Skip to main content
. 2022 Sep 7;2022(9):CD001704. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD001704.pub5
Study ID Adherence was measured Adherence data were reported Measurement of adherence Reported adherence results
Baker 1991 No No
Binder 2004 Yes Yes Adherence to exercise programme, measured as the percentage of 72 sessions performed Intervention group: mean (SD) attendance (/72 sessions) = 87% (24%); mean (SD) number of exercise session per week 2.3 (0.2)
Control group: control participants who completed exercise log data (n = 32, 74%). Of these, the percentage of the 72 sessions performed was mean (SD) 131% (62%)
(NB: participants in control were advised to perform at least 3 times per week but not prohibited from performing more exercises and the mean compliance reported in control group indicated some participants performed more than 3 times per week)
Bischoff‐Ferrari 2010 Yes Yes Adherence to exercise programme Intervention group: 69% of participants reached 12‐month visit or telephone call and performed the home programme at least once a week
Braid 2008 No No
Gorodetskyi 2007 No No
Graham 1968 No No
Hauer 2002 Yes Yes Adherence to exercise programme Intervention group: mean (SD) [range] adherence to exercise = 93.1% (13.5%) [55% to 100%]
Control group: mean (SD) [range] adherence to placebo activities = 96.7 % (6.1%) [83% to 100%]
Karumo 1977 No No
Kimmel 2016 No No
Kronborg 2017 Yes Yes Adherence to exercise programme Intervention group: 80% of participants completed all strength training sessions
Lamb 2002 No No
Langford 2015 Yes No
Latham 2014 Yes Yes Attendance Intervention group: attendance across 26 weeks = 70%
Lauridsen 2002 Yes Yes Adherence to exercise programme Intervention group: average hours of training = 6.4 hours; average number of days of training = 14 days; average number of hours per day = 0.5 hours.
Prescribed physical therapy: 6 hours + non‐supervised training for other 4 days
Control group: average hours of training = 4 hours; average number of days of training = 17 days; average number of hours per day = 0.2 hours
Prescribed physical therapy: approximately 2 hours (NB: did not clearly state if there is non‐supervised training)
Magaziner 2019 Yes Yes Adherence to exercise programme Intervention group: 72.4% participants completed ≥ 80% expected intervention visits; mean (SD) percentage of expected intervention visits completed per participant = 78.3% (27.6%)
Control group: 81% participants completed ≥ 80% expected intervention visits; mean (SD) percentage of expected intervention visits completed per participant = 87.0% (14.3%)
Mangione 2005 Yes Yes Attendance Mean attendance in exercise training = 98%
Mangione 2010 Yes Yes Attendance Intervention group: attendance = 99% (number of sessions completed divided by possible number of sessions = 237/240 sessions).
Control group attendance = 99% (178/180 sessions)
Miller 2006 Yes Yes Attendance Adherence to the 12 weeks of resistance training = 86%
Mitchell 2001 Yes Yes Adherence to exercise programme Intervention group: median (range) number of training sessions completed at the six‐week assessment = 11 (10 to 12)
Monticone 2018 Yes No
Moseley 2009 Yes Yes Adherence to exercise programme Higher dose weight‐bearing exercise group: median (interquartile range (IQR)) total exercise time during the in‐hospital phase = 543 (463) minutes (min); median (IQR) number of times visited by physiotherapist during the community phase = 8 (4); median (IQR) reported walking time: 517 min (1125)).
Lower dose weight‐bearing exercise group: median (IQR) total exercise time during the in‐hospital phase = 363 (318) min; median (IQR) number of times visited by physiotherapist during the community phase = 4 (1)
Oh 2020 No No
Ohoka 2015 No No
Oldmeadow 2006 No No
Orwig 2011 Yes Yes Adherence to exercise programme Intervention group: mean number of visits = 36.2
Pol 2019 Yes Yes Attendance of the 20 scheduled exercise sessions Intervention group: 49 of the 70 participants completed the exercise programmes
Median number of sessions: 20
Median number of exercises per visits: 5
Resnick 2007 Yes Yes Adherence to exercise programme Combined two exercise groups: mean (SD) exercise time in hours per week at 12 month = 3.22 (3.87)
Control group: mean (SD) exercise time in hours per week at 12 month = 0.92 (1.45)
NB. Prescribed duration of training was not clear
Salpakoski 2015 Yes Yes Adherence to exercise programme Interevention group: proportion of classes attended (amount of performed exercises over expected number of exercises) during the first 6 months, strengthening = 61%, stretching = 53%, balance = 65%, functional exercises = 69%.
All but 1 participant attended the first face‐to‐face physical activity counselling session.
Responded to phone contact: first contact = 90%, second contact = 88%, third contact = 83%.
Control group: did not follow for compliance with the home exercises
Sherrington 1997 Yes Yes Adherence to exercise programme Mean (SD) [range] number of days of exercise determined from the exercise diaries = 24.7 (3.8) [18 to 30]
Prescribed number of days of exercise: 30 days
Mean (SD) [range] number of repetitions completed = 737 (664) [154 to 2450]. Median (IQR) number of repetitions = 480 (405 to 692)
Sherrington 2003 No No
Sherrington 2004 No No
Sherrington 2020 No No
Stasi 2019 No No
Suwanpasu 2014 No No
Sylliaas 2011 No No
Sylliaas 2012 No No
Taraldsen 2019 Yes Yes Attendance to occupational therapy sessions Inpatient period: median (IQR) of in‐hospital number of sessions: 4 (2 to 5) for usual care, 4 (2 to 6) for cognitive behavioural therapy (CBT)‐based occupational therapy, 2.5 (1 to 5) for CBT‐based occupational therapy with sensor monitoring
At home: 2 (0 to 4) for CBT‐based occupational therapy and 4 (2 to 4) for CBT‐based occupational therapy with sensor monitoring
Duration of session (minutes): 41 (0 to 60) for CBT‐based occupational therapy, 45 (38.5 to 60) for CBT‐based occupational therapy with sensor monitoring
Tsauo 2005 No No
Van Ooijen 2016 Yes Yes Attendance Adaptability treadmill training group: median (minimum to maximum) number of training sessions on treadmill: 11 (8 to 15); number of sessions of usual therapy = 13 (7 to 18).
Conventional treadmill training group: median (minimum to maximum) number of training sessions on treadmill:12 (7 to 14); number of sessions of usual therapy = 12 (7 to 15).
Usual physical therapy: median (minimum to maximum) number of sessions = 27 (16 to 31)
Williams 2016 Yes Yes Adherence to exercise programme Number of participants who received 6 sessions = 13; average number of sessions delivered to the intervention participants = 5