Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2023 Jul 12.
Published in final edited form as: IEEE Trans Biomed Circuits Syst. 2022 Jul 12;16(3):395–408. doi: 10.1109/TBCAS.2022.3175926

TABLE III.

Comparision with Previous Work

References Tdis work [47] [61] [62] [63] [10] [64] [21] [31]
Type ASIC external wired MCU external wired ASIC external wireless ASIC implanted wireless ASIC implanted wireless ASIC implanted wired
Amplifier Bandwidth 300–1000 Hz 300–1000 Hz 100–7800 Hz 500–5000 Hz N/A 300–7000 Hz
Number of Channels 93 96 97 100 128 15
Sampling Frequency 2 kSps 2 kSps 20 kSps 20 kSps 20 kSps 25 kSps
Feature Extraction SBP(CAR) SBP N/A N/A Spike firing rate* Spike firing rate*
Decoding SSKF continuous N/A N/A N/A Extreme Learning Machine (ELM) discrete (13 classes) Spiking neural network discrete (63 classes)
Subject model NHP NHP Human & NHP NHP NHP (No in-vivo) Rodent (No in-vivo)
Data-Rate
Reduction
4,800× (1D)
2,325× (2D)
100× 1× (recording only) 1× (recording only) 1000× 768×
Data Format 16b fixed-point 32b floating point 12b fixed-point 12b fixed-point 7b fixed-point 8b fixed-point
Process 180 nm - 500,180 nm 600 nm 350 nm 180 nm
Power 0.581 mW (1D) / 0.588 mW (2D) RHD2132s: 12 mW 33.6 mW 51 mW 90.6 mW Mixed-signal computing array: 0.4 μW** Mixed-signal computing array: 4 mW**
*

Off-chip feature extraction used.

**

Power of MCU, AFE, TX/RX not included.