Skip to main content
. 2022 Aug 30;21(Suppl 1):121. doi: 10.1186/s12939-022-01716-2
Item T4D ACTHealth World Vision
Papers & reports Project files Papers & reports Project files Papers & reports Project files
Title & Abstract
 1a Title: Purpose & study design Yes Yes No
 1b Abstract: Importance, study design, methods, results, and conclusions Yes Incomplete No
 1c Keywords: Social accountability & health No No No
Introduction
 2a Background and rationale Yes Yes No
 2b Research objective/questions Yes Yes Yes
 2c Theory of change Yes Yes Yes
 2d Role of context Yes Yes No Yes
Methods
 3. Study Design
  3a Study design & how addresses objectives Yes Yes Yes
  3b Who designed study & how Yes No Yes
  3c Changes after study began No Yes No No Yes
  3d Trial registration & protocol No Yes Yes No
 4. Study participants and sample
  4a Inclusion/ exclusion criteria & recruitment Yes Incomplete No Yes
  4b Unit of assignment Incomplete  Yes NA
  4c Participant selection & representativeness Yes No No
  4d Data collection settings Yes Yes Yes
  4e Data collection methods Yes Yes Incomplete
 5. Intervention description
  5a Intervention strategies named Yes Yes Yes
  5b Description of implementation stages, representation of marginalized groups Yes Yes No
  5c Adherence to delivery protocols No Yes No No Yes
  5d Financial and other resources required for implementation No No No
 6. Overall goal & objectives
  6a Accountability outcomes Yes Yes Yes
  6b Outcomes for sub-groups Yes Yes Incomplete
  6c Changes to outcomes after study begins Yes No NA
 7. Analytical Methods
  7a Statistical methods Yes Yes No
  7b Qualitative methods No NA Yes
  7c Methods used to describe intervention implementation No Incomplete Yes No Yes
  7d Methods for integrating and triangulating data Yes NA Yes
  7e Methods for examining interactions and mediators No Yes No
Results
 8. Implementation Analysis Yes Incomplete Yes No Yes
 9. Data collection outcomes
  9a Numbers assigned, receiving intervention, and analyzed No Yes No
  9b Numbers sampled and exposed to the intervention Yes NA Yes
 10. Recruitment
  10a Dates of recruitment and follow-up Yes Yes Yes
  10b Why the study was stopped NA NA NA
  11. Baseline data Yes Yes No
 12. Numbers analyzed
  12a Number in each analysis and whether intent to treat Yes Yes Yes
  12b Description of how noncompliers were treated NA Yes NA
 13. Outcomes and estimations
  13a Estimated effect size and precision Incomplete Yes Yes
  13b Major and minor themes No NA Yes
 14. Ancillary Analyses
  14a Results of subgroup and adjusted analyses Yes Yes No
  14b Results from mixed methods analysis Yes NA Yes
  15. Harms & unintended effects No No No Yes
Discussion
 16. Limitations No No No
 17. Generalizability
  17a Generalizability for RCTs No No NA
  17b Generalizability for quasi-experimental NA NA No
  17c Generalizability for qualitative studies No NA No
 18.Interpretation Yes Yes Yes
Important Information
 19. Registration No Yes No
 20. Protocol Yes No Yes No
 21. Declaration of Interest Yes No No
 22. Stakeholder Involvement
  22a Involvement of intervention developer in the study No No Yes
  22b Stakeholder involvement in study design Yes Yes Yes
  22c Incentives Yes Yes No Yes
 23. Transparency
  23a Datasets publicly available No No No
  23b Statement of ethical approvals No Yes No