Table 2.
Summary of phenotyping robots categorized by drive mechanism. 4WD4WS: four-wheel driving and four-wheel steering; 2WD2WS: two-wheel driving and two-wheel steering.
| Robot | Phenotyping sensor | Perception sensor | Crop | Advantages | Disadvantages | Applications |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Wheeled robot (skid steering) | ||||||
| VinBot [28] | RGB-D camera 2D LiDAR |
RTK-GNSSIMU | Grape | Simple mechanical structure Simple motion control Low cost |
Low power efficiency in turning High wear and tear of the tires Can cause damage to the soil |
Yield estimation [47] |
| Shrimp [25] | 3D LiDAR RGB camera Hyperspectral camera |
RTK-GNSSIMU | Horticultural crop | Mango fruit detection [25] Almond mapping of flower, fruits, and yield [48] Almond fruit detection [49] |
||
| Robotanist [26] | Stereo camera RGB camera |
RTK-GNSSIMU2D LiDAR Stereo camera |
Sorghum | Corn stalk count and width estimation [50] | ||
| Vinobot [24] | Trinocular camera | GNSS2D LiDAR | Maize Sorghum |
Simulation of Vinobot [51] | ||
| TerraSentia [27] | Multispectral camera2D LiDAR Hyperspectral camera RGB camera RGB-D camera |
GNSS Gyroscope |
Maize | Corn stem width estimation [52] Under canopy navigation [53] |
||
| MARIA [29] | 2D LiDAR RGB-D camera |
RTK-GNSSIMU | Not specified | Simulation of an agricultural robot [54] | ||
| [55] | RGB-D camera | RTK-GNSS2D LiDAR | Maize | Corn stalk diameter estimation [55] | ||
|
| ||||||
| Wheeled robot (differential drive) | ||||||
| RobHortic [30] | Thermal camera Multispectral camera RGB camera NIR camera Hyperspectral camera |
RTK-GNSS | Horticultural crop | Simple mechanical structure Simple motion control Low cost |
Less precise in steering control | Carrot disease detection [30] |
|
| ||||||
| Wheeled robot (2WD2WS and Ackerman steering) | ||||||
| AgBotII [31] | RGB camera | RTK‐GNSS | Row crop | Precise steering control | Need coordination between drive wheel and steering wheel | Weed detection [56] |
| Phenobot 1.0 [32] | Stereo camera | RTK‐GNSS | Sorghum | Sorghum plant height and stalk diameter estimation [32] Sorghum plant architecture [57] |
||
| AgriRover-01 [33] | 3D LiDAR | RTK‐GNSS | Corn | Plant height and row spacing estimation [58] | ||
| DairyBioBot [34] | 2D LiDAR NDVI sensor |
RTK‐GNSS | Ryegrass | Ryegrass biomass estimation [34] | ||
|
| ||||||
| Wheeled robot (articulated steering) | ||||||
| Phenobot 3.0 [2, 35] | Stereo camera | RTK-GNSS | Sorghum | Good mobility for rough terrain Precise steering control |
Increased complexity in mechanical structure | |
|
| ||||||
| Wheeled robot (4WD4WS) | ||||||
| Thorvald II [36] | Application dependent | GPSIMU2D LiDAR | Row crop Horticulture crop |
High maneuverability Good terrain adaptation |
Complex mechanical structure Complex motion control High cost |
Development of a strawberry harvesting robot [59] Development of row-following algorithm in polytunnels [60] |
| Ladybird [37] | RGB camera2D LiDAR Hyperspectral camera Stereo camera Thermal camera |
2D LiDAR RTK-GNSSIMU |
Row crop | Weed detection [61] Dataset collection [62] |
||
| Phenomobile V1 [38] | 2D LiDAR RGB camera Multispectral camera |
RTK-GNSS | Row crop Wheat Mixed crop |
Estimation of plant height from LiDAR measurement [38] Estimation of wheat green area index from LiDAR measurement [63] |
||
| AgRover [64] | Not specified | RTK-GNSS | Row crop | |||
| Flex-Ro [39] | RGB camera Ultrasonic sensor Infrared thermometer Spectrometer |
GNSS Obstacle detector |
Row crop | |||
| MARS X [40] | Application dependent | RTK-GNSS | Row crop | |||
|
| ||||||
| Tracked (differential drive) | ||||||
| Armadillo Scout [41] | Application dependent | GNSS2D LiDAR | Not specified | Good mobility for rough terrain Low ground pressure |
Complex mechanical structure Low power efficiency in turning Can damage the soil |
|
| PHENObot [42] | RGB camera | RTK-GNSS | Grape | Grape bunch and berry detection [66] | ||
| [65] | RGB camera | RTK-GNSS | Soybean | |||
| [43] | RGB camera | |||||
| TERRA-MEPP [44] | Stereo camera Depth camera RGB camera |
RTK-GNSS Wheel encoder Gyroscope |
Sorghum | |||
| Phenomobile V2 [45] | 2D LiDAR RGB camera Multispectral camera |
RTK-GNSSIMU | Wheat Cotton Sunflower Mixed crop |
|||
|
| ||||||
| Wheel-legged (4WD4WS) | ||||||
| BoniRob [67] | Application dependent | RTK-GNSS Inertial sensor3D LiDAR |
Row crop | High maneuverability Good terrain adaptation Physical dimension can be changed |
Complex mechanical structure Complex motion control High cost |
Soil compaction and moisture measurement [68] Weed image dataset collection [69] Image dataset collection [70] Ground and aerial robot collaboration [71] |