Skip to main content
. 2022 Feb 14;36:8. doi: 10.47176/mjiri.36.8

Table 1. Characteristics of 13 studies included in the present article .

First author Study design Number of institutions Number of participants
and Type of participation
Number and type of teams participated
Fernandez
2020
Quantitative 1 79 second- and third-year emergency medicine and general surgical residents at the University of Washington
Trauma resuscitations were video recorded and coded using outcome measures.
1 trauma team at the University of Washington
MO
2019
Mixed 1 Phase 1. Quantitative: 21 members from trauma team were interviewed
Phase 2. Quantitative: 64 members from trauma team completed DCE (Discrete Choice Experiment) questionnaire
Trauma team included physicians (resident, fellow, or attending), nurses, x-ray technologists, respiratory therapists, etc.
1 Pediatric trauma team
Oza
2018
Mixed 2 Phase 1. Developing LOFT (Leadership Observation Feedback Tool): Internal medicine and pediatric residents were surveyed (20), completed a Delphi questionnaire (15) and participated in a pilot study (78).

Phase 2. LOFT testing: 377 team members (attending physicians, fellows, and residents, nurses, pharmacists, medical students, and allied health professionals) completed LOFT for 95 residents.
5 Clinical teams
Stone
2017
Mixed 1 7 surgeons and 82 non-surgeons (phase 1) and 5 surgeons and 105 non-surgeons (phase 2) were surveyed to measure surgical staff member perceptions and attitudes about themselves, their teams, and team dynamics.

-Cases involving 7surgeons (phase1) and 4 surgeons (phase2) were observed to collect data about interactions between surgeons and non-surgeons during individual surgical procedures.

- 7 surgeons and 116 team members were interviewed to gain insights on contextual influences underlying observed interactions
Non-surgeons included scrub technicians/nurses, circulating nurses, physician assistants, perfusionists, anesthesiologists, and trainees (e.g. surgical fellows, anesthesia residents.
Number not stated




Surgical teams
Leenstra 2016 Mixed 3 28 participants including 5 surgeons, 3 surgical residents, 8 emergency physicians, 1 resident emergency physician, 1 anesthesiologist, 2 anesthesiology residents and 8 emergency nurses, were interviewed (critical incident type). Number not stated

Trauma teams
Coolen
2015
Quantitative 1 12 pediatric residents participated in 48 team simulations of a pediatric critical-care event.
38 residents were surveyed to assess the specific needs in leadership training as felt by them.
Number not stated
Pediatric emergency teams
Parker
2014
Quantitative 3 Videos of 29 operations from Surgical teams (surgeons, surgical residents, nurses, anesthesiologists were analyzed. Number not stated
Surgical teams
Parker
2013
Mixed 1 Phase 1. Qualitative: 106 participants, including surgeons, trainees, anesthetists, nurses participated in 10 focus groups.

Phase 2. Testing taxonomy: 2 psychologists rated 5 videos of live surgery.
1 Operating room team
Grant
2012
Mixed 5 Phase 1.8 pediatric acute care physician educators (3 from emergency medicine, 4 from critical care, and one practicing in both subspecialties) from five pediatric tertiary care hospitals in Canada participated in a Delphi method to develop pediatric resuscitation team leader evaluation tool as members of an Expert Working Group (EWG).
Phase 2. 30 residents on two videotaped scenarios were assessed by 4 pediatricians using pediatric resuscitation team leader evaluation tool for Instrument psychometric testing.

Number not stated

Pediatric resuscitation team
Parker
2012
Quantitative 3 20 surgeons Observed at 29 surgery
Participants included consultant surgeons, surgical trainees, circulating nurses, scrub nurses, and anesthetists
22
Surgical teams
Reader
2011
Qualitative 7 25 senior ICU physicians were interviewed (critical incident technique). Number not stated

ICU teams
Künzle
2010
Quantitative 1 26 residents and nurses videotaped during simulated anesthesia inductions. Videotapes were analyzed using the software ATLAS ti. 12 Anesthesia teams
Edmondson
2003
Qualitative
16 165 members from 16 Operating Room teams (Surgeons, Anesthesiologists, OR nurses perfusionists, Cardiologists, intensive care unit (ICU) nurses, general care unit (or floor) nurses, senior hospital agents), were interviewed.
16 Operating Room teams