Study ID | Adherence was measured | Adherence data were reported | Measurement of adherence | Reported adherence results |
Baker 1991 | No | No | ‐ | ‐ |
Binder 2004 | Yes | Yes | Adherence to exercise programme, measured as the percentage of 72 sessions performed | Intervention group: mean (SD) attendance (/72 sessions) = 87% (24%); mean (SD) number of exercise session per week 2.3 (0.2) Control group: control participants who completed exercise log data (n = 32, 74%). Of these, the percentage of the 72 sessions performed was mean (SD) 131% (62%) (NB: participants in control were advised to perform at least 3 times per week but not prohibited from performing more exercises and the mean compliance reported in control group indicated some participants performed more than 3 times per week) |
Bischoff‐Ferrari 2010 | Yes | Yes | Adherence to exercise programme | Intervention group: 69% of participants reached 12‐month visit or telephone call and performed the home programme at least once a week |
Braid 2008 | No | No | ‐ | ‐ |
Gorodetskyi 2007 | No | No | ‐ | ‐ |
Graham 1968 | No | No | ‐ | ‐ |
Hauer 2002 | Yes | Yes | Adherence to exercise programme | Intervention group: mean (SD) [range] adherence to exercise = 93.1% (13.5%) [55% to 100%] Control group: mean (SD) [range] adherence to placebo activities = 96.7 % (6.1%) [83% to 100%] |
Karumo 1977 | No | No | ‐ | ‐ |
Kimmel 2016 | No | No | ‐ | ‐ |
Kronborg 2017 | Yes | Yes | Adherence to exercise programme | Intervention group: 80% of participants completed all strength training sessions |
Lamb 2002 | No | No | ‐ | ‐ |
Langford 2015 | Yes | No | ‐ | ‐ |
Latham 2014 | Yes | Yes | Attendance | Intervention group: attendance across 26 weeks = 70% |
Lauridsen 2002 | Yes | Yes | Adherence to exercise programme | Intervention group: average hours of training = 6.4 hours; average number of days of training = 14 days; average number of hours per day = 0.5 hours. Prescribed physical therapy: 6 hours + non‐supervised training for other 4 days Control group: average hours of training = 4 hours; average number of days of training = 17 days; average number of hours per day = 0.2 hours Prescribed physical therapy: approximately 2 hours (NB: did not clearly state if there is non‐supervised training) |
Magaziner 2019 | Yes | Yes | Adherence to exercise programme | Intervention group: 72.4% participants completed ≥ 80% expected intervention visits; mean (SD) percentage of expected intervention visits completed per participant = 78.3% (27.6%) Control group: 81% participants completed ≥ 80% expected intervention visits; mean (SD) percentage of expected intervention visits completed per participant = 87.0% (14.3%) |
Mangione 2005 | Yes | Yes | Attendance | Mean attendance in exercise training = 98% |
Mangione 2010 | Yes | Yes | Attendance | Intervention group: attendance = 99% (number of sessions completed divided by possible number of sessions = 237/240 sessions). Control group attendance = 99% (178/180 sessions) |
Miller 2006 | Yes | Yes | Attendance | Adherence to the 12 weeks of resistance training = 86% |
Mitchell 2001 | Yes | Yes | Adherence to exercise programme | Intervention group: median (range) number of training sessions completed at the six‐week assessment = 11 (10 to 12) |
Monticone 2018 | Yes | No | ‐ | ‐ |
Moseley 2009 | Yes | Yes | Adherence to exercise programme | Higher dose weight‐bearing exercise group: median (interquartile range (IQR)) total exercise time during the in‐hospital phase = 543 (463) minutes (min); median (IQR) number of times visited by physiotherapist during the community phase = 8 (4); median (IQR) reported walking time: 517 min (1125)). Lower dose weight‐bearing exercise group: median (IQR) total exercise time during the in‐hospital phase = 363 (318) min; median (IQR) number of times visited by physiotherapist during the community phase = 4 (1) |
Oh 2020 | No | No | ‐ | ‐ |
Ohoka 2015 | No | No | ‐ | ‐ |
Oldmeadow 2006 | No | No | ‐ | ‐ |
Orwig 2011 | Yes | Yes | Adherence to exercise programme | Intervention group: mean number of visits = 36.2 |
Pol 2019 | Yes | Yes | Attendance of the 20 scheduled exercise sessions | Intervention group: 49 of the 70 participants completed the exercise programmes Median number of sessions: 20 Median number of exercises per visits: 5 |
Resnick 2007 | Yes | Yes | Adherence to exercise programme | Combined two exercise groups: mean (SD) exercise time in hours per week at 12 month = 3.22 (3.87) Control group: mean (SD) exercise time in hours per week at 12 month = 0.92 (1.45) NB. Prescribed duration of training was not clear |
Salpakoski 2015 | Yes | Yes | Adherence to exercise programme | Interevention group: proportion of classes attended (amount of performed exercises over expected number of exercises) during the first 6 months, strengthening = 61%, stretching = 53%, balance = 65%, functional exercises = 69%. All but 1 participant attended the first face‐to‐face physical activity counselling session. Responded to phone contact: first contact = 90%, second contact = 88%, third contact = 83%. Control group: did not follow for compliance with the home exercises |
Sherrington 1997 | Yes | Yes | Adherence to exercise programme | Mean (SD) [range] number of days of exercise determined from the exercise diaries = 24.7 (3.8) [18 to 30] Prescribed number of days of exercise: 30 days Mean (SD) [range] number of repetitions completed = 737 (664) [154 to 2450]. Median (IQR) number of repetitions = 480 (405 to 692) |
Sherrington 2003 | No | No | ‐ | ‐ |
Sherrington 2004 | No | No | ‐ | ‐ |
Sherrington 2020 | No | No | ‐ | ‐ |
Stasi 2019 | No | No | ‐ | ‐ |
Suwanpasu 2014 | No | No | ‐ | ‐ |
Sylliaas 2011 | No | No | ‐ | ‐ |
Sylliaas 2012 | No | No | ‐ | ‐ |
Taraldsen 2019 | Yes | Yes | Attendance to occupational therapy sessions | Inpatient period: median (IQR) of in‐hospital number of sessions: 4 (2 to 5) for usual care, 4 (2 to 6) for cognitive behavioural therapy (CBT)‐based occupational therapy, 2.5 (1 to 5) for CBT‐based occupational therapy with sensor monitoring At home: 2 (0 to 4) for CBT‐based occupational therapy and 4 (2 to 4) for CBT‐based occupational therapy with sensor monitoring Duration of session (minutes): 41 (0 to 60) for CBT‐based occupational therapy, 45 (38.5 to 60) for CBT‐based occupational therapy with sensor monitoring |
Tsauo 2005 | No | No | ‐ | ‐ |
Van Ooijen 2016 | Yes | Yes | Attendance | Adaptability treadmill training group: median (minimum to maximum) number of training sessions on treadmill: 11 (8 to 15); number of sessions of usual therapy = 13 (7 to 18). Conventional treadmill training group: median (minimum to maximum) number of training sessions on treadmill:12 (7 to 14); number of sessions of usual therapy = 12 (7 to 15). Usual physical therapy: median (minimum to maximum) number of sessions = 27 (16 to 31) |
Williams 2016 | Yes | Yes | Adherence to exercise programme | Number of participants who received 6 sessions = 13; average number of sessions delivered to the intervention participants = 5 |