Table 1.
Summary Measures
Number | Title | Authors | Year | Country | Sample (Size) | Control Group (Size) | Independent Variables | Dependent Variables | Study Design | Results |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1. | Predictors of Emergency Room and Hospital Utilization Among Adults with Intellectual and Developmental Disabilities23 | Blaskowitz, M. G.; Hernandez, B.; Scott, P. W. | 2019 | USA | Adults with intellectual and developmental disability n: 597 |
None | Age, gender, level of intellectual disability, chronic health problems, mental health diagnoses, polypharmacy, supported living arrangement, region |
ER use for a medical/physical reason, hospitalization for a medical/physical reason, ER use for a behavioral/psychiatric reason, hospitalization for a behavioral/psychiatric reason | Prevalence study, secondary data: survey of medical charts |
Predictors (environmental and individual risk factors) for ED use: institutionalized people are less likely to be admitted; people from deprived neighborhoods with a lack of care are less likely to visit the ED |
2. | Rate and characteristics of urgent hospitalization in persons with profound intellectual disabilities compared with general population24 | Amor-Salamanca, A.; Menchon, J. M. | 2018 | Spain | Adults with severe/ profound intellectual disability n: 28 |
Other hospitalized ED patients n: 83 |
Gender, age, living arrangement | Emergency visits, admission to hospital after emergency visit | Retrospective cohort study, secondary data: discharge reports |
No differences in the proportion of people with profound intellectual disability and controls admitted to hospital after their emergency visit; the median hospital stay was higher for people with profound intellectual disability s: 7.5 vs 4 days for controls |
3. | Factors associated with ambulatory care sensitive emergency department visits for South Carolina Medicaid members with intellectual disability25 | McDermott, S.; Royer, J. A.; Mann, J. R.; Armour, B. S. | 2018 | USA | Individuals with intellectual disability identified from ICD-9 CM codes n: 14.650 |
Subgrouping: moderate-to-profound intellectual disability (37. 8%), mild intellectual disability (33.8%), unspecified intellectual disability (16.4%), Down syndrome/other genetic causes (11.9%) |
age, race, sex, rurality of county, residential service setting, years of enrollment, supplemental nutrition assistance | Primary care visits, ED visits, and subsequent inpatient hospital admission, timing of services | Retrospective cohort study, secondary data: discharge dataset |
ED overuse of intellectual disability subgroups due to conditions that are manageable in primary care; living in the community, comorbidity, and previous primary care were associated with more frequent ED visits |
4. | Postpartum Hospital Utilization among Massachusetts Women with Intellectual and Developmental Disabilities: A Retrospective Cohort Study26 | Mitra, M.; Parish, S. L.; Akobirshoev, I.; Rosenthal, E.; Moore Simas, T. A. | 2018 | USA | Women with intellectual and developmental disability identified from ICD-9 CM codes n: 1104 |
Women without intellectual and developmental disability n: 778,409 |
Woman who gave birth, maternal age, race/ethnicity, education, marital status, type of health insurance, adequacy of prenatal care, diseases | Postpartum hospital admissions, ED visits during three critical postpartum periods (1–42, 43–90, and 1–365 days), nondelivered hospitalizations, observational stays | Retrospective cohort study, secondary data: Massachusetts Pregnancy to Early Life Longitudinal Data System (PELL) |
Women with intellectual and developmental disability had markedly higher rates of postpartum hospital admissions and ED visits after a childbirth |
5. | Antenatal Hospitalization Among US Women with Intellectual and Developmental Disabilities: A Retrospective Cohort Study27 | Mitra, M.; Parish, S. L.; Clements, K. M.; Zhang, J.; Moore Simas, T. A. | 2018 | USA | Women with intellectual and developmental disability identified from ICD-9 CM n: 498 |
Women without intellectual and developmental disability n: 1,531 |
Women who gave birth, maternal age, education, race/ethnicity, marital status, health insurance; father named on the birth certificate; adequacy of prenatal care utilization, smoking during pregnancy, diseases | Hospital utilization during pregnancy: ED visit, observational stays, and non-delivery hospital stays | Retrospective cohort study, secondary data: Massachusetts Pregnancy to Early Life Longitudinal Data System (PELL) | Higher likelihood of women with intellectual and developmental disability to visit ED or get hospitalized during pregnancy |
6. | Postpartum Acute Care Utilization Among Women with Intellectual and Developmental Disabilities28 | Brown, H. K.; Cobigo, V.; Lunsky, Y.; Vigod, S. | 2017 | Canada | Women with intellectual and developmental disability n: 3803 |
Women without intellectual and developmental disability n: 378,313 |
Women who gave birth, maternal age, parity, neighborhood income quintile, region of residence, preexisting diseases, diseases during pregnancy | Postpartum hospital admissions, ED visits | Retrospective cohort study, secondary data: Ontario (Canada) health and social services administrative data | Women with intellectual and developmental disability, compared to those without, had an increased risk for postpartum hospital admissions overall, for psychiatric reasons but not for medical reasons |
7. | Emergency department and inpatient hospitalizations for young people with fragile X syndrome29 | McDermott, S.; Hardin, J. W.; Royer, J. A.; Mann, J. R.; Tong, X.; Ozturk, O. D.; Ouyang, L. | 2015 | USA | Adolescents and young adults with fragile x syndrome, identified from ICD-9 CM n: 125 (fragile x syndrome) |
Adolescents and young adults with intellectual disability, people with autism spectrum disorder identified from ICD-9 CM. people without disability n: 2,592 (autism spectrum disorder) 10,685 (intellectual disability) |
Gender, age, and insurance coverage | Hospital encounters | Prevalence study, secondary data: state’s health and human services data, hospital discharge dataset | People with fragile x syndrome, autism spectrum disorder, or intellectual disability are more likely to have had hospital encounters |
8. | Predictors of emergency department visits by persons with intellectual disability experiencing a psychiatric crisis30 | Lunsky, Y.; Balogh, R.; Cairney, J. | 2012 | Canada | Adults with intellectual disability who visited ED in response to a crisis n: 96 |
Adults with intellectual disability who did not visit ED in response to a crisis n:480 |
Persons who visited the ED in response to the first crisis, people who did not visit the ED in response to the first crises | Predictors of ED use: level of disability, type of residence, crisis plan, family physician, history of involvement with the criminal justice system, and history of ED visits | Cohort study, primary data: staff assessment | Significant predictors of ED visits: level of disability, type of residence, crisis plan, family physician, history of involvement with the criminal justice system, and history of ED visits |
9. | Quantifying emergency department admission rates for people with a learning disability31 | Williamson, T.; Flowers, J.; Cooke, M. | 2012 | UK | Persons with learning disability identified from the ICD-10 n: 246 |
None | Age, sex | Hospital admission via ED | Prevalence study, secondary data: Admission data from Birmingham Heartlands Hospital | Admission rates of patients with learning disability |
10. | Life events and emergency department visits in response to crisis in individuals with intellectual disabilities32 | Lunsky, Y.; Elserafi, J. | 2011 | Canada | Adults with intellectual disability who visited ED in response to a crisis n: 96 |
Adults with intellectual disability who did not visit ED in response to a crisis n:480 |
Stressful life events | Hospital use | Cohort study, primary data: Informants provided data (Psychiatric Assessment for Adults with Developmental Disabilities Checklist) |
Individuals experiencing life events in the past year were more likely to visit the ED in response to crisis than those who did not experience any life events |
11. | The Impact of Medicaid Managed Care on Health Service Utilization Among Adults with Intellectual and Developmental Disabilities33 | Yamaki, K.; Wing, C.; Mitchell, D.; Owen, R.; Heller, T. | 2019 | USA | People with intellectual and developmental disability from a region that reformed Medicaid n: 1,121 |
People with intellectual and developmental disability from a different region n:1,102 |
Transition from fee-for-service to Medicaid managed care | Utilization of ED and/or primary care physicians, inpatient hospitalization | Quasi-experiment, secondary data: state Medicaid agency, integrated care program | Medicaid managed care reduced avoidable ED visits (manageable conditions, mental conditions) |
12. | Emergency Department Use: Common Presenting Issues and Continuity of Care for Individuals with and without Intellectual and Developmental Disabilities34 | Durbin, A.; Balogh, R.; Lin, E.; Wilton, A. S.; Lunsky, Y.24 | 2018 | Canada | Adults with intellectual and developmental disability n: 66,484 |
Adults without intellectual and developmental disability n: 2,760,670 |
Level of continuity of primary care | ED visits | Retrospective cohort study, secondary data: administrative health and social services data | Individuals with intellectual and developmental disability were more likely than individuals with no intellectual and developmental disability to visit the ED; for both groups, greater primary care continuity was associated with less ED use, but this relationship was more marked for adults with intellectual and developmental disability |
13. | Use of health services in the last year of life and cause of death in people with intellectual disability: a retrospective matched cohort study35 | Brameld, K.; Spilsbury, K.; Rosenwax, L.; Leonard, H.; Semmens, J.25 | 2018 | Australia | Decedents with intellectual disability identified from ICD n: 591 |
Decedents without intellectual disability n: 29,713 |
Cause of death | ED visit, hospital admissions | Retrospective cohort study, secondary data: Data Linkage Branch, Western Australian Department of Health, Intellectual Disability Exploring Answers (IDEA) Database |
People with intellectual disability had increased odds of presentation, admission, or death from conditions that have been defined as ambulatory care sensitive and are potentially preventable |
14. | Pain underreporting associated with profound intellectual disability in emergency departments36 | Amor-Salamanca, A.; Menchon, J. M. | 2017 | Spain | Persons with profound intellectual disability n: 100 |
Patients without profound intellectual disability n: 300 |
Age, gender | Reasons and diagnoses in ED, patients behaviour while travelling to the hospital, time spent waiting and being examined in the ED |
Retrospective cohort study, secondary data: clinical report from the ED, primary data: interview conducted by the person who had accompanied the patient to the hospital | Somatic complaints were the main reason for ED attendance among persons with profound intellectual disability; a diagnosis implying physical pain was given less often to people with profound intellectual disability than to controls |
Abbreviations: ED-Emergency Department, ER-Emergency Room, CD-International Classification of Disease.