Skip to main content
. 2022 Aug 4;19(15):9599. doi: 10.3390/ijerph19159599

Table 2.

Study characteristics of included studies.

Study ID Place of Study Sample Size Teeth/Patient Age Range
(Years)
Pathology of Teeth Type of Teeth Pulp Vitality Tests Pulp Sensibility Tests Authors’ Conclusions
Gopikrishna et al., 2007 [7] India 80/80 Not reported Requiring endodontic therapy for prosthodontic considerations or for irreversible pulpitis Single-rooted incisors, canines and premolars PO CT
EPT
Custom-built pulse oximeter dental probe is an effective, accurate and objective method of determining the vitality of permanent teeth.
Karayilmaz and Kirzioğlu, 2011 [10] Turkey 59/51 12–18 Root canal treated Maxillary anterior teeth LDF
PO
EPT LDF was found to be a more reliable and effective method than PO and EPT for assessing the pulpal status of human teeth.
Dastmalchi et al., 2012 [11] Iran 24/24 18–50 Requiring endodontic treatment for prosthodontic reasons Single-canal mandibular premolars PO CT
HT
EPT
PO is a reliable method in determining the actual status of the pulp in endodontics; however, CT, HT and EPT are not suitable methods for pulp testing.
Janani et al., 2020 [12] India 79 18–56 Requiring endodontic therapy Single-rooted teeth PO CT
HT
EPT
Customized pulse oximeter sensor holder proves to be accurate, reliable and objective in assessing the actual condition of the tooth.
Chen and Abbott, 2011 [16] Australia 121/20 18–74 Suspected or known to have pulp pathosis; previously received or currently undergoing endodontic treatment; or provisionally diagnosed as having a healthy pulp Not reported LDF CT
EPT
Carbon dioxide (CO2) crystals, EPT and LDF were reliable and the most accurate tests, but CO2 and EPT were less repeatable yet less time consuming than LDF.
Samuel et al., 2014 [25] India 120/30 7–18 Free of any dental pathology Permanent maxillary central and lateral incisors PO CT
EPT
In young children, PO method was found to be as accurate as cold test but large variations were seen in electric pulp test.
Condit, 2015 [26] Columbus, US 85 6–16 Traumatized teeth Maxillary central and lateral incisors LDF CT
EPT
LDF could not distinguish between healthy and necrotic pulp tissue among traumatized teeth.
Sharma et al., 2015 [27] India Not reported 4–15 Requiring endodontic therapy Not reported PO EPT PO is an objective, very sensitive and noninvasive method that can be used as a routine method for assessing the pulp vitality in primary, young permanent and mature permanent teeth.
Ghouth et al., 2019 [28] UK 37 8–16 Root canal treated Permanent anterior teeth LDF CT
EPT
LDF was unable to differentiate between teeth with vital and nonvital pulps in children between the ages of 8 and 16 years, with an acceptable level of confidence.
Ajitha et al., 2020 [29] India 30 18–50 Requiring endodontic therapy indicative of irreversible pulpitis Single-canal incisors, canine and mandibular premolar teeth PO CT
HT
EPT
The use of custom-made holder is effective in placement of sensor probe onto the tooth surface. It aided in evaluating the actual pulp status by producing accurate interpretation of results.