Skip to main content
. 2022 Aug 3;19(15):9559. doi: 10.3390/ijerph19159559

Table 1.

Characteristics of the included studies.

Study Population Groups Interventions Exercise Intervention Protocols Outcomes
Session Duration (min) IT Work/Rest Ratio Frequency Total Training Time (min)
Healthy participants
Ballesta-Garcia, 2019 [11] Healthy adults WB-HIIT vs. WB-MIIT vs. CTL
  • WB-HIIT: Whole-body exercises at high RPEs

  • WB-MIIT: Whole-body exercises at moderate RPE

  • CTL: No exercise

WB-HIIT: 18–40
WB-MIIT: 18–50
WB-HIIT: 60–90″/120–150″ WB-HIIT: 16 wks, 2×/wk
WB-MIIT: 16 wks, 2×/wk
WB-HIIT: 928
WB-MIIT: 1088
MSF
Ballesta-Garcia, 2020 [12] Healthy adults WB-HIIT vs. WB-MIIT vs. CTL
  • WB-HIIT: Whole-body exercises at high RPEs

  • WB-MIIT: Whole-body exercises at moderate RPE

  • CTL: No exercise

WB-HIIT: 18–40
WB-MIIT: 18–50
WB-HIIT: 60–90″/120–150″ WB-HIIT: 16 wks, 2×/wk
WB-MIIT: 16 wks, 2×/wk
WB-HIIT: 928
WB-MIIT: 1088
CRF
Blackwell et al., 2017 [20] Healthy adults WB-HIIT vs. HIIT
  • WB-HIIT: Whole-body exercises

  • HIIT: Cycling at 95–110% Wmax

WB-HIIT: 11
HIIT: 11
WB-HIIT: 60″/90″
HIIT: 60″/90″
WB-HIIT: 4 wks, 3×/wk
HIIT: 4 wks, 3×/w
WB-HIIT: 132
HIIT: 132
CRF, Metabolic risk factors
* Connolly et al., 2020 [18] Healthy adults WB-HIIT vs. CTL
  • WB-HIIT: Whole-body exercises

  • CTL: No exercise

WB-HIIT: 15 WB-HIIT: 30″ low/20″ moderate/10″ high intensity WB-HIIT: 12 wks, 3×/wk WB-HIIT: 540 Metabolic risk factors
Engel et al., 2019 [22] Healthy adults WB-HIIT vs. CTL
  • WB-HIIT: Whole-body exercises with suspension trainer

  • CTL: No exercise

WB-HIIT: 30 WB-HIIT: 20″/10″ WB-HIIT: 8 wks, 2×/wk WB-HIIT: 480 MSF, Metabolic risk factors
Evangelista et al., 2019 [23] Healthy adults WB-HIIT vs. VICT
  • WB-HIIT: Whole-body exercises

  • VICT: Running at 80% HRmax

WB-HIIT: 20
VICT: 20
WB-HIIT: 30″/30″ WB-HIIT: 6 wks, 3×/wk
VICT: 6 wks, 3×/wk
WB-HIIT: 360
VICT: 360
Fat mass, Fat-free mass, MSF
Evangelista et al., 2021 [24] Healthy adults WB-HIIT vs. CTL
  • WB-HIIT: Whole-body exercises

WB-HIIT: 21 WB-HIIT: 40″/20″ Wb-HIIT: 6 wks, 3×/wk WB-HIIT: 378 CRF, MSF
Islam et al., 2019 [25] Healthy adults WB-HIIT vs. VICT vs. CTL
  • WB-HIIT: Whole-body exercises

  • VICT: Running at 85% HRmax

  • CTL: No exercise

WB-HIIT: 4
VICT: 30
WB-HIIT: 20″/10″ WB-HIIT: 4 wks, 4×/wk
VICT: 4 wks, 4×/wk
WB-HIIT: 60
VICT: 480
CRF, MSF
Jimenez-Garcia et al., 2019 [21] Healthy adults WB-HIIT vs. WB-MIIT vs. CTL
  • WB-HIIT: Squats using TRX® at 90–95% HRmax

  • WB-MIIT: Squats using TRX® at 50–70% HRmax

  • CTL: No exercise

WB-HIIT: 25
WB-MIIT: 25
WB-HIIT: 4′/3′
WB-MIIT: 4′/3′
WB-HIIT: 12 wks, 2×/wk
WB-MIIT: 12 wks, 2×/wk
WB-HIIT: 600
WB-MIIT: 600
Fat mass, Fat-free mass, MSF
Lu et al., 2021 [26] Healthy adults WB-HIIT vs. HIIT
  • WB-HIIT: Whole-body exercises

  • HIIT: Running

WB-HIIT: 4
HIIT: 4
WB-HIIT: 20″/10″
HIIT:30″/30″
WB-HIIT: 12 wks, 3×/wk
HIIT: 12 wks, 3×/wk
WB-HIIT: 144
HIIT: 144
CRF, Fat mass, Fat-free mass, MSF
* McRae et al., 2012 [16] Healthy adults WB-HIIT vs. VICT vs. CTL
  • WB-HIIT: Whole-body exercises

  • CT: Running at 85% HRmax

  • CTL: No exercise

WB-HIIT: 4
VICT: 30
WB-HIIT: 20″/10″ WB-HIIT: 4 wks, 4×/wk
CT: 4 wks, 4×/wk
WB-HIIT: 48
CT: 480
CRF, MSF
Menz et al., 2019 [27] Healthy adults WB-HIIT vs. HIIT
  • WB-HIIT: Whole-body exercises

  • HIIT: Running

WB-HIIT: 12–16
HIIT: 12–16
WB-HIIT: 20″/10″
HIIT: 20″/10″
WB-HIIT: 4 wks, 3–4×/wk
HIIT: 4 wks, 3–4×/wk
WB-HIIT: 191
HIIT: 191
CRF, Fat mass, Fat-free mass, MSF
Micielska et al., 2019 [28] Healthy adults WB-HIIT vs. CTL
  • WB-HIIT: Whole-body exercises

  • CTL: Whole-body exercises

WB-HIIT: 25 WB-HIIT: 30″/10″ WB-HIIT: 5 wks, 3×/wk
CTL: 2 sessions
WB-HIIT: 325
CTL: 50
CRF, Fat mass, Fat-free mass
Murawska-Cialowicz et al., 2020 [29] Healthy adults WB-HIIT vs. CTL
  • WB-HIIT: Whole-body exercises

  • CTL: No exercise

WB-HIIT: 40 WB-HIIT: 20″/10″ WB-HIIT: 8 wks, 2×/wk WB-HIIT: 640 CRF, Fat mass, Fat-free mass
Schaun et al., 2018 [13] Healthy adults WB-HIIT vs. HIIT vs. VICT
  • WB-HIIT: Whole-body exercises

  • HIIT: Running at 130% VO2 max

  • VICT: Running at 90–95% VT2

WB-HIIT: 8
HIIT: 8
VICT: 30
WB-HIIT: 20″/10″
HIIT: 20″/10″
WB-HIIT: 16 wks, 3×/wk
HIIT: 16 wks, 3×/wk
VICT: 16 wks, 3×/wk
WB-HIIT: 384
HIIT: 384
VICT: 1440
CRF, Fat mass
Schaun et al.,
2019 [14]
Healthy adults WB-HIIT vs. HIIT vs. VICT
  • WB-HIIT: Whole-body exercises

  • HIIT: Running at 130% VO2 max)

  • VICT: Running at 90–95% VT2

WB-HIIT: 8
HIIT: 8
VICT: 30
WB-HIIT: 20″/10″
HIIT: 20″/10″
WB-HIIT: 16 wks, 3×/wk
HIIT: 16 wks, 3×/wk
VICT: 16 wks, 3×/wk
WB-HIIT: 384
HIIT: 384
VICT: 1440
MSF
Schmidt et al., 2016 [30] Healthy adults WB-HIIT vs. CTL
  • WB-HIIT: Whole-body exercises

  • CTL: No exercise

WB-HIIT 7: 1 × 7
WB-HIIT 14: 1 × 7 (wk 1–4), 2 × 7 (wk 5–8)
WB-HIIT: 30″/10″ WB-HIIT 7: 8 wks, 3×/wk
WB-HIIT 14: 8 wks, 3×/wk
WB-HIIT 7: 168
WB-HIIT 14: 252
CRF, Fat mass, MSF
Sperlich et al., 2018 [31] Healthy adults WB-HIIT LV vs. WB-HIIT HV vs. CTL
  • WB-HIIT LV: Whole-body exercises (1×/day)

  • WB-HIIT HV: Whole-body exercises (2×/day)

  • CTL: No exercise

WB-HIIT LV: 1 × 6
WB-HIIT HV: 2 × 6
WB-HIIT LV: Not specified (6 min circuit)
WB-HIIT HV: Not specified (6 min circuit)
WB-HIIT LV: 4 wks, 7×/wk
WB-HIIT HV: 4 wks, 14×/wk
WB-HIIT LV: 168
WB-HIIT HV: 336
CRF, Fat mass, Fat-free mass, MSF
* Wilke et al., 2019 [17] Healthy adults WB-HIIT vs. MICT
  • WB-HIIT: Whole-body exercises

  • MICT: Walking at 50–60% HRR

WB-HIIT: 30
MICT: 50
WB-HIIT: 20″/10″ WB-HIIT: 6 wks, 3×/wk
MICT: 6 wks, 3×/wk
WB-HIIT: 540
MICT: 900
CRF, MSF
Specific populations
Batrakoulis et al., 2018 [32] Obese women WB-HIIT vs. CTL
  • WB-HIIT: Whole-body exercises

  • CTL: No exercise

WB-HIIT: 23–41 WB-HIIT: 20″/40″ WB-HIIT: 20 wks, 3×/wk WB-HIIT: 1761 CRF, Fat mass, Fat-free mass, MSF
Jung et al., 2019 [33] Women with sarcopenia WB-HIIT vs. CTL
  • WB-HIIT: Whole-body exercises

  • CTL: No exercise

WB-HIIT: 25–55 WB-HIIT: 10″/5″ WB-HIIT: 12 wks, 3×/wk WB-HIIT: 1440 Fat mass, Fat-free mass
Scott et al., 2019 [34] Obese adults WB-HIIT vs. HIIT vs. MICT
  • WB-HIIT: Whole-body exercises at >80% theorical HRmax

  • HIIT: Cycling at 100% Wmax

  • MICT: Running/Cycling at 65% Theorical HRmax

WB-HIIT: 8–16
HIIT: 8–16
MICT: 30–50
WB-HIIT: 60″/60″
HIIT: 60″/60″
WB-HIIT: 12 wks, 3×/wk
HIIT: 12 wks, 3×/wk
MICT: 12 wks, 3×/wk
WB-HIIT: 432
HIIT: 432
MICT: 1440
CRF, Fat mass, Fat-free mass, Metabolic risk factors

CRF, cardiorespiratory fitness; CTL, control; HIIT, high-intensity interval training; HR, heart rate; HRR, heart rate reserve; HV, high volume; LV, low volume; MSF, musculoskeletal fitness; MICT, moderate-intensity continuous training; RPE, rate of perceived exertion; VICT, vigorous-intensity continuous training; VT2, second ventilatory threshold; WB-HIIT, whole-body high-intensity interval training; WB-MIIT, whole-body moderate intensity interval training; Wmax, maximal workload, wk(s), week(s), *, excluded from the meta-analysis.