Study description |
Links to references |
Setting (country) |
Australia: Baker 1991; Kimmel 2016; Miller 2006; Moseley 2009; Oldmeadow 2006; Sherrington 1997; Sherrington 2003; Sherrington 2004; Sherrington 2020 Canada: Langford 2015 Denmark: Kronborg 2017; Lauridsen 2002
Finland: Karumo 1977; Salpakoski 2015 Germany: Hauer 2002 Greece: Stasi 2019 Italy: Monticone 2018 Japan: Ohoka 2015 Netherlands: Pol 2019; Van Ooijen 2016 Norway: Sylliaas 2011; Sylliaas 2012; Taraldsen 2019 Russia:Gorodetskyi 2007 South Korea:Oh 2020 Switzerland:Bischoff‐Ferrari 2010 Taiwan:Tsauo 2005 Thailand: Suwanpasu 2014 United Kingdom: Braid 2008; Graham 1968; Lamb 2002; Mitchell 2001; Williams 2016 USA: Binder 2004; Latham 2014; Mangione 2005; Mangione 2010; Orwig 2011; Resnick 2007; Magaziner 2019
|
Setting |
Started study in‐hospital and transitioned to community during study a) Majority of intervention in hospital:Braid 2008; Lamb 2002; Miller 2006; Monticone 2018; Moseley 2009; Stasi 2019 a) Majority of intervention in post‐hospital setting:Bischoff‐Ferrari 2010; Langford 2015; Stasi 2019 In‐hospital(orthopedic ward):Gorodetskyi 2007; Karumo 1977; Kimmel 2016; Kronborg 2017; Lamb 2002; Miller 2006; Oldmeadow 2006 In‐hospital (rehabilitation ward):Baker 1991; Braid 2008; Lauridsen 2002; Mitchell 2001; Monticone 2018; Moseley 2009; Oh 2020; Ohoka 2015; Sherrington 2003; Van Ooijen 2016 In‐hospital (ward unclear):Graham 1968 (started 2 weeks postoperatively) Community:Binder 2004; Bischoff‐Ferrari 2010; Hauer 2002; Langford 2015; Latham 2014; Magaziner 2019; Mangione 2005; Mangione 2010; Orwig 2011; Pol 2019; Resnick 2007; Salpakoski 2015; Sherrington 1997; Sherrington 2004; Sherrington 2020; Stasi 2019; Sylliaas 2011; Sylliaas 2012; Taraldsen 2019; Tsauo 2005; Williams 2016 Unclear:Suwanpasu 2014
|
Participants |
Trials in which all participants were women |
Baker 1991; Hauer 2002; Lamb 2002; Lauridsen 2002; Ohoka 2015; Orwig 2011; Resnick 2007
|
Trials in which mean age was over 80 years |
Baker 1991; Binder 2004; Bischoff‐Ferrari 2010; Braid 2008; Hauer 2002; Kimmel 2016; Lamb 2002; Langford 2015; Lauridsen 2002; Magaziner 2019; Mangione 2010; Miller 2006; Mitchell 2001; Moseley 2009; Ohoka 2015; Orwig 2011; Pol 2019; Resnick 2007; Salpakoski 2015; Sherrington 2003; Sylliaas 2011; Sylliaas 2012; Taraldsen 2019; Van Ooijen 2016
|
Trials excluding participants with cognitive impairment (either defined as an exclusion criterion or implied by the stated requirement to be able to give informed consent, to follow instructions, or both) |
Binder 2004; Bischoff‐Ferrari 2010; Braid 2008; Hauer 2002; Kronborg 2017; Lamb 2002; Langford 2015; Latham 2014; Mangione 2005; Mangione 2010; Miller 2006; Mitchell 2001; Monticone 2018; Moseley 2009; Oh 2020; Orwig 2011; Pol 2019; Resnick 2007; Salpakoski 2015; Sherrington 1997; Sherrington 2003; Sherrington 2004; Sherrington 2020; Sylliaas 2011; Sylliaas 2012; Tsauo 2005; Van Ooijen 2016; Williams 2016
|
Interventions |
Comparisons |
In‐hospital: Usual physiotherapy: Baker 1991; Graham 1968; Karumo 1977; Kimmel 2016; Kronborg 2017; Lauridsen 2002; Miller 2006; Mitchell 2001; Monticone 2018; Moseley 2009; Oh 2020; Ohoka 2015; Oldmeadow 2006; Sherrington 2003; Suwanpasu 2014; Van Ooijen 2016 Placebo electrical stimulation: Braid 2008; Gorodetskyi 2007; Lamb 2002 Post‐hospital: Exercise programme: Binder 2004; Bischoff‐Ferrari 2010; Hauer 2002; Langford 2015; Latham 2014; Magaziner 2019; Mangione 2005; Orwig 2011; Resnick 2007; Salpakoski 2015; Sherrington 1997; Sherrington 2004; Sherrington 2020; Stasi 2019; Sylliaas 2011; Sylliaas 2012; Taraldsen 2019; Tsauo 2005; Williams 2016 Electrical stimulation: Mangione 2010 Coaching based on cognitive behavioural therapy: Pol 2019
|
Intervention. Type of exercises according to ProFaNE categorisation, or electrical stimulation |
Gait, balance and functional training: Baker 1991; Binder 2004; Bischoff‐Ferrari 2010; Graham 1968; Hauer 2002; Karumo 1977; Kimmel 2016; Latham 2014; Lauridsen 2002; Mitchell 2001; Monticone 2018; Moseley 2009; Oh 2020; Ohoka 2015; Oldmeadow 2006; Salpakoski 2015; Sherrington 1997; Sherrington 2003; Sherrington 2004*; Sherrington 2020;Taraldsen 2019; Tsauo 2005; Van Ooijen 2016; Williams 2016 Strength / resistance training: Binder 2004; Hauer 2002; Kronborg 2017; Magaziner 2019; Mangione 2005; Mangione 2010; Miller 2006; Mitchell 2001; Orwig 2011; Resnick 2007*; Stasi 2019; Sylliaas 2011; Sylliaas 2012 Flexibility: no studies Three dimensional (3D) exercise: no studies General physical activity: no studies Endurance: Magaziner 2019; Mangione 2005; Orwig 2011; Resnick 2007* Other type of intervention: Langford 2015; Orwig 2011; Pol 2019; Resnick 2007; Sherrington 2004*; Suwanpasu 2014; Williams 2016 Electrical stimulation: Braid 2008; Gorodetskyi 2007; Lamb 2002
|
Personnel delivering intervention in post‐hospital setting |
Expert delivering intervention: Binder 2004; Bischoff‐Ferrari 2010; Langford 2015; Latham 2014; Magaziner 2019; Mangione 2005; Mangione 2010; Pol 2019; Salpakoski 2015; Sherrington 1997; Sherrington 2004; Sherrington 2020; Stasi 2019; Sylliaas 2011; Sylliaas 2012; Taraldsen 2019; Tsauo 2005; Williams 2016 No expert delivering intervention: Orwig 2011; Resnick 2007; Suwanpasu 2014 Unclear: Hauer 2002
|
* = multi‐group trial appearing in more than one category |