Medical diagnosis |
Angle's classification, midline deviation, crossbite, open bite, overbite, crowding, Examiner: N.I Clinical calibration: N.I Examination conditions: dental chair |
Inclusion criteria Age between 5 to 18 years Mixed or permanent dentition Exclusion criteria Another disorder or syndrome than ASD, history of orthodontic treatment, Incomplete files with respect to the child's diagnosis of ASD |
Yes Children without ASD (N = 101) |
Alkhabuli et al.[47] | Cross-sectional | United Arab Emirates | Rehabilitation centres for disabled children |
N total = 54; N ASD = 9 boys (70.4%) girls (29.6%) Age group: 3–17 years-old |
Medical records |
Angle’s classification, crowding; spacing, anterior open bite, IOTN Examiner: N.I Clinical calibration: Kappa = 0.83 Examination conditions: adjustable chair using torchlight, dental explorer, and mouth mirror |
Inclusion criteria Age ≤ 17 years |
No |
Kuter and Guler [48] | Cross-sectional | Turkey | Regular schools |
N total = 407; N ASD = 285 boys (80%), girls (20%) Age group: 5–16 years-old |
Not reported |
crowding, open bite, deep-palate Examiner: N.I Clinical calibration: N.I Examination conditions: chair using dental mirror and explorer |
None |
Yes Children without ASD (N = 122) |
Leiva-Garcia et al. [49] | Cross-sectional | Spain | Rehabilitation centre for disabled children |
N total = 146; N ASD = 55 boys (74%), girls (26%) Age group: 6–18 years-old Mean age = 10.7 ± 3.0 |
Medical diagnosis |
Angle's classification, open bite, crossbite Examiner: one pediatric dentist Clinical calibration: Kappa = 0.80 Examination conditions: chair under natural light and using a sterile exploration kit comprising an oral probe and mirror, and cotton tips |
Exclusion criteria Special diets, food allergies or medications capable of modifying dietary intake and oral health |
Yes Children with typical development (N = 91) |
Orellana et al. [50] | Cross-sectional | Chile | Institutions for people with ASD |
N ASD = 123 boys (82.9%), girls (17.1%) Age group: 4–23 years-old Mean age = 9.4 ± 4.3 |
Not reported |
Deep/ogival palate, anterior open bite, anterior and posterior crossbite Examiner: dentists Clinical calibration: Kappa > 0.81 Examination conditions: portable dental chair and lamp |
Inclusion criteria Understanding very simple instructions |
No |
Mangione et al. [51] | Cross-sectional | France | special dental care department Division of Dentistry of University |
N ASD = 118 boys (75.4%), girls (24.6%) Age group: 4–53 years-old Mean age = 23.3 |
Medical records |
mild to severe dental and/or alveolar malocclusions Examiner: N.I Clinical calibration: N.I Examination conditions: dental chairs |
None | No |
Bagattoni et al. [52] | Cross-sectional | Italy | Special Needs Dentistry Unit of University |
N total = 128, N ASD = 64 boys (66%), girls (34%) Age group: 9.0 ± 2.9 years |
Medical diagnosis |
Angle’s classification, posterior crossbite, anterior open bite and deep bite Examiner: dentists Clinical calibration: N.I Examination conditions: dental chair using a dental mirror and a WHO periodontal probe |
Exclusion criteria: Medical condition associated with oral diseases, inability to cooperate in the oral examination, dental prophylaxis in the previous 6 months, history of orthodontic treatment |
Children without ASD (N = 64) |
*Diagnostic methods of ASD and non-ASDs were not considered as eligibility criteria
N.I.: not informed