Skip to main content
. 2022 Aug 30;2022(8):CD007697. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD007697.pub3
Study Reason for exclusion
Aletti 2006b Participants in comparison standard surgery group also had extensive bowel surgery, which is ultra‐radical. It was also unclear whether women with recurrent disease were included.
Aletti 2006c Intervention was ultra‐radical (removal of tumour from diaphragm), but unclear whether those in comparison group received different form of ultra‐radical surgery.
Aletti 2009a Comparison of ultra‐radical versus standard surgery groups not possible – low complexity scores also included possible small bowel resection.
Aletti 2009b Comparison of ultra‐radical versus standard surgery groups not possible – low complexity scores also included possible small bowel resection.
Angioli 2012 < 100 participants in analysis.
Bahra 2013 Comparison not possible.
Barlin 2013 No multivariate analysis.
Bartl 2018 No comparator.
Bertelsen 1990 Comparison of ultra‐radical versus standard surgery groups not possible. It was also unclear whether women with recurrent disease were included.
Bristow 1999 Women with recurrent disease also included.
Butler 2012 < 100 participants; conference abstract.
Cai 2007 Comparisons were made between bowel resection versus no bowel resection regardless of the nature of surgery, so those in the no bowel resection group may have still received a form of ultra‐radical surgery. It was also unclear whether women with recurrent disease were included.
Campos 2014 Conference abstract.
Canlorbe 2018 Participants in comparison standard surgery group also had extensive bowel surgery, which is ultra‐radical. It was also unclear whether women with recurrent disease were included.
Chang 2012b No ultra‐radical surgery.
Chereau 2011 Mixed FIGO stages; no multivariate analysis.
Chi 2004 Participants in comparison standard surgery group also had extensive bowel surgery, which is ultra‐radical. It was also unclear whether women with recurrent disease were included.
Chi 2009 Comparison between standard surgery and ultra‐radical surgery groups not possible as all women underwent extensive upper abdominal surgery.
Chua 2011 Comparison not of interest.
Clark 2012 Outcomes not of interest; conference abstract.
Clark 2014 Comparison not of interest.
Cormier 2012 No ultra‐radical surgery; conference abstract.
Cummins 2019 Conference abstract.
Davies 2019 Participants in comparison standard surgery group also had extensive bowel surgery, which is ultra‐radical. It was also unclear whether women with recurrent disease were included.
Eisenhauer 2006 Participants in comparison standard surgery group also had extensive bowel surgery, which is ultra‐radical. Also unclear if women with recurrent disease included.
Eisenkop 1993 Participants in comparison standard surgery group also had extensive bowel surgery or diaphragmatic stripping (or both) which is ultra‐radical. It was also unclear whether women with recurrent disease were included.
Eisenkop 1998 Participants in comparison standard surgery group also had extensive bowel surgery or diaphragmatic stripping (or both) which is ultra‐radical. Women with recurrent disease were also included.
Eisenkop 2001 Comparison of ultra‐radical versus standard surgery groups not possible. 
Eisenkop 2003 Comparison of ultra‐radical versus standard surgery groups not possible. Women with recurrent disease were also included.
Eisenkop 2006 Comparisons were made between splenectomy versus no splenectomy regardless of the nature of surgery, so those in the no splenectomy group may have still received a form of ultra‐radical surgery. Women with recurrent disease were also included.
Elgamal 2019 Participants in comparison standard surgery group also had extensive bowel surgery, which is ultra‐radical. It was also unclear whether women with recurrent disease were included.
Eng 2018 No multivariate analysis.
Eoh 2017 Participants in comparison standard surgery group also had extensive bowel surgery, which is ultra‐radical. It was also unclear whether women with recurrent disease were included.
Falconer 2020 Uncontrolled before‐after study.
Favero 2014 Comparison not of interest.
Ferrero 2014 Comparison not of interest.
Filippova 2019 Participants in comparison standard surgery group also had extensive bowel surgery, which is ultra‐radical. It was also unclear whether women with recurrent disease were included.
Fotopoulou 2012 Comparison not of interest; conference abstract.
Gockley 2019 Participants in comparison standard surgery group also had extensive bowel surgery, which is ultra‐radical. It was also unclear whether women with recurrent disease were included.
Gremeau 2014 Comparison not of interest.
Grimm 2017 No comparator.
Guyon 2014 Comparison not of interest.
Hamilton 2011 Comparison not of interest.
Hudry 2013 Comparison not of interest.
Hwang 2014 Mixed population; comparison not of interest.
Janda 2014 Comparison not of interest.
Jiang 2013 Abstract form only but appeared to be same study as Ren 2015 where multivariate analysis did not include surgery type.
Kato 2013a Comparison not of interest.
Kato 2013b Population not of interest.
Kehoe 2013 Comparison not of interest.
Kim 2011 Comparison not of interest.
Kolev 2014 Recurrent cancer.
Kommoss 2010 Comparison between groups not possible as both groups also included participants undergoing bowel resection.
Kristensen 2014 Borderline tumours.
Kuhn 1998 Participants in comparison standard surgery group also had extensive bowel surgery or diaphragmatic stripping (or both), which is ultra‐radical. Women with recurrent disease were also included.
Laios 2019 No comparator.
Lee 2017 Conference abstracts.
Li 2014 Comparison not of interest.
Liberale 2019 Conference abstract.
Liu 2013a Germ cell tumours; < 100 participants.
Liu 2013b Germ cell tumours; article in Chinese.
Martinez 2014 Conference abstract.
McCann 2011 No multivariate analysis.
Muallem 2018 No multivariate analysis.
Oseledchyk 2016 Participants in comparison standard surgery group also had extensive bowel surgery, which is ultra‐radical. It was also unclear whether women with recurrent disease were included.
Oshita 2013 Included only stages pT1‐2.
Park 2011 No ultra‐radical surgery; conference abstract.
Pathiraja 2011 < 100 participants; conference abstract.
Pathiraja 2013 < 100 participants; outcomes not of interest.
Pelissier 2018 No comparator.
Perri 2013 Comparison not of interest.
Phillips 2018 No multivariate analysis.
Pushpalatha 2011 Comparison not of interest.
Qin 2012 No meta‐analysis; comparison not of interest.
Ratnavelu 2014 < 100 participants; conference abstract.
Ren 2015 Multivariate analysis did not include surgery type.
Rodriguez 2012 Women with suboptimal debulking were excluded (see also full publication Rodriguez 2013).
Rodriguez 2013 Women with suboptimal debulking were excluded.
Rouzier 2010 Mixed population; comparison not of interest.
Sagara 2019 No multivariate analysis.
Sandadi 2014 Comparison not of interest.
Scalici 2014 Comparison not of interest.
Sehouli 2010 Comparison not of interest.
Soo Hoo 2015 No multivariate analysis.
Stefanović 2011 < 100 participants.
Sundar 2014 < 100 participants; conference abstract.
Sundar 2018 Conference abstract.
Sundar 2019 Conference abstract.
Suzuki 2008 Conference abstract.
Szczesny 2016 Conference abstract.
Tozzi 2019 Participants in comparison standard surgery group also had extensive bowel surgery, which is ultra‐radical. It was also unclear whether women with recurrent disease were included.
Tsolakidis 2010a Comparison between 'standard surgery' and 'ultra‐radical surgery' groups not possible as all women underwent diaphragmatic stripping.
Tsolakidis 2010b Comparison between standard surgery and ultra‐radical surgery groups not possible as all women underwent diaphragmatic stripping.
van de Laar 2014 Protocol for a new study; applies to recurrent cancer.
Vidal 2016 No comparator.
von Hugo 1989 Unclear if women with recurrent disease were included.
Wallace 2016 No comparator.
Wat 2012 < 100 participants; conference abstract.
Wimberger 2007 Comparison of ultra‐radical versus standard surgery groups not possible, as the comparative groups include participants who had both types of surgery.
Wright 2012 Outcomes not of interest.
Yildirim 2014 No comparator.
Zamurovic 2013 No multivariate analysis.
Zapardiel 2012 No multivariate analysis.