Table 11.
Image | K | Algorithms |
|||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
SOA [45] | HHOA [35] | FPA [18] | CS [19] | HS [15] | SCA [22] | BA [23] | COVID-HHOA | ||
Medical1 | 6 | 29.1150 | 29.1440 | 28.4842 | 28.5451 | 28.4039 | 28.4511 | 28.9466 | 29.1497 |
8 | 36.4624 | 36.6540 | 35.1770 | 35.7679 | 35.6282 | 36.1923 | 36.0033 | 36.7475 | |
10 | 42.8551 | 43.2945 | 42.1935 | 42.2456 | 41.7597 | 41.3143 | 42.9482 | 44.0402 | |
12 | 48.0268 | 49.6176 | 46.7989 | 46.3681 | 45.9796 | 46.5262 | 47.9183 | 50.1440 | |
14 | 53.1311 | 54.8167 | 52.5195 | 52.4872 | 50.0722 | 51.4593 | 53.2681 | 55.7106 | |
Medical2 | 6 | 30.0560 | 30.0624 | 29.2634 | 29.3301 | 29.1013 | 29.5610 | 29.7242 | 30.1228 |
8 | 37.4817 | 37.6122 | 36.3408 | 36.4637 | 36.4182 | 37.0426 | 37.3252 | 37.5760 | |
10 | 44.1656 | 44.5172 | 41.9516 | 43.6734 | 42.7747 | 42.7167 | 43.6806 | 44.7035 | |
12 | 50.0224 | 50.2347 | 49.0840 | 48.5610 | 47.7153 | 49.4137 | 50.2842 | 50.9972 | |
14 | 55.3181 | 56.5864 | 53.2115 | 53.1273 | 52.3780 | 52.7230 | 55.0156 | 56.9942 | |
Medical3 | 6 | 29.4506 | 29.4480 | 28.6691 | 23.1739 | 28.4564 | 29.4011 | 29.2656 | 29.4703 |
8 | 37.2324 | 37.3536 | 35.0245 | 28.3095 | 35.1488 | 36.4795 | 36.0121 | 37.3482 | |
10 | 43.5538 | 44.2176 | 42.3845 | 32.7091 | 41.7464 | 42.8749 | 42.8232 | 44.3337 | |
12 | 49.1426 | 50.3112 | 47.7115 | 36.5965 | 47.5394 | 48.0504 | 49.5033 | 50.4694 | |
14 | 52.4016 | 56.0881 | 52.5454 | 40.3468 | 52.2408 | 52.9522 | 54.6020 | 56.1094 | |
Medical4 | 6 | 29.7038 | 29.8214 | 29.0196 | 29.4504 | 29.3854 | 29.2795 | 29.4105 | 29.8370 |
8 | 36.5791 | 36.8520 | 35.7648 | 35.8712 | 35.9158 | 36.3379 | 36.2300 | 36.9593 | |
10 | 42.8729 | 43.6696 | 40.4616 | 41.3581 | 41.8134 | 42.2490 | 42.7692 | 43.7918 | |
12 | 47.4509 | 49.5428 | 46.0389 | 47.2014 | 46.8216 | 47.7198 | 48.9814 | 49.5914 | |
14 | 54.1334 | 55.1970 | 51.3232 | 52.4321 | 51.3109 | 52.4020 | 54.7969 | 55.4478 | |
Medical5 | 6 | 27.5392 | 27.6409 | 26.9876 | 21.7552 | 26.9903 | 27.1946 | 27.1707 | 27.6422 |
8 | 35.0168 | 35.1453 | 33.7456 | 27.3895 | 34.5749 | 34.5868 | 33.8298 | 35.2417 | |
10 | 41.1285 | 42.0444 | 40.8043 | 31.4742 | 39.7802 | 40.7294 | 41.1127 | 42.1571 | |
12 | 47.0732 | 48.4408 | 46.2316 | 35.6166 | 45.5961 | 46.2532 | 48.1818 | 48.5939 | |
14 | 52.6506 | 54.3979 | 50.5047 | 39.2780 | 50.1560 | 50.3272 | 53.5915 | 54.5965 | |
Medical6 | 6 | 28.9177 | 29.0004 | 27.9225 | 22.9562 | 34.5683 | 28.6647 | 28.2243 | 29.0004 |
8 | 36.0479 | 36.9304 | 34.5297 | 27.9091 | 36.3630 | 35.8314 | 36.3014 | 36.9257 | |
10 | 43.0778 | 43.5536 | 40.2129 | 32.3120 | 40.6346 | 42.0560 | 42.1871 | 43.6132 | |
12 | 48.8374 | 49.6670 | 47.4302 | 36.4025 | 45.0181 | 46.1182 | 48.5252 | 49.8300 | |
14 | 52.3678 | 55.3890 | 51.7384 | 39.7488 | 51.7612 | 50.7992 | 52.9835 | 54.4504 |