Skip to main content
. 2022 Aug 29;14(3):223–235. doi: 10.1007/s12560-022-09530-3

Table 1.

Summary of global meta-analysis results for prevalence of hepatitis E virus in different water matrices divided by risk of bias

Water matrix Prevalence (%) [95%CI] 95% Prediction interval No of studies No of samples H
[95%CI]
§I2
[95%CI]
P heterogeneity
Untreated wastewater
 Overall 15.1 [9.4–21.8] [0–64.6] 40 4412 5.1 [4.7–5.6] 96.1 [95.4–96.8]  < 0.001
 Low risk of bias 9.7 [0.9–24.7] [0–75.1] 8 1886 6.1 [5.1–7.4] 97.3 [96.2–98.2]  < 0.001
 Process controlled 17.4 [7.8–29.6] [0–75.8] 16 2414 5.8 [5.1–6.6] 97 [96.1–97.7]  < 0.001
Treated wastewater
 Overall 3.8 [0–15.2] 0–63.7 11 388 3.4 [2.7–4.3] 91.5 [86.7–94.5]  < 0.001
 Low risk of bias 38.3 [0–100] NA 2 23 5.3 [3.2–8.7] 96.4 [90–98.7]  < 0.001
 Process controlled 1.1 [0–9.4] [0–48.5] 8 353 3.2 [2.4–4.2] 90 [82.8–94.2]  < 0.001
Surface water
 Overall 7.5 [2.4–14.5] [0–49] 20 1271 3.5 [3–4.1] 92 [89–94.2]  < 0.001
 Low risk of bias 2 [0.6–4.1] [0–23.9] 3 329 1 [1–3.1] 0 [0–89.6] 0.448
 Process controlled 8.5 [1.4–19.7] [0–62.9] 11 804 4.3 [3.6–5.2] 94.6 [92.1–96.3]  < 0.001
Drinking water
 Overall 4.7 [0–15.9] 0–59.9 10 998 4.1 [3.3–5] 94 [90.9–96]  < 0.001
 Process controlled 9.9 [0–42.9] [0–100] 4 778 6.5 [5–8.5] 97.6 [95.9–98.6]  < 0.001
Groundwater
 Overall 8.3 [0–32.4] NA 1 12 NA NA 1
Others
 Overall 6 [0–33.2] 0–100 5 179 4.1 [3–5.6] 94.1 [89.1–96.8]  < 0.001
 Low risk of bias 0 [0–7] NA 1 24 NA NA 1
 Process controlled 0 [0–5.1] NA 2 35 1 NA 0 NA 0.798

95% CI 95% confidence interval; NA not applicable

H is a measure of the extent of heterogeneity; a value of H > 1 indicates a potential heterogeneity of the prevalence of hepatitis E virus

§I2 describes the proportion of total variation in prevalence of hepatitis E virus that is due to heterogeneity; a value > 50% indicates the presence of heterogeneity