Skip to main content
. 2022 Aug 24;16:912766. doi: 10.3389/fnins.2022.912766

TABLE 5.

The final 20 ranked consensus variables associated with HAND status.

Rank VDT variable description Type Driving domain(s) assessed Cognitive domains that were statistically associated with the VDT variable in this analysis
(Note: Bolded domains indicate statistical significance maintained after a Bonferroni correction for multiple comparisons)
1 Mean forward jerk while traversing an inactive railroad crossing Zonal Primary:
Vehicle control
Secondary:
Hazard anticipation and response
Language
2 Number of collisions with vehicles from sides or behind Global Primary:
Vehicle control
Attention and working memory
Motor function
Executive function
Language
Visuospatial memory
3 Maximum lane deviation of vehicle driving along a curve with an active school playground on the right side Zonal Primary:
Road positioning
Secondary:
Hazard anticipation and response
Attention and working memory
Executive function
4 Median lane deviation of driver vehicle traversing a 4-way traffic-light-controlled intersection instructed to make a left turn Zonal Primary:
Road positioning
Secondary:
Gap selection
Communication and right of way
Attention and working memory
5 Mean forward acceleration while traversing an inactive railroad crossing Zonal Primary:
Vehicle control
Secondary:
Hazard anticipation and response
Language
6 Number of collisions with other vehicles (all orientations of vehicle-to-vehicle collisions). Global Primary:
Vehicle control
Attention and working memory
Motor function
Executive function
Verbal memory
7 Number of collisions with static objects Global Primary:
Vehicle control
Motor function
Executive function
8 VDT Error Score (a linear combination of serious error counts along the entire VDT route) Global Primary:
Vehicle control
Hazard anticipation and response
Gap selection
Speed management
Communication and right of way
Attention maintenance
Attention and working memory
Motor function
Executive function
Verbal memory
9 Minimum difference of vehicle speed relative to posted speed limit while traversing a speed-reduction construction zone Zonal Primary:
Speed management
Secondary:
Hazard anticipation and response
Motor function
Executive function
Verbal memory
Visuospatial memory
10 Minimum forward acceleration while traversing an inactive railroad crossing Zonal Primary:
Vehicle control
Secondary:
Hazard anticipation and response
Attention and working memory
Verbal memory
11 Maximum forward jerk of vehicle while traversing an inactive railroad crossing Zonal Primary:
Vehicle control
Secondary:
Hazard anticipation and response
Attention and working memory
Verbal memory
12 Standard deviation of heading misalignment with road following direction while traversing a 4-way traffic-light-controlled intersection instructed to make a right turn
Zonal Primary:
Road positioning
Secondary:
Gap selection
Communication and right of way
Attention and working memory
Motor function
Executive function
13 Minimum signed distance from road center (negative values indicate driving on the left side of the road, potentially into oncoming traffic, over the median) Global Primary:
Road positioning
Attention and working memory
Motor function
Executive function
14 Standard deviation of steering wheel while an active-moving ambulance approaching from behind Zonal Primary:
Road positioning
Secondary:
Vehicle control
Hazard anticipation and response
Communication and right of way
Attention and working memory
Motor function
Executive function
15 % Time driven ≤ 15 mph below posted speed limit while traversing a traffic-light-controlled 4-way intersection instructed to make a left turn onto main arterial Zonal Primary:
Speed management
Secondary:
Gap selection
Communication and right of way
Attention and working memory
Motor function
Executive function
Verbal memory
16 Number of vehicle teleports (vehicle returned back to a starting position after a significant deviation from the planned route) Global Primary:
Attention maintenance
Attention and working memory
Motor function
Executive function
17 Minimum steering wheel rotation while an active-moving ambulance approaching from behind Zonal Primary:
Road positioning
Secondary:
Vehicle control
Hazard anticipation and response
Communication and right of way
Attention and working memory
Visuospatial memory
18 % Time driven ≤ 10 mph below posted speed limit while traversing an 4-way stop sign-controlled intersection, instructed to make a right turn Zonal Primary:
Speed management
Secondary:
Gap selection
Communication and right of way
Attention and working memory
Executive function
Verbal memory
19 Maximum heading misalignment with road following direction while an active-moving ambulance approaching from behind Zonal Primary:
Road positioning
Secondary:
Hazard anticipation and response
Communication and right of way
Processing speed
Attention and working memory
Motor function
Executive function
Language
20 Mean heading misalignment with road following direction while traversing a speed-reduction school zone Zonal Primary:
Road positioning
Secondary:
Hazard anticipation and response
Attention and working memory
Executive function