Table 3.
Studies on the omission of axillary lymph node dissection
Study | Period | Type | Inclusion | n | Treatment of axillary | Follow-up | Results |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
NSABP B-04 [75] | 1971-1974 | prospective | primary operable breast cancer | 1765 | 1079 cN0 (1/3 ALND; 1/3 RT; 1/3 no surgery) | 25 years | NS in RFS, DFS, or OS |
586 cN+ (1/2 RT; 1/2 ALND) | |||||||
AMAROS [93] | 2001-2010 | prospective | T1-2, cN0 | 4806 | 2402 ALND | 6.1 years | ALND vs RT: |
2404 RT | 5-year axillary recurrence | ||||||
1425 cN+ | 0.43% vs 1.19% | ||||||
744 ALND; 681 RT | DFS: 86.9% vs 82.7% | ||||||
OS: 81.4% and 84.6% | |||||||
ACOSOG Z0011 [94] | 1999-2004 | prospective | T1-2, cN0; | 891 | 446 SLND alone | 9.3 years | SLND vs ALND |
N1-2 | 445 ALND | OS: 86.3% vs 83.6% | |||||
DFS: 80.2% vs 78.2% | |||||||
NS in LRR | |||||||
Alliance A011202 | 2013- | prospective | T1-3, N1, M0 | 1660 | ALND vs RT. | - | No results |
NRG9353 | 2003- | prospective | T1-3, N1, M0 | 1636 | ALND vs RT | - | No results |
Abbreviations: OS, overall survival; DFS, disease-free survival; RFS, relapse-free survival; LRR, locoregional recurrence rate; NAC, neoadjuvant chemotherapy; pCR, pathological complete response; cCR, clinical complete response; ALND, axillary lymph node dissection; SLND, sentinel lymph node biopsy; TAD, targeted axillary dissection; RT, radiotherapy treatment; NS, no significant.