Table 1.
Biomarkers in development for autism spectrum disorder
Biomarker | Type (potential) | Period | Strength | Weakness | Validation studies |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Prenatal history | |||||
Gestational infections | Risk | Prenatal | Can obtain from medical history | Not clear If specific to specific infection or if the effects of infection treatments (eg, antibiotics) have an effect. No clear treatment consequences other than standard of care | No |
Obesity/diabetes | Risk | Prenatal | Can obtain from medical history | No clear treatment consequences other than standard of care | No |
Genetics | |||||
Structural DNA alterations |
Risk subgroup Treatment |
All periods | High-throughput comprehensive genetic analysis is becoming clinically routine. Particularly helpful in difficult, refractory cases to provide prognostic information | Low yield for any single disorder and phenotype can be variable. Variants of unknown significance are common results leading to ambiguous information which can be hard to reconcile. Experienced geneticist is needed to interpret complex genetic information | No |
Single nucleotide polymorphism |
Risk Treatment |
Postnatal | Single nucleotide polymorphism is generally available even on the consumer level | Lack of rigorous scientific research on risk association and treatment implications leads to dubious treatment recommendations based on results, especially at the consumer level | No |
mRNA/miRNA |
Diagnostic Subgroup |
Post-diagnosis | Noninvasive. Some correlation with neurodevelopment outcomes | Variable performance in validation studies. Different RNA subtypes used in various studies. Utility unclear if diagnosis already established | Yes |
Methylation |
Risk Diagnostic |
All periods | Biologically important. Important epigenetic factor than may explain inheritance and environmental exposures | Very variable results regarding direction of methylation abnormalities and specific gene target of methylations changes. Very complicated field given both inherited and environmental factors are at play | No |
Neurological | |||||
Morphology and diffusion tensor imaging |
Risk Diagnostic |
Pre-diagnosis Post-diagnosis |
Consistent abnormalities in brain growth appear prior to diagnosis and persist into the diagnostic period. Non-invasive | Large prospective studies are needed to validate findings. MRI may require specialized centers. Limited to infants and children that can tolerate MRI scanner | No |
N170 | Diagnostic | Post-Diagnosis | Non-invasive. No Sedation Needed | Requires cooperation and attention to view stimuli. Utility unclear if diagnosis already established. Large prospective studies are needed to validate findings | No |
MEG |
Diagnostic Treatment |
Post-diagnosis | Non-invasive. No Sedation Needed. Possible association with GABA signaling leading to possible prediction of treatment response | Variable protocols limit conclusions from current research. Utility unclear if diagnosis already established. Large prospective studies are needed to validate findings | No |
Resting state MRI |
Risk Diagnostic |
Pre-diagnosis Post-diagnosis |
Non-invasive | Variable protocols limit conclusions from current research. Require specialized centers. Limited to infants and children that can tolerate MRI scanner | No |
Visual attention |
Risk Diagnostic |
Pre-diagnosis Post-diagnosis |
Non-invasive | Require specialized centers. Requires cooperation and attention to view stimuli | No |
Metabolic | |||||
Transmethylation transsulphuration |
Risk Diagnostic Treatment |
All Periods | Only requires blood test. Possible prenatal predictive. Biologically important and possibly relevant to treatment | Requires specialized centers and equipment and not widely available clinically. May correlation with symptoms. Large prospective studies are needed to validate findings | Yes |
Mitochondrial |
Subgroup Treatment |
Post-diagnosis | Various biomarkers, some non-invasive. Possibly biologically important and relevant to treatment | Variable techniques and biomarkers limit conclusions from current research. Large prospective studies using a validated biomarker are needed to validate findings | No |
Immune | |||||
Maternal autism related (MAR) | Diagnostic | Prenatal | Possible prenatal prediction of ASD diagnosis with a high sensitivity for the MAR subgroup | Large prospective studies are needed to validate findings. Treatment implications unclear at this time | No |
Brain autoantibodies | Treatment | Post-diagnosis | Possibly biologically important and relevant to treatment | Variable techniques and biomarkers limit conclusions from current research. Large prospective studies using a validated biomarker are needed to validate findings | No |
Folate receptor alpha autoantibody |
Risk Subgroup Treatment |
All periods |
Possible prenatal prediction of ASD diagnosis given that found also in parents May represent an ASD subgroup that is treatment responsive |
May indicate distinct at-risk subgroup but lack sensitivity for ASD diagnosis. Transgenerational features require significant more investigation. Large prospective studies are needed to validate findings | No |
Cytokines |
Risk Subgroup Treatment |
All periods | Elevated cytokines in pregnancy and neonatal period interesting as possible risk predictor. May indicate subgroup that requires specific treatment | Variable techniques and biomarkers limit conclusions from current research. Large prospective studies using a validated biomarker are needed to validate findings | No |
Autonomic | |||||
Heart rate variability |
Subgroup Treatment |
Post-Diagnosis | May represent an ASD subgroup that is treatment responsive | Variable techniques and biomarkers limit conclusions from current research. Large prospective studies using a validated biomarker are needed to validate findings | No |
Pupillometry | Diagnostic | Post-Diagnosis | Non-invasive | Variable techniques and biomarkers limit conclusions from current research | No |
Zinc |
Risk Subgroup |
Prenatal Post-diagnosis |
Abnormal zinc level in pregnancy period is an interesting possible risk predictor with treatment implications. May indicate subgroup that requires specific treatment | Deciduous teeth typically not available until after diagnosis so fetal zinc measurements would need to be developed. Treatment implications unclear | No |
Vitamin D |
Risk Treatment |
Prenatal Post-diagnosis |
Easily obtained prenatally with routine laboratories and treatment implications straightforward. Biologically relevant | Target optimum vitamin D level widely debated. Large prospective studies are needed to validate findings | No |
Folate | Risk | Pre-diagnosis | Easily obtained with routine laboratories | The complicated nature of various folate species is not captured in routine total folate levels and the interaction with other folate pathway abnormalities makes routine levels hard to interpret on their own | No |
ASD autism spectrum disorder, DNA deoxyribonucleic acid, GABA gamma-aminobutyric acid, MRI magnetic resonance imaging, MAR maternal autism related, mRNA messenger RNA, miRNA microRNA, RNA ribonucleic acid