Table 1. Characteristics of 13 studies included in the present article .
First author | Study design | Number of institutions | Number of participants and Type of participation |
Number and type of teams participated |
Fernandez 2020 |
Quantitative | 1 | 79 second- and third-year emergency medicine and general surgical residents at the University of Washington Trauma resuscitations were video recorded and coded using outcome measures. |
1 trauma team at the University of Washington |
MO 2019 |
Mixed | 1 | Phase 1. Quantitative: 21 members from trauma team were interviewed Phase 2. Quantitative: 64 members from trauma team completed DCE (Discrete Choice Experiment) questionnaire Trauma team included physicians (resident, fellow, or attending), nurses, x-ray technologists, respiratory therapists, etc. |
1 Pediatric trauma team |
Oza 2018 |
Mixed | 2 | Phase 1. Developing LOFT (Leadership Observation Feedback Tool): Internal medicine and pediatric residents were surveyed (20), completed a Delphi questionnaire (15) and participated in a pilot study (78). Phase 2. LOFT testing: 377 team members (attending physicians, fellows, and residents, nurses, pharmacists, medical students, and allied health professionals) completed LOFT for 95 residents. |
5 Clinical teams |
Stone 2017 |
Mixed | 1 | 7 surgeons and 82 non-surgeons (phase 1) and 5 surgeons and 105 non-surgeons (phase 2) were surveyed to measure surgical staff member perceptions and attitudes about themselves, their teams, and team dynamics. -Cases involving 7surgeons (phase1) and 4 surgeons (phase2) were observed to collect data about interactions between surgeons and non-surgeons during individual surgical procedures. - 7 surgeons and 116 team members were interviewed to gain insights on contextual influences underlying observed interactions Non-surgeons included scrub technicians/nurses, circulating nurses, physician assistants, perfusionists, anesthesiologists, and trainees (e.g. surgical fellows, anesthesia residents. |
Number not stated Surgical teams |
Leenstra 2016 | Mixed | 3 | 28 participants including 5 surgeons, 3 surgical residents, 8 emergency physicians, 1 resident emergency physician, 1 anesthesiologist, 2 anesthesiology residents and 8 emergency nurses, were interviewed (critical incident type). | Number not stated
Trauma teams |
Coolen 2015 |
Quantitative | 1 | 12 pediatric residents participated in 48 team simulations of a pediatric critical-care event. 38 residents were surveyed to assess the specific needs in leadership training as felt by them. |
Number not stated Pediatric emergency teams |
Parker 2014 |
Quantitative | 3 | Videos of 29 operations from Surgical teams (surgeons, surgical residents, nurses, anesthesiologists were analyzed. | Number not stated Surgical teams |
Parker 2013 |
Mixed | 1 | Phase 1. Qualitative: 106 participants, including surgeons, trainees, anesthetists, nurses participated in 10 focus groups. Phase 2. Testing taxonomy: 2 psychologists rated 5 videos of live surgery. |
1 Operating room team |
Grant 2012 |
Mixed | 5 | Phase 1.8 pediatric acute care physician educators (3 from emergency medicine, 4 from critical care, and one practicing in both subspecialties) from five pediatric tertiary care hospitals in Canada participated in a Delphi method to develop pediatric resuscitation team leader evaluation tool as members of an Expert Working Group (EWG). Phase 2. 30 residents on two videotaped scenarios were assessed by 4 pediatricians using pediatric resuscitation team leader evaluation tool for Instrument psychometric testing. |
Number not stated Pediatric resuscitation team |
Parker 2012 |
Quantitative | 3 | 20 surgeons Observed at 29 surgery Participants included consultant surgeons, surgical trainees, circulating nurses, scrub nurses, and anesthetists |
22 Surgical teams |
Reader 2011 |
Qualitative | 7 | 25 senior ICU physicians were interviewed (critical incident technique). | Number not stated ICU teams |
Künzle 2010 |
Quantitative | 1 | 26 residents and nurses videotaped during simulated anesthesia inductions. Videotapes were analyzed using the software ATLAS ti. | 12 Anesthesia teams |
Edmondson 2003 |
Qualitative |
16 | 165 members from 16 Operating Room teams (Surgeons, Anesthesiologists, OR nurses perfusionists, Cardiologists, intensive care unit (ICU) nurses, general care unit (or floor) nurses, senior hospital agents), were interviewed. |
16 Operating Room teams |