Skip to main content
. 2022 Sep 9;22:1141. doi: 10.1186/s12913-022-08512-2

Table 4.

Summary of Studies included in the Systematic Review, N = 12

Author & year Country& Setting Study methods Study population mHealth intervention platforms Barriers Facilitators
Jahangir et al. [42]

Bangladesh

Community-based

Rural

Qualitative

In-depth interviews

Health providers

Sexual health services

SMS or text-messaging

- Low levels of technological and health literacy.

-Not possible to provide diagnoses of STIs over the phone

-Not possible to provide physical examination on phone.

-Emotional burden for receiving too many calls and time.

-mHealth quite good for providing counselling.

-Gets quick information to clients

- Easy referral services to clinics

- Time and cost management for traveling to health facilities.

- Effective in time managemt for providing services.

-Culturally appropriate in providing SRH information.

-Effective in providing greater access to health information for women regarding STIs.

-Provides an innovative platform to bridging the health communication gaps in sexual health

Peprah et al. [46]

Ghana

Rural

Qualitative

In-depth interviews

Healthcare providers

Sexual and reproductive services

Phone call

-Language barrier.

-Illiteracy or low educational level of recipients.

- Lack of trust.

-Mobile network connectivity challenges.

mHealth saves waiting hours’ time.

-Delivering services via mHealth technology saves time.

-mHealth reduces workload.

-mHealth able to contact many clients at a time for healthcare.

Braun et al. [37]

Tanzania

Rural

Qualitative

IDIs

Community health workers

Family planning (FP) services

text messaging

-Low technological skills.

-Limited power for battery charging

-Cost of mobile phone.

- Timelier

- More convenient contacting clients from remote locations.

-Ease of use of technology

confidential information and care.

-Increased method choice.

-Improved privacy, confidentiality and trust with clients.

Dev et al. [38]

Kenya

Rural

Qualitative

In-depth interviews

Healthcare providers (nurses)

Contraception services

Mobile phone call

- Limited technological literacy

- Workload for receiving calls from clients.

-Emotional stress.

-Helps deliver the appropriate and detailed SRH information.

-Saves time for providing education or counselling.

-Improves client provider interactions relationship.

- Allows discuss confidential issues with women on contraceptives privately with women to make better decisions

-Maximizes time or saves providers time in providing counselling process.

Logie et al. [44]

Nigeria

Keyna

Rural

Mixed method

Qualitive In-depth interviews (IDIs)

Healthcare providers

Sexual and reproductive health services

Mobile phone call

-Does not work if a client/ person doesn’t have a phone.

-Lack of regular internet access.

-Lack of technological literacy of using mobile apps.

- Cost of mobile phones

-Able to target specific health information to clients in rural areas based on health demographics.

-Able to provide access to SRH information for underserved group.

- Easier to provide mHealth apps SRH confidentially for young people in remote areas.

-Easy for healthcare providers to constantly remind or follow up on clients.

Ibembe [41]

Kenya

Health facility

Rural

Qualitative

IDIs

Healthcare professionals

Reproductive health services

Mobile phone call

-Lack of technological expertise.

-Poor network connectivity.

-Cost of phone credit or airtime.

-Lack of motivation.

-Lack of technological literacy and skills.

- Not owning a cell phone.

-Easy consultation.

- Addressing challenges distance between health providers and users.

- Trust and confidentiality are built. Around health providers and users.

-Quality and timely health decision making.

Ong et al. [45]

Cambodia

Rural/urban

Qualitative

Focus group discussions (FGDs) IDIs

Community health workers

Sexual and reproductive health/HIV

Text messaging

Voice messaging

-Lack of financial support for service provision.

-Network connectivity interruptions.

- Able to provide information on HIV and STIs prevention issues.

- Able to link up with many clients with SRH services.

-Able to connect groups of clients.

-Able to help clients in making SRH decisions

-More efficient to deliver information directly and more frequently to a larger group via mobile phones.

Khatun et al. [43]

Bangladesh

Rural

Qualitative IDIs

Health services

Mobile phone call

-Technological human resource inadequacy.

-Healthcare personnel readiness to use mobile technology for SRH services.

-Lack of technological skills by some HCPs and young people.

- illiteracy barriers.

-Decrease in patient loads in rural healthcare centers.

-mHealth consultation saves time

- Enables health providers to provide quality health services.

-Culturally sensitive and technology friendly solution

Hirsch-Moverman et al. [40]

Lesotho

Rural

Qualitative

IDIs

Healthcare providers

Health facility & community -based

Health services/HIV text messaging

-Lack of technology infrastructure.

-Limited network connectivity

-Limited electricity connectivity.

-Community members influence of use of mobile phones for SRH services.

-Facilitates communication between patients’ providers.

-Ability to be able to follow-up patients frequently.

-mHealth communication messages strengthen the patient–provider bond.

-Ability to monitor patients over phone.

-Easily able to track and follow up patients.

Jennings et al. [29]

Kenya

Rural

Qualitative

FGDs/IDIs

Community health workers & nurses

Health facility-based

HIV services

Voice calls,

Text messaging

- Cost for airtime for maintenance of phones.

-Lack of technological by clients

- Protects the confidentiality of information.

- Convenient for follow

-Easy referral of clients to HCPs.

-Timelier notification f information

-Save time

-Reduces unnecessary visits.to health facilities

Hampshire et al. [39]

Ghana & Malawi

Peri-urban & rural

Qualitative

IDIs

Health workers

Community-based

Contraception/family planning/HIV prevention education.

Text messaging

phone calls

Voice messaging

-Not having personal mobile phones.

-Temporary mobile phone breakdown can be problematic.

-Poor or unreliable network

- Mobile phone credit or airtime.

-Limited sources to buy credit

Emotional burden for receiving calls at night.

--Mobile phones help in emergencies, staff making emergency calls.

-Helps in communicating with patients’ colleagues, obtaining clinical advice.

Chang et al. [39]

Uganda

Rural

Qualitative

IDIs

Peer health workers

HIV services

Text messaging

Voice messaging

-Phone maintenance cost

-Lack of power/electricity to charge phones.

-Mobile phones theft .

-Facilitates task shifting.

Time saving.

-Facilitates exchange of information or communication between HCPs and patients and HCPs.

-Improved peer health workers morale.