Skip to main content
. 2022 Sep 7;2022(9):CD001704. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD001704.pub5
Study description Links to references
Setting (country) Australia: Baker 1991; Kimmel 2016; Miller 2006; Moseley 2009; Oldmeadow 2006; Sherrington 1997; Sherrington 2003; Sherrington 2004; Sherrington 2020
Canada: Langford 2015
Denmark: Kronborg 2017; Lauridsen 2002Finland: Karumo 1977; Salpakoski 2015
Germany: Hauer 2002
Greece: Stasi 2019
Italy: Monticone 2018
Japan: Ohoka 2015
Netherlands: Pol 2019; Van Ooijen 2016
Norway: Sylliaas 2011; Sylliaas 2012; Taraldsen 2019
Russia:Gorodetskyi 2007
South Korea:Oh 2020
Switzerland:Bischoff‐Ferrari 2010
Taiwan:Tsauo 2005
Thailand: Suwanpasu 2014
United Kingdom: Braid 2008; Graham 1968; Lamb 2002; Mitchell 2001; Williams 2016
USA: Binder 2004; Latham 2014; Mangione 2005; Mangione 2010; Orwig 2011; Resnick 2007; Magaziner 2019
Setting Started study in‐hospital and transitioned to community during study
a) Majority of intervention in hospital:Braid 2008; Lamb 2002; Miller 2006; Monticone 2018; Moseley 2009; Stasi 2019
a) Majority of intervention in post‐hospital setting:Bischoff‐Ferrari 2010; Langford 2015; Stasi 2019
In‐hospital(orthopedic ward):Gorodetskyi 2007; Karumo 1977; Kimmel 2016; Kronborg 2017; Lamb 2002; Miller 2006; Oldmeadow 2006
In‐hospital (rehabilitation ward):Baker 1991; Braid 2008; Lauridsen 2002; Mitchell 2001; Monticone 2018; Moseley 2009; Oh 2020Ohoka 2015; Sherrington 2003; Van Ooijen 2016
In‐hospital (ward unclear):Graham 1968 (started 2 weeks postoperatively)
Community:Binder 2004; Bischoff‐Ferrari 2010; Hauer 2002; Langford 2015; Latham 2014; Magaziner 2019; Mangione 2005; Mangione 2010; Orwig 2011; Pol 2019; Resnick 2007; Salpakoski 2015; Sherrington 1997; Sherrington 2004; Sherrington 2020; Stasi 2019; Sylliaas 2011; Sylliaas 2012; Taraldsen 2019; Tsauo 2005; Williams 2016
Unclear:Suwanpasu 2014
Participants
Trials in which all participants were women Baker 1991; Hauer 2002; Lamb 2002; Lauridsen 2002; Ohoka 2015; Orwig 2011; Resnick 2007
Trials in which mean age was over 80 years Baker 1991; Binder 2004; Bischoff‐Ferrari 2010; Braid 2008; Hauer 2002; Kimmel 2016; Lamb 2002; Langford 2015; Lauridsen 2002; Magaziner 2019; Mangione 2010; Miller 2006; Mitchell 2001; Moseley 2009; Ohoka 2015; Orwig 2011; Pol 2019; Resnick 2007; Salpakoski 2015; Sherrington 2003; Sylliaas 2011; Sylliaas 2012; Taraldsen 2019; Van Ooijen 2016
Trials excluding participants with cognitive impairment (either defined as an exclusion criterion or implied by the stated requirement to be able to give informed consent, to follow instructions, or both) Binder 2004; Bischoff‐Ferrari 2010; Braid 2008; Hauer 2002; Kronborg 2017; Lamb 2002; Langford 2015; Latham 2014; Mangione 2005; Mangione 2010; Miller 2006; Mitchell 2001; Monticone 2018; Moseley 2009; Oh 2020Orwig 2011; Pol 2019; Resnick 2007; Salpakoski 2015; Sherrington 1997; Sherrington 2003; Sherrington 2004; Sherrington 2020; Sylliaas 2011; Sylliaas 2012; Tsauo 2005; Van Ooijen 2016; Williams 2016
Interventions
Comparisons In‐hospital:
Usual physiotherapy: Baker 1991; Graham 1968; Karumo 1977; Kimmel 2016; Kronborg 2017; Lauridsen 2002; Miller 2006; Mitchell 2001; Monticone 2018; Moseley 2009; Oh 2020Ohoka 2015; Oldmeadow 2006; Sherrington 2003; Suwanpasu 2014; Van Ooijen 2016
Placebo electrical stimulation: Braid 2008; Gorodetskyi 2007; Lamb 2002
Post‐hospital:
Exercise programme: Binder 2004; Bischoff‐Ferrari 2010; Hauer 2002; Langford 2015; Latham 2014; Magaziner 2019; Mangione 2005; Orwig 2011; Resnick 2007; Salpakoski 2015; Sherrington 1997; Sherrington 2004; Sherrington 2020; Stasi 2019; Sylliaas 2011; Sylliaas 2012; Taraldsen 2019; Tsauo 2005; Williams 2016
Electrical stimulation: Mangione 2010
Coaching based on cognitive behavioural therapy: Pol 2019
 
Intervention. Type of exercises according to ProFaNE categorisation, or electrical stimulation Gait, balance and functional training: Baker 1991; Binder 2004; Bischoff‐Ferrari 2010; Graham 1968; Hauer 2002; Karumo 1977; Kimmel 2016; Latham 2014; Lauridsen 2002; Mitchell 2001; Monticone 2018; Moseley 2009Oh 2020Ohoka 2015; Oldmeadow 2006; Salpakoski 2015; Sherrington 1997; Sherrington 2003; Sherrington 2004*; Sherrington 2020;Taraldsen 2019; Tsauo 2005; Van Ooijen 2016; Williams 2016
Strength / resistance training: Binder 2004; Hauer 2002; Kronborg 2017; Magaziner 2019; Mangione 2005; Mangione 2010; Miller 2006; Mitchell 2001; Orwig 2011; Resnick 2007*; Stasi 2019; Sylliaas 2011; Sylliaas 2012
Flexibility: no studies
Three dimensional (3D) exercise: no studies
General physical activity: no studies
Endurance: Magaziner 2019; Mangione 2005; Orwig 2011; Resnick 2007*
Other type of intervention: Langford 2015; Orwig 2011; Pol 2019; Resnick 2007; Sherrington 2004*; Suwanpasu 2014; Williams 2016
Electrical stimulation: Braid 2008; Gorodetskyi 2007; Lamb 2002
Personnel delivering intervention in post‐hospital setting Expert delivering intervention: Binder 2004; Bischoff‐Ferrari 2010; Langford 2015; Latham 2014; Magaziner 2019; Mangione 2005; Mangione 2010; Pol 2019; Salpakoski 2015; Sherrington 1997; Sherrington 2004; Sherrington 2020; Stasi 2019; Sylliaas 2011; Sylliaas 2012; Taraldsen 2019; Tsauo 2005; Williams 2016
No expert delivering intervention: Orwig 2011; Resnick 2007; Suwanpasu 2014
Unclear: Hauer 2002
* = multi‐group trial appearing in more than one category