Skip to main content
. 2022 Jul 2;6(5):713–722. doi: 10.1016/j.jseint.2022.06.002

Table III.

Quality assessment of case series.

Quality assessment of case series
Joanna Briggs Institute critical appraisal tool—Checklist for case series Clear inclusion criteria Condition measured in standard, reliable way for all Valid methods used for identification of condition for all Consecutive inclusion Complete inclusion Clear reporting of demographics Clear reporting of clinical information Clear reporting of outcomes or follow-up results Clear reporting of study site's demographics Was statistical analysis appropriate Sum
EHA Al-Hamdani (2019)2 Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes No No Yes No N/A 6/9
Burkhart (2011)7 No Yes Yes Unclear Unclear No No Yes No N/A 3/9
Hohman (2014)18 No Yes Yes Yes Unclear Yes Yes Yes No N/A 6/9
Leung (2022)27 Yes Yes Yes Yes Unclear No No Yes No Yes 6/10
Nestorson (2015)36 Yes Yes Yes Yes Unclear No No Yes No Yes 6/10
Phadnis (2015)38 No Yes Yes Yes Unclear No No Yes No Yes 5/10
Schultzel (2022)44 No Yes Yes Unclear Unclear No No Yes No Yes 4/10
Smith (2013)47 Yes Yes Yes Unclear Unclear No Yes Yes No Yes 6/10
ORIF Al-Hamdani (2022)1 Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes No Yes Yes Yes Yes 9/10
Ansari (2020)3 Yes Yes Yes Unclear Unclear No Yes Yes No Yes 6/10
Biz (2017)6 Yes Yes Yes Yes Unclear Yes Yes Yes No Yes 8/10
Celli (2008)8 No Yes Yes Unclear Unclear Yes No Yes No N/A 5/9
Chen (2011)9 No Yes Unclear Unclear Unclear No No Yes No Yes 3/10
Clavert (2013)10 Yes Yes Yes Unclear Unclear No No Yes No Yes 5/10
Ducrot (2013)14 Yes Yes Yes Yes Unclear No No Yes No Yes 6/10
Huang, J. (2011)20 Yes Yes Yes Yes Unclear No No Yes No Yes 6/10
Huang, T. (2005)21 No Yes Yes Yes Unclear No No Yes No N/A 4/9
Iwamoto (2017)22 No Yes Yes Unclear Unclear No No Yes No N/A 3/9
Kaiser (2011)24 No Yes Yes Yes Unclear No No Yes No N/A 4/9
Liu (2009)28 Yes Yes Yes Yes Unclear No No Yes No N/A 5/9
Luegmair (2008)30 No Yes Yes Yes Unclear No No Yes No N/A 4/9
Sanchez-Sotelo (2007)42 Yes Yes Yes Yes Unclear No No Yes No Yes 6/10
Serrano-Mateo (2014)45 Yes Yes Yes Unclear Unclear No No Yes No N/A 4/9
Shannon (2018)46 Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes No No Yes No N/A 6/9
Xie (2014)50 Yes Yes Yes Unclear Unclear No No Yes No Yes 5/10
Zhang (2014)51 Yes Yes Yes Unclear Unclear No No Yes No Yes 5/10

N/A, not applicable; EHA, elbow hemiarthroplasty; ORIF, open reduction and internal fixation.