Skip to main content
. 2022 Jul 15;12(5):593–598. doi: 10.1016/j.jobcr.2022.07.003

Table 2.

A table summarising the advantages and disadvantages of some common autologous reconstructive options.

Reconstruction Advantages Disadvantages
Non-Vascularised
  • -

    Appropriate calibre and shape

  • -

    Unpredictable growth

  • -

    Costochondral

  • -

    Adaptable bone

  • -

    Late asymmetry/facial deformity

  • -

    Can be harvested with cartilaginous cap

  • -

    Resorption or heterotrophic bone

  • -

    Low donor site morbidity

  • -

    Increased risk of ankylosis in adults

  • -

    Potential for growth

  • -

    Donor site risk of pneumothorax

  • -

    Sterno-clavicular

  • -

    Composite osseo-chondral tissue

  • -

    Limited long term outcome data

  • -

    Histologically similar to condyle

  • -

    Significant donor site morbidity that can affect shoulder function

  • -

    Iliac Crest

  • -

    Obvious scar

  • -

    Good quality bone stock

  • -

    Donor site complications e.g. hernia

  • -

    Well established harvesting technique

  • -

    No cartilaginous tissue

  • -

    Limited thickness of bone

  • -

    Calvarium

  • -

    Minimal functional effect at donor site

  • -

    Bone only graft

Vascularised
  • -

    Good quality and appropriate calibre bone stock

  • -

    No cartilaginous tissue

  • -

    Fibula

  • -

    Reliable segmental blood supply

  • -

    Requires intra-operative shaping to create condylar morphology and vertical height

  • -

    Low functional donor site morbidity

  • -

    Limited length of bone

  • -

    Long term outcome data

  • -

    Short pedicle

  • -

    Descending circumflex Iliac artery (DCIA) free flap

  • -

    Good quality and ample bone stock

  • -

    Donor site morbidity

  • -

    Micro-surgically reliable

  • -

    Thin bone without segmental supply

  • -

    Scapular

  • -

    Versatile flap with options for chimerism and a variety of soft tissue connotations

  • -

    Intra-operative patient positioning restrictions