Skip to main content
. 2017 Dec 24;84(3):381–388. doi: 10.1016/j.bjorl.2017.11.003

Table 3.

Quality of the articles included, according to the Newcastle–Ottawa Quality Assessment Scale.

Authors Sample representativeness Justified sample sizea Rate of non-responses Exposure assessment Comparability Assessment of results Appropriate statistical test Final assessmentb
McNerney, Coad, Burkard (2014)26 Non-representative (0) Yes (1) 0% (1) Validated tool (2) Yes (2) Study's own report (1) Yes (1) 8/10
Sousa, Suzuki (2014)27 Non-representative (0) No (0) 0% (1) Validated tool (2) Yes (2) Study's own report (1) Yes (1) 7/10
a

Minimum criterion of n ≥ 30 (central limit theorem).

b

Maximum score of 10 stars. Result presented as: points obtained/maximum score.