Skip to main content
. 2022 Aug 24;150:106003. doi: 10.1016/j.compbiomed.2022.106003

Table 19.

SSIM results of 3D medical image segmentation using Kapur's method for all algorithms.

Image K Algorithms
SOA [41] HHOA [35] FPA [18] CS [19] HS [15] SCA [22] BA [23] COVID-HHOA
Medical1 6 0.9649 0.9632 0.9552 0.9680 0.9601 0.9624 0.9635 0.9650
8 0.9621 0.9738 0.9621 0.9701 0.9668 0.9700 0.9734 0.9755
10 0.9743 0.9765 0.9673 0.9732 0.9723 0.9733 0.9767 0.9788
12 0.9792 0.9800 0.9720 0.9768 0.9756 0.9775 0.9785 0.9809
14 0.9807 0.9813 0.9750 0.9807 0.9779 0.9795 0.9810 0.9818
Medical2 6 0.9588 0.9578 0.9244 0.9529 0.9500 0.9448 0.9513 0.9600
8 0.9635 0.9631 0.9477 0.9638 0.9549 0.9588 0.9650 0.9664
10 0.9697 0.9688 0.9545 0.9686 0.9600 0.9671 0.9694 0.9701
12 0.9713 0.9729 0.9622 0.9721 0.9640 0.9702 0.9710 0.9735
14 0.9725 0.9742 0.9648 0.9734 0.9681 0.9688 0.9735 0.9745
Medical3 6 0.9044 0.9012 0.8415 0.8968 0.8648 0.9026 0.8894 0.9055
8 0.9123 0.9187 0.8829 0.9106 0.8835 0.9107 0.9059 0.9240
10 0.9298 0.9276 0.9074 0.9220 0.9038 0.9168 0.9266 0.9323
12 0.9321 0.9332 0.9100 0.9324 0.9235 0.9215 0.9322 0.9424
14 0.9386 0.9373 0.9166 0.9421 0.9326 0.9335 0.9404 0.9453
Medical4 6 0.8301 0.8327 0.8008 0.8314 0.8109 0.8420 0.8450 0.8470
8 0.8470 0.8378 0.8165 0.8373 0.8149 0.8433 0.8480 0.8535
10 0.8531 0.8409 0.8268 0.8463 0.8227 0.8485 0.8499 0.8557
12 0.8540 0.8421 0.8342 0.8525 0.8402 0.8531 0.8541 0.8566
14 0.8558 0.8456 0.8452 0.8565 0.8416 0.8552 0.8599 0.8644
Medical5 6 0.9583 0.9610 0.9504 0.9371 0.9485 0.9542 0.9543 0.9620
8 0.9675 0.9653 0.9598 0.9441 0.9592 0.9624 0.9661 0.9688
10 0.9719 0.9743 0.9637 0.9648 0.9652 0.9659 0.9734 0.9750
12 0.9732 0.9751 0.9688 0.9682 0.9695 0.9702 0.9747 0.9758
14 0.9750 0.9769 0.9664 0.9707 0.9719 0.9720 0.9760 0.9772
Medical6 6 0.9213 0.9204 0.8700 0.9160 0.9131 0.9191 0.9211 0.9244
8 0.9420 0.9412 0.9145 0.9415 0.9327 0.9265 0.9419 0.9430
10 0.9569 0.9565 0.9277 0.9589 0.9476 0.9519 0.9554 0.9579
12 0.9590 0.9604 0.9412 0.9591 0.9516 0.9645 0.9608 0.9612
14 0.9618 0.9648 0.9479 0.9632 0.9576 0.9577 0.9665 0.9652
Average 0.9380 0.9374 0.9192 0.9350 0.9268 0.9348 0.9381 0.9421