Skip to main content
. 2022 Aug 30;9:85. doi: 10.1186/s40634-022-00520-9

Table 2.

Quality assessment of included studies

Study Tool Questions Overall quality
Case series and non-RCTs 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 Assessment Score
1 Hernigou P JBI Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes High 9
2 S. J. Kim NIH Yes Yes No NR Yes Yes No Yes Yes Moderate 6
3 S. J. Kim JBI Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes High 9
4 C. Pascual-Garrido NIH Yes Yes Yes NR Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes High 8
5 D. Connell 2009 NIH Yes No Yes CD Yes Yes No Yes Yes Moderate 6
6 Y. S. Kim 2017 JBI Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes High 9
7 B. E. Stein 2015 NIH Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes No Yes High 8
8 J. L. Ellera Gomes 2012 NIH Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes No Yes High 8
9 S. Y. Lee 2015 NIH Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes High 9
10 L. N. Muench 2020 NIH Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes High 9
11 C. H. Jo 2020 NIH Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes High 9
12 A. Wang 2015 NIH Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes High 9
13 M. Khoury 2021 NIH Yes No Yes Yes No Yes Yes Yes Yes High 8
14 K. Tate-Oliver 2013 NIH Yes Yes CD Yes Yes No Yes No No Low 5
15 C. J. Centeno 2015 NIH CD Yes Yes No No Yes No Yes Yes Moderate 5
16 A. Singh 2014 NIH Yes No No Yes No No No Yes No Low 3
RCTs (Cochrane Rob 2 tool) Randomization process Deviations from the intended interventions Missing outcome data Measurement of the outcome Selection of the reported result The overall risk of bias
1 J. L. Hurd 2020 + + + + +
2 G. Rodas 2021 + + + + +
3 D. A. V. Rosário 2021 + + + ؟
4 A. W. Clarke 2011 + + + + + +
5 Usuelli, F. G 2017 + ؟ + + + +
6 J. R. Lamas 2019 +

Abbreviations: CD Cannot determine, NR Not reported, NA Not available, NIH National Institutes of Health quality assessment tool for case-series studies, JBI Joanna Briggs Institute critical appraisal checklist for quasi-experimental studies, RCT Randomized clinical trials