Skip to main content
. 2022 Mar 18;71(3):264–280. doi: 10.1538/expanim.21-0120

Table 1. Advantages and disadvantages of the radial arm maze (RAM), Barnes maze (BM), and Morris water maze (MWM).

Behavioral assays Advantages Disadvantages
Radial arm maze • Suitable for spatial working memory assessment.
• Less laborious.
• Possible exploitation of serial strategy.
• Selection of choice-point decision rather than spatial strategy due to olfactory cue trails.

Barnes maze • Suitable for spatial learning and memory assessment.
• Ability to track individual trajectory of different exploration patterns.
• Lack of aversive stimuli may reduce animal’s motivation to escape.
• Inconsistent escape behaviors between rats and mice.

Morris water maze • Reliable in various cross-species studies including guinea pigs, rats, and mice.
• Ability to track various swimming strategies (spatial, non-spatial, and thigmotaxis).
• Able to tract non-cognitive factor based on cued task.
• Possibility of hypothermia and excessive stress due to the extensive and uncontrolled trials.
• Not sensitive for spatial working memory assessment.

Contextual fear conditioning test • Reliable for various rat and mouse strains.
• Less affectability to motor dysfunction.
• Suitable for evaluating associative learning which involves multiple brain regions (hippocampus, amygdala, and neocortex).
• Assessment on contextual learning does not necessarily represent spatial learning.
• Not sensitive for hippocampal-dependent learning.

Object location memory test • Cost-effective.
• Simple protocols without integration with intricate experiment instruments and extensive analysis parameters.
• Motor dysfunction due to treatment or surgical manipulations may confound the test habituation.
• Exhibition of anxiety in normal animals can affect the animals’ learning.