Skip to main content
. 2022 Aug 12;14:441–456. doi: 10.2147/OAEM.S361676

Table 1.

Summary Measures

Number Title Authors Year Country Sample (Size) Control Group (Size) Independent Variables Dependent Variables Study Design Results
1. Predictors of Emergency Room and Hospital Utilization Among Adults with Intellectual and Developmental Disabilities23 Blaskowitz, M. G.; Hernandez, B.; Scott, P. W. 2019 USA Adults with intellectual and developmental disability
n: 597
None Age, gender, level of intellectual disability, chronic health
problems, mental health diagnoses, polypharmacy, supported living arrangement, region
ER use for a medical/physical reason, hospitalization for a medical/physical reason, ER use for a behavioral/psychiatric reason, hospitalization for a behavioral/psychiatric reason Prevalence study,
secondary data: survey of medical charts
Predictors (environmental and individual risk factors) for ED use: institutionalized people are less likely to be admitted; people from deprived neighborhoods with a lack of care are less likely to visit the ED
2. Rate and characteristics of urgent hospitalization in persons with profound intellectual disabilities compared with general population24 Amor-Salamanca, A.; Menchon, J. M. 2018 Spain Adults with severe/ profound intellectual disability
n: 28
Other hospitalized ED patients
n: 83
Gender, age, living arrangement Emergency visits, admission to hospital after emergency visit Retrospective cohort study,
secondary data: discharge reports
No differences in the proportion of people with profound intellectual disability and controls admitted to hospital after their emergency visit; the median hospital stay was higher for people with profound intellectual disability s: 7.5 vs 4 days for controls
3. Factors associated with ambulatory care sensitive emergency department visits for South Carolina Medicaid members with intellectual disability25 McDermott, S.; Royer, J. A.; Mann, J. R.; Armour, B. S. 2018 USA Individuals with intellectual disability identified from ICD-9 CM codes
n: 14.650
Subgrouping: moderate-to-profound intellectual disability (37. 8%), mild
intellectual disability (33.8%), unspecified intellectual disability (16.4%), Down
syndrome/other genetic causes (11.9%)
age, race, sex, rurality of county, residential service setting, years of enrollment, supplemental nutrition assistance Primary care visits, ED visits, and subsequent inpatient hospital admission, timing of services Retrospective cohort study,
secondary data: discharge dataset
ED overuse of intellectual disability subgroups due to conditions that are manageable in primary care; living in the community, comorbidity, and previous primary care were associated with more frequent ED visits
4. Postpartum Hospital Utilization among Massachusetts Women with Intellectual and Developmental Disabilities: A Retrospective Cohort Study26 Mitra, M.; Parish, S. L.; Akobirshoev, I.; Rosenthal, E.; Moore Simas, T. A. 2018 USA Women with intellectual and developmental disability identified from ICD-9 CM codes
n: 1104
Women without intellectual and developmental disability
n: 778,409
Woman who gave birth, maternal age, race/ethnicity, education, marital status, type of health insurance, adequacy of prenatal care, diseases Postpartum hospital admissions, ED visits during three critical postpartum periods (1–42, 43–90, and 1–365 days), nondelivered hospitalizations, observational stays Retrospective cohort study, secondary data: Massachusetts Pregnancy to
Early Life Longitudinal Data System (PELL)
Women with intellectual and developmental disability had markedly higher rates of postpartum hospital admissions and ED visits after a childbirth
5. Antenatal Hospitalization Among US Women with Intellectual and Developmental Disabilities: A Retrospective Cohort Study27 Mitra, M.; Parish, S. L.; Clements, K. M.; Zhang, J.; Moore Simas, T. A. 2018 USA Women with intellectual and developmental disability identified from ICD-9 CM
n: 498
Women without intellectual and developmental disability
n: 1,531
Women who gave birth, maternal age, education, race/ethnicity, marital status, health insurance; father named on the birth certificate; adequacy of prenatal care utilization, smoking during pregnancy, diseases Hospital utilization during pregnancy: ED visit, observational stays, and non-delivery hospital stays Retrospective cohort study, secondary data: Massachusetts Pregnancy to Early Life Longitudinal Data System (PELL) Higher likelihood of women with intellectual and developmental disability to visit ED or get hospitalized during pregnancy
6. Postpartum Acute Care Utilization Among Women with Intellectual and Developmental Disabilities28 Brown, H. K.; Cobigo, V.; Lunsky, Y.; Vigod, S. 2017 Canada Women with intellectual and developmental disability
n: 3803
Women without intellectual and developmental disability
n: 378,313
Women who gave birth, maternal age, parity, neighborhood income quintile, region of residence, preexisting diseases, diseases during pregnancy Postpartum hospital admissions, ED visits Retrospective cohort study, secondary data: Ontario (Canada) health and social services administrative data Women with intellectual and developmental disability, compared to those without, had an increased risk for postpartum hospital admissions overall, for psychiatric reasons but not for medical reasons
7. Emergency department and inpatient hospitalizations for young people with fragile X syndrome29 McDermott, S.; Hardin, J. W.; Royer, J. A.; Mann, J. R.; Tong, X.; Ozturk, O. D.; Ouyang, L. 2015 USA Adolescents and young adults with fragile x syndrome, identified from ICD-9 CM
n: 125 (fragile x syndrome)
Adolescents and young adults with intellectual disability, people with autism spectrum disorder identified from ICD-9 CM. people without disability
n: 2,592 (autism spectrum disorder) 10,685 (intellectual disability)
Gender, age, and insurance coverage Hospital encounters Prevalence study, secondary data: state’s health and human services data, hospital discharge dataset People with fragile x syndrome, autism spectrum disorder, or intellectual disability are more likely to have had hospital encounters
8. Predictors of emergency department visits by persons with intellectual disability experiencing a psychiatric crisis30 Lunsky, Y.; Balogh, R.; Cairney, J. 2012 Canada Adults with intellectual disability who visited ED in response to a crisis
n: 96
Adults with intellectual disability who did not visit ED in response to a crisis
n:480
Persons who visited the ED in response to the first crisis, people who did not visit the ED in response to the first crises Predictors of ED use: level of disability, type of residence, crisis plan, family physician, history of involvement with the criminal justice system, and history of ED visits Cohort study, primary data: staff assessment Significant predictors of ED visits: level of disability, type of residence, crisis plan, family physician, history of involvement with the criminal justice system, and history of ED visits
9. Quantifying emergency department admission rates for people with a learning disability31 Williamson, T.; Flowers, J.; Cooke, M. 2012 UK Persons with learning disability identified from the ICD-10
n: 246
None Age, sex Hospital admission via ED Prevalence study, secondary data: Admission data from Birmingham Heartlands Hospital Admission rates of patients with learning disability
10. Life events and emergency department visits in response to crisis in individuals with intellectual disabilities32 Lunsky, Y.; Elserafi, J. 2011 Canada Adults with intellectual disability who visited ED in response to a crisis
n: 96
Adults with intellectual disability who did not visit ED in response to a crisis
n:480
Stressful life events Hospital use Cohort study, primary data:
Informants provided data (Psychiatric Assessment for Adults with Developmental Disabilities Checklist)
Individuals experiencing life events in the past year were more likely to visit the ED in response to crisis than those who did not experience any life events
11. The Impact of Medicaid Managed Care on Health Service Utilization Among Adults with Intellectual and Developmental Disabilities33 Yamaki, K.; Wing, C.; Mitchell, D.; Owen, R.; Heller, T. 2019 USA People with intellectual and developmental disability from a region that reformed Medicaid
n: 1,121
People with intellectual and developmental disability from a different region
n:1,102
Transition from fee-for-service to Medicaid managed care Utilization of ED and/or primary care physicians, inpatient hospitalization Quasi-experiment, secondary data: state Medicaid agency, integrated care program Medicaid managed care reduced avoidable ED visits (manageable conditions, mental conditions)
12. Emergency Department Use: Common Presenting Issues and Continuity of Care for Individuals with and without Intellectual and Developmental Disabilities34 Durbin, A.; Balogh, R.; Lin, E.; Wilton, A. S.; Lunsky, Y.24 2018 Canada Adults with intellectual and developmental disability
n: 66,484
Adults without intellectual and developmental disability
n: 2,760,670
Level of continuity of primary care ED visits Retrospective cohort study, secondary data: administrative health and social services data Individuals with intellectual and developmental disability were more likely than individuals with no intellectual and developmental disability to visit the ED; for both groups, greater primary care continuity was associated with less ED use, but this relationship was more marked for adults with intellectual and developmental disability
13. Use of health services in the last year of life and cause of death in people with intellectual disability: a retrospective matched cohort study35 Brameld, K.; Spilsbury, K.; Rosenwax, L.; Leonard, H.; Semmens, J.25 2018 Australia Decedents with intellectual disability identified from ICD
n: 591
Decedents without intellectual disability
n: 29,713
Cause of death ED visit, hospital admissions Retrospective cohort study, secondary data: Data Linkage Branch, Western Australian Department
of Health, Intellectual Disability
Exploring Answers (IDEA) Database
People with intellectual disability had increased odds of presentation, admission, or death from conditions that have been defined as ambulatory care sensitive and are potentially preventable
14. Pain underreporting associated with profound intellectual disability in emergency departments36 Amor-Salamanca, A.; Menchon, J. M. 2017 Spain Persons with profound intellectual disability
n: 100
Patients without profound intellectual disability
n: 300
Age, gender Reasons and diagnoses in ED, patients behaviour while
travelling to the hospital, time spent waiting and being examined in the ED
Retrospective cohort study, secondary data: clinical report from the ED, primary data: interview conducted by the person who had accompanied the patient to the hospital Somatic complaints were the main reason for ED attendance among persons with profound intellectual disability; a diagnosis implying physical pain was given less often to people with profound intellectual disability than to controls

Abbreviations: ED-Emergency Department, ER-Emergency Room, CD-International Classification of Disease.