Skip to main content
. 2022 Aug 25;16:957441. doi: 10.3389/fncir.2022.957441

TABLE 5.

Results of a linear mixed-effects model of Granger causality between the logarithm of movement speed (Speed) and the z-scored ΔF/F of cholinergic activity (ACh) with four fixed effects, namely the y-intercept, the Granger causality magnitude with two levels of direction, namely from the logarithm of movement speed to cholinergic activity (Speed → ACh) and from cholinergic activity to the logarithm of movement speed (ACh → Speed), lighting condition with two levels, namely light and darkness, and the interaction between direction in Granger causality and lighting condition.

Fixed effects coefficients
Name Estimate SE t-statistic DF P-value 95% CI
y-intercept 0.00635 0.00105 6.05 200 <0.0001 [0.00428 0.00842]
ACh –> Speed –0.00198 0.00105 –1.88 200 0.061 [–0.00406 9.48 × 10–05]
Darkness 0.00018 0.00061 0.29 200 0.773 [–0.00102 0.00137]
(ACh –> Speed)*Darkness –0.00065 0.00068 –0.96 200 0.338 [0.33829 –0.00199]

Model formula
yijmkl= β0+j=22β1jI[S]ij+m=22β2mI[D]im+j=22m=22β3jmI[S*D]ijm+b0kAk+b0lSl+ b1kjSkj+b1ljSlj+b2kmDkm+b2lmDlm+b3kjm(S*D)kjm+b3ljm(S*D)ljm+ εijmkl,
where index i corresponds to the # of observations, index j corresponds to the direction of Granger causality, index m corresponds to light or darkness, index k corresponds to the animal identity, and index l corresponds to the session identity. Ak represents the kth animal, Sl represents the lth session, I[S]ij is the dummy variable representing level j of direction in Granger causality, I[D]im is the dummy variable representing level m of the darkness type, b the random mixed effects, εijmkl the observation error, and yijmkl the response variable representing z-scored ΔF/F. Random effects and observation error are normally distributed around zero.
Model statistics
AIC: -1762.5 BIC: -1719.4 Log-likelihood: 894.26 Deviance: -1788.5

Random effects of the animal (n = 5) and sessions (n = 102, 55 “light” sessions and 47 “dark” sessions) on all fixed effects were included in addition to a random error term. Total number of observations: 204; Fixed effects coefficients: 4; Random effects coefficients: 428; Covariance parameters: 9. SE, standard error; DF, degree of freedom; CI, confidence interval.