Figure 2.
External and self-review results for representative papers, including all three original scoring systems. In Scoring V3, filled circles show average external reviewer score, error bars show an external reviewer score range, open circles show external NA scores, and open squares show selfevaluation scores. Coloration behind Scoring V3 was applied after the evaluation (i.e., reviewers did not assign numeric scores with paired colors) by mapping the 6-level V3 scores (NA, 0 − 5) onto the final 5-level color scheme: gray = NA; red = 0 − < 0.5; orange = 0.5 − < 2.5; yellow = 2.5 − < 4.5; blue = 4.5 − 5. Articles reviewed by 1SRT category reviewers or 2full SRT reviewers.