Aletti 2006b |
Participants in comparison standard surgery group also had extensive bowel surgery, which is ultra‐radical. It was also unclear whether women with recurrent disease were included. |
Aletti 2006c |
Intervention was ultra‐radical (removal of tumour from diaphragm), but unclear whether those in comparison group received different form of ultra‐radical surgery. |
Aletti 2009a |
Comparison of ultra‐radical versus standard surgery groups not possible – low complexity scores also included possible small bowel resection. |
Aletti 2009b |
Comparison of ultra‐radical versus standard surgery groups not possible – low complexity scores also included possible small bowel resection. |
Angioli 2012 |
< 100 participants in analysis. |
Bahra 2013 |
Comparison not possible. |
Barlin 2013 |
No multivariate analysis. |
Bartl 2018 |
No comparator. |
Bertelsen 1990 |
Comparison of ultra‐radical versus standard surgery groups not possible. It was also unclear whether women with recurrent disease were included. |
Bristow 1999 |
Women with recurrent disease also included. |
Butler 2012 |
< 100 participants; conference abstract. |
Cai 2007 |
Comparisons were made between bowel resection versus no bowel resection regardless of the nature of surgery, so those in the no bowel resection group may have still received a form of ultra‐radical surgery. It was also unclear whether women with recurrent disease were included. |
Campos 2014 |
Conference abstract. |
Canlorbe 2018 |
Participants in comparison standard surgery group also had extensive bowel surgery, which is ultra‐radical. It was also unclear whether women with recurrent disease were included. |
Chang 2012b |
No ultra‐radical surgery. |
Chereau 2011 |
Mixed FIGO stages; no multivariate analysis. |
Chi 2004 |
Participants in comparison standard surgery group also had extensive bowel surgery, which is ultra‐radical. It was also unclear whether women with recurrent disease were included. |
Chi 2009 |
Comparison between standard surgery and ultra‐radical surgery groups not possible as all women underwent extensive upper abdominal surgery. |
Chua 2011 |
Comparison not of interest. |
Clark 2012 |
Outcomes not of interest; conference abstract. |
Clark 2014 |
Comparison not of interest. |
Cormier 2012 |
No ultra‐radical surgery; conference abstract. |
Cummins 2019 |
Conference abstract. |
Davies 2019 |
Participants in comparison standard surgery group also had extensive bowel surgery, which is ultra‐radical. It was also unclear whether women with recurrent disease were included. |
Eisenhauer 2006 |
Participants in comparison standard surgery group also had extensive bowel surgery, which is ultra‐radical. Also unclear if women with recurrent disease included. |
Eisenkop 1993 |
Participants in comparison standard surgery group also had extensive bowel surgery or diaphragmatic stripping (or both) which is ultra‐radical. It was also unclear whether women with recurrent disease were included. |
Eisenkop 1998 |
Participants in comparison standard surgery group also had extensive bowel surgery or diaphragmatic stripping (or both) which is ultra‐radical. Women with recurrent disease were also included. |
Eisenkop 2001 |
Comparison of ultra‐radical versus standard surgery groups not possible. |
Eisenkop 2003 |
Comparison of ultra‐radical versus standard surgery groups not possible. Women with recurrent disease were also included. |
Eisenkop 2006 |
Comparisons were made between splenectomy versus no splenectomy regardless of the nature of surgery, so those in the no splenectomy group may have still received a form of ultra‐radical surgery. Women with recurrent disease were also included. |
Elgamal 2019 |
Participants in comparison standard surgery group also had extensive bowel surgery, which is ultra‐radical. It was also unclear whether women with recurrent disease were included. |
Eng 2018 |
No multivariate analysis. |
Eoh 2017 |
Participants in comparison standard surgery group also had extensive bowel surgery, which is ultra‐radical. It was also unclear whether women with recurrent disease were included. |
Falconer 2020 |
Uncontrolled before‐after study. |
Favero 2014 |
Comparison not of interest. |
Ferrero 2014 |
Comparison not of interest. |
Filippova 2019 |
Participants in comparison standard surgery group also had extensive bowel surgery, which is ultra‐radical. It was also unclear whether women with recurrent disease were included. |
Fotopoulou 2012 |
Comparison not of interest; conference abstract. |
Gockley 2019 |
Participants in comparison standard surgery group also had extensive bowel surgery, which is ultra‐radical. It was also unclear whether women with recurrent disease were included. |
Gremeau 2014 |
Comparison not of interest. |
Grimm 2017 |
No comparator. |
Guyon 2014 |
Comparison not of interest. |
Hamilton 2011 |
Comparison not of interest. |
Hudry 2013 |
Comparison not of interest. |
Hwang 2014 |
Mixed population; comparison not of interest. |
Janda 2014 |
Comparison not of interest. |
Jiang 2013 |
Abstract form only but appeared to be same study as Ren 2015 where multivariate analysis did not include surgery type. |
Kato 2013a |
Comparison not of interest. |
Kato 2013b |
Population not of interest. |
Kehoe 2013 |
Comparison not of interest. |
Kim 2011 |
Comparison not of interest. |
Kolev 2014 |
Recurrent cancer. |
Kommoss 2010 |
Comparison between groups not possible as both groups also included participants undergoing bowel resection. |
Kristensen 2014 |
Borderline tumours. |
Kuhn 1998 |
Participants in comparison standard surgery group also had extensive bowel surgery or diaphragmatic stripping (or both), which is ultra‐radical. Women with recurrent disease were also included. |
Laios 2019 |
No comparator. |
Lee 2017 |
Conference abstracts. |
Li 2014 |
Comparison not of interest. |
Liberale 2019 |
Conference abstract. |
Liu 2013a |
Germ cell tumours; < 100 participants. |
Liu 2013b |
Germ cell tumours; article in Chinese. |
Martinez 2014 |
Conference abstract. |
McCann 2011 |
No multivariate analysis. |
Muallem 2018 |
No multivariate analysis. |
Oseledchyk 2016 |
Participants in comparison standard surgery group also had extensive bowel surgery, which is ultra‐radical. It was also unclear whether women with recurrent disease were included. |
Oshita 2013 |
Included only stages pT1‐2. |
Park 2011 |
No ultra‐radical surgery; conference abstract. |
Pathiraja 2011 |
< 100 participants; conference abstract. |
Pathiraja 2013 |
< 100 participants; outcomes not of interest. |
Pelissier 2018 |
No comparator. |
Perri 2013 |
Comparison not of interest. |
Phillips 2018 |
No multivariate analysis. |
Pushpalatha 2011 |
Comparison not of interest. |
Qin 2012 |
No meta‐analysis; comparison not of interest. |
Ratnavelu 2014 |
< 100 participants; conference abstract. |
Ren 2015 |
Multivariate analysis did not include surgery type. |
Rodriguez 2012 |
Women with suboptimal debulking were excluded (see also full publication Rodriguez 2013). |
Rodriguez 2013 |
Women with suboptimal debulking were excluded. |
Rouzier 2010 |
Mixed population; comparison not of interest. |
Sagara 2019 |
No multivariate analysis. |
Sandadi 2014 |
Comparison not of interest. |
Scalici 2014 |
Comparison not of interest. |
Sehouli 2010 |
Comparison not of interest. |
Soo Hoo 2015 |
No multivariate analysis. |
Stefanović 2011 |
< 100 participants. |
Sundar 2014 |
< 100 participants; conference abstract. |
Sundar 2018 |
Conference abstract. |
Sundar 2019 |
Conference abstract. |
Suzuki 2008 |
Conference abstract. |
Szczesny 2016 |
Conference abstract. |
Tozzi 2019 |
Participants in comparison standard surgery group also had extensive bowel surgery, which is ultra‐radical. It was also unclear whether women with recurrent disease were included. |
Tsolakidis 2010a |
Comparison between 'standard surgery' and 'ultra‐radical surgery' groups not possible as all women underwent diaphragmatic stripping. |
Tsolakidis 2010b |
Comparison between standard surgery and ultra‐radical surgery groups not possible as all women underwent diaphragmatic stripping. |
van de Laar 2014 |
Protocol for a new study; applies to recurrent cancer. |
Vidal 2016 |
No comparator. |
von Hugo 1989 |
Unclear if women with recurrent disease were included. |
Wallace 2016 |
No comparator. |
Wat 2012 |
< 100 participants; conference abstract. |
Wimberger 2007 |
Comparison of ultra‐radical versus standard surgery groups not possible, as the comparative groups include participants who had both types of surgery. |
Wright 2012 |
Outcomes not of interest. |
Yildirim 2014 |
No comparator. |
Zamurovic 2013 |
No multivariate analysis. |
Zapardiel 2012 |
No multivariate analysis. |