Study | Reason for exclusion |
---|---|
Bang 2019 | Ineligible comparator |
Blanaru 2012 | Ineligible comparator (comparison of 2 interventions, music listening versus muscle relaxation techniques) |
Chan 2010 | Ineligible population (not all participants had insomnia. No inclusion criteria of insomnia and PSQI < 5) |
Chen 2014 | Ineligible population (young adults with different sleep latencies. Poor sleepers (PSQI < 5) excluded) |
Deshmukh 2009 | Ineligible comparator (comparison of 2 interventions, music listening versus hypnotic medications) |
Garcia‐Molina 2019 | Ineligible population |
Hausenblas 2019 | Ineligible comparator |
Hérnandez‐Ruíz 2005 | Ineligible population (some participants were 'good sleepers') |
Jespersen 2012 | Ineligible study design (quasi‐randomised trial) |
KaradaĞ 2015 | Ineligible population |
Kayumov 2003 | Ineligible comparator (individualised versus non‐individualised 'brain music') |
Koenig 2013 | Ineligible population (healthy university students with no sleep problems) |
Lafçi 2015 | Ineligible population |
Lai 2012 | Ineligible comparator (live music with nursing presence versus prerecorded music) |
Lai 2015 | Ineligible intervention (music video) |
Lazic 2007 | Ineligible population (healthy university students) |
Lio 2018 | Ineligible intervention |
Lu 2020 | Ineligible population |
Mottaghi 2016 | Ineligible intervention |
Oxtoby 2013 | Ineligible population (university students. About 50% of participants experienced no sleep problems) |
Qin 2020 | Ineligible intervention |
Shobeiri 2016 | Ineligible intervention (music combined with counselling) |
Sithinamsuwan 2012 | Ineligible population (some participants were 'good sleepers' with PSQI scores < 5) |
Srikolcheep 2017 | Ineligible intervention |
Weise 2020 | Ineligible population |
Yamasato 2020 | Ineligible study design |
Ziv 2008 | Ineligible comparator (music listening versus progressive muscular relaxation) |
PSQI: Pittsburgh Sleep Quality Index.