Skip to main content
. 2020 Oct 27;67(1):46–58. [Article in French] doi: 10.1111/idj.12254

Table 4.

Quality assessment of included studies

Study Selection bias Study design Data-collection methods Global rating
Abelsen & Olsen26 Moderate Strong Strong Strong
Adams54 Moderate Strong Moderate Strong
Ayers et al.55 Strong Strong Strong Strong
Benicewicz & Metzger56 Moderate Strong Moderate Strong
Blue et al.24 Weak Weak Moderate Weak
Gordon & Rayner57 Moderate Moderate Moderate Strong
Hopcraft et al.25 Moderate Strong Moderate Strong
Kaldenberg & Smith58 Moderate Strong Moderate Strong
Lambert et al.59 Moderate Strong Strong Strong
Moffat & Coates60 Moderate Strong Moderate Strong
Murtomaa & Haugejorden61 Strong Strong Moderate Strong
Sgan-Cohen et al.62 Weak Weak Weak Weak
Van Dam et al.63 Weak Weak Weak Weak
Van Wyk et al.42 Moderate Strong Strong Strong