TABLE 1.
A comparative point of view for different blood pressure (BP) monitoring methods in multi-scenes.
Applicable scene: scene 1 (A): lay down, scene 2 (B): sit, scene 3 (C): walk around, scene 4 (D): sports, scene 5 (E): special scene; Monitoring method: I: continuous monitoring, II: single measurement, III: interval measurement, take measurements every once in a while; | |||||||||
Method | Applicable scene | Monitoring method | Measuring position | Cuff | Cost | Instrument accuracy | Technology maturity degree | Advantages | Disadvantages |
Auscultatory (33–35) | B, C, D | II, III | Bicep | Yes | Low | Gold standard for standard control | Mature | Commonly and widely used by the medical doctors | 1. User dependent, supervision form professional is necessary. 2. More than 3 min time delay between successive measurements. |
Oscillometry | A, B, C, D | II, III | Bicep, Wrist | Yes | Medium | Medical Level | Arm-cuff oscillographic method is mature; Wrist-cuff systems needs more clinical validation |
Most widely used method in many scenes, results are considered to be medical level | 1. Uncomfortable, noisy for long time monitoring. 2. Cuff dependent. |
Applanation tonometry (36–43) | A | I | Wrist | No | High | Medical Level | Mature, sensor structures are improving | Used for continuous blood pressure monitoring in Scene 1 only under supervision | 1. Strict conditions for sensor location or structure and monitoring environment. 2. Supervision form professional is necessary. |
Volume clamp method (44) | A | I | Wrist, Finger | Yes | High | Medical Level | Mature, control algorithms are improving | Instantaneous, continuous measurement in Scene 1 in hospitals | Complex and precise control systems are required. |
PWV/PTT/PAT | A, B, C, D, E | I, II, III | Proximal and distal pulse waveform | No | Low | Accuracy is controversial | Improving, one of the hot spots of current researches | Have the potential to be used in all the scenes mentioned in this article | Calibration is required, more clinical data is needed. |