Table 21.
Description of Studies: mixed conditions
| Authors, Year | Condition | CEA | CUA | Setting | N (participants) | Baseline Characteristics | Intervention/ comparator(s) | effectiveness measure(s); cost measures (price year) | Perspective | Time horizon |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Larsen et al. 2016 [65*] | Dermatology | ✓ | Norway; | N Participants: | 169 |
telephone-based individualised motivational interviewing, as a follow-up to a 3-week climate therapy/heliotherapy (CHT) programme, compared to TAU following the CHT. Intervention: 86 Control: 83 |
15D instrument of health-related quality of life; | Healthcare and employment | 6mths | |
| Age in years (mean, SD): | Intervention: 46.2 (12.7); Control: 46.5 (13.0) | Euros (2012) | ||||||||
| Sex (% female): | Intervention: 40.7 Control: 47 | |||||||||
| Ethnicity (% white): | Not given | |||||||||
| Maes et al. 2014 [73*] | Tinnitus | ✓ | Netherlands; | N Participants: | 492 |
stepped care, including an individual consultation with a psychologist then a programme comprising key elements of CBT for those with moderate or severe tinnitus compared to standard stepped care treatment. Intervention: 245 Control: 247 |
Health Utilities Index Mark III (HUI) | Healthcare and societal | 12mths | |
| Patients referred to an audiology centre | Age in years (mean, SD): | 54.21 (11.52) | Converted to US$ (from Euros) (2009) | |||||||
| Sex (% female): | 37.2 | |||||||||
| Ethnicity (% white): | Not given | |||||||||
| Parry et al. 2012 [85*] | Asthma | ✓ | ✓ | England; | N Participants: | 94 |
Individual CBT (introductory session followed by 4-6 weekly or fortnightly 1 hr. sessions, with two follow up sessions if considered necessary, compared to usual care. Intervention: 50 Control: 44 |
Panic-fear sub-scale of the Asthma Symptom Checklist, EQ-5D-3L; | Healthcare | 6 mths |
| Sheffield | Age in years (mean, range): | Intervention: 47.0 (28-65) Control: 43.8 (25-61) | £ (year not given) | |||||||
| Sex (% female): | Intervention: 60.7 Control group: 64.5 | |||||||||
| Ethnicity (% white): | Not given | |||||||||
| Rolving et al. 2016 [89*] | Surgery | ✓ | Denmark; | N Participants: | 90 |
group-based CBT, six 3-hour sessions, four prior and two post-surgery (at 3 and 6mths), delivered by a multidisciplinary team, compared to usual care. Intervention: 59 Control: 31 |
EQ-5D scores (Danish tariff); | Societal | 12mths | |
| Hospital | Age in years (mean, range): | mean age 50.1 (28-64), | Euros (2014) | |||||||
| Sex (% female): | 57 | |||||||||
| Ethnicity (% white): | Not given | |||||||||
| Tyrer et al. 2014 [94*] | Secondary care | ✓ | ✓ | England; | N Participants: Control: | 444 |
CBT for health anxiety (CBT-HA), 5-10 sessions with additional booster sessions allowed, compared to standard care. Intervention: 219 Control: 225 |
HAI, EQ-5D; | Health and social care | 24 months |
| Hospitals (multi-centre) | Age in years (mean, SD): | Intervention: 50·3 (13·6); Control: 47·0 (13·4) | £ (2008-09 financial year) | |||||||
| Sex (% female): | Intervention: 52%; Control: 55 | |||||||||
| Ethnicity (% white): | Intervention: 80; Control: 76 | |||||||||
| van der Aa et al. 2017 [96*] | Vision impairment | ✓ | ✓ | Netherlands and Belgium; | N Participants: | 265 |
Stepped care (step 1 watchful waiting, 2 guided self-help course based on CBT, 3 problem solving treatment, 4 referral to GP) compared to usual care. Intervention: 131 Control: 134 |
HADS-A, CES-D, EQ-5D-3L (Dutch tariff); | Healthcare and societal | 24mths |
| Outpatient clinics | Age in years (mean, SD): | Intervention: 72.4 (12.5); Control: 74.9 (11.9) | Euros (2013) | |||||||
| Sex (% female): | Intervention: 69%; Control: 70 | |||||||||
| Ethnicity (% white): | Not given |